Buccaneers Draft 2012

 

7. S Mark Barron D

Hmmm, Mark Barron and a 4th round pick…or Morris Claiborne? That shouldn’t have been a tough question, but it was for the Buccaneers, who seem to have gotten it wrong. I know the Buccaneers had Barron higher than Claiborne on their board, but that’s ridiculous. Claiborne is a better player at a position of higher value. I had Barron in the 20s on my board. I don’t believe any player at a “luxury” position (linebacker, safety, running back, interior offensive line) should go in the first round unless they are an exceptional talent, which is why I gave Barron a 1st/2nd round grade. He’s not Eric Berry and he certainly was not worth a pick in the top 10. It’s only worth noting that everyone and their dog agreed that there were 6 blue chip prospects in this draft class, so I really don’t like the Buccaneers moving out of the top 6 for just a 4th round pick. The 7th spot was the one no one wanted, but the Buccaneers took it willingly.

31. RB Doug Martin B+

Martin fits the range and fills a need, but the pick isn’t getting an A just because they moved up for him. I don’t believe in bad teams moving up unless it’s an unbelievable value. The Buccaneers have too many needs to be giving up picks like this and they have so many needs that there would definitely be a player they liked that fit the range and filled a need at their original spot.

58. OLB Lavonte David A

Linebacker was a huge need for the Buccaneers, maybe even their biggest need. Since the stat has been kept track of, no team missed more tackles ever than the Buccaneers did last season. David is also a very good value at the end of the 2nd, so I have no problem with them moving up in this case.

140. MLB Najee Goode B-

This is a slight reach in the 5th round, but it’s not like they didn’t need another linebacker.

174. CB Keith Tandy A

Finally the Buccaneers get their cornerback. They could have gotten one earlier if they didn’t trade up twice. Anyway, Tandy is a very, very good value here in the 6th. I thought he was one of the underrated gems of the cornerback position in this draft. This need is not filled coming out of the draft, but they can’t be expected to fill every need.

212. RB Michael Smith B

Another running back? Again, you can’t hate 7th round picks, but Smith didn’t make my top 250 so this is a slight reach.

233. FB Drake Dunsmore A

I like this value a lot here in the 7th round. Dunsmore could probably be their starting fullback this year after they lost Earnest Graham and he also provides some depth at tight end.

I gave this a C yesterday and then I looked it that C after doing the write ups and that seemed a little ridiculous. Yes, I think they missed up big time with their first pick and that’s the most important one. However, the rest of their draft was really nice. I think they got 3 new starters out of this draft and while they didn’t address arguably their biggest need at cornerback, they couldn’t be expected to address all of their needs and they did address 3 prominent ones (S, OLB, RB). They might not be the most important positions, but 3 starters isn’t too shabby.

They also did some nice things in the late rounds, especially with Keith Tandy and Drake Dunsmore. Dunsmore might even make it 4th starters if he emerges as the starting fullback, but, then again, it is just the fullback position. Tandy, meanwhile, will provide solid depth behind Eric Wright and Aqib Talib. Cornerback will probably be a primary need of their 2013 draft because Wright is overrated (and overpaid) and Talib will be a free agent.

Grade: B-

 

Jets Draft Grades 2012

 

 

16. 3-4 DE Quinton Coples A

I love the fit of Coples in New York. Rex Ryan has a good chance to get the most out of him and he can use him in a variety of different ways. He’ll probably play mostly 5-technique, where he’s an upgrade over Mike DeVito, who is a run stopper and nothing else, but he can play some outside linebacker as well as long as he rarely has to drop into coverage.

43. WR Stephen Hill A

This was a great steal. Stephen Hill is boom or bust, but you absolutely take a chance on this guy in the 2nd round given that he could be the best receiver in this draft class when all is said and done. He could take a while, but I love the value in the 2nd round. Also, side note, the Jets got a triple option receiver after Tebow had so much success with one in Denver. Something tells me he won’t be the punt protector at the end of the season.

77. MLB Demario Davis C-

This is a couple rounds too early for Davis, a workout wonder with mediocre tape, but he has upside both inside and outside in the Jets’ 3-4. Best case for them is that he could emerge as a pass rusher on the outside, but depth at middle linebacker was also needed seeing as Bart Scott might not be around much longer.

187. S Josh Bush B-

This is a reach and I didn’t have him in my top 250, but they at least filled a need and it’s a late round pick.

202. RB Terrance Ganaway A

The Jets needed a ground and pound back to go with Shonn Greene. Ganaway could actually see significant snaps as a rookie and he might surprise a lot of people. This guy reminds me of LeGarrette Blount.

203. G Robert Griffin B-

The Jets got Robert Griffin! Well, I guess they needed guard depth, but I had him outside of my top 250. Again, this is the 6th round so it’s not a big deal.

242. S Antonio Allen A

How did Allen fall this far in a bad safety class? Did everyone forget he was on the board? I had him as a top 5 safety.

244. WR Jordan White A

They don’t have a ton of receiver depth, so they could use another one. I had a 7th round grade on White so this makes a lot of sense.

The Jets took high upside, high risk players with their first 2 picks, but they did so with picks low enough to be good values according to my board. Coples could end up being a perennial Pro Bowler and Stephen Hill has upside beyond any other receiver in this draft class. Both also filled major needs. I would have liked to have seen them address the safety, running back, right tackle, or rush linebacker position in the 3rd round. Those needs were all more pressing than middle linebacker (where I think Davis ends up) and they didn’t address them early. They had solid late round selections that might end up filling two of this needs (running back and safety), but they also reached with a few late rounders. This was a solid draft, but not perfect.

Grade: B+