2019 NFL All-Breakout Team

Every year young players breakout and make the Pro-Bowl and even the All-Pro team for the first time. This list is the most likely player by position to do so in 2019. All players on this team are in their third year in the league or less and have never made a Pro-Bowl or All-Pro team.

Quarterback Baker Mayfield (Cleveland)

Drafted first overall in the 2018 NFL Draft by a previously winless Browns team, Baker Mayfield’s career got off to an underwhelming start. He led a week 3 comeback in relief of an injured Tyrod Taylor to give the Browns their first victory in almost two years, but then went 1-4 in his next 5 starts. Through week 8 he had completed just 58.3% of his passes for an average of 6.60 YPA, 8 touchdowns, and 6 interceptions. 

That changed when head coach Hue Jackson and offensive coordinator Todd Haley were fired before week 9. Mayfield flourished in new play caller Freddie Kitchens’ offense. He completed 68.4% of his passes for an average of 8.57 YPA, 19 touchdowns, and 8 interceptions and led the Browns to a 5-3 finish in 8 games without Jackson and Haley. Now with new #1 wide receiver Odell Beckham in the mix, Mayfield has sky high expectations for his second season in the league. He’s still inexperienced and a sophomore slump is still a possibility, but Mayfield is clearly a potential Pro-Bowler in 2019. 

Running Back Christian McCaffrey (Carolina)

It might seem strange to have Christian McCaffrey on a breakout players list, but he technically meets the requirements after getting snubbed for the Pro-Bowl in 2018, which knocks a very deserving Nick Chubb from this list. The 2017 8th overall pick, McCaffrey had a 219/1098/7 slash line as a runner and a 107/867/6 slash line as a receiver last season. His 5.01 YPC average was highest among running backs with at least 200 carries and he caught 86.3% of targets thrown his way without a single drop. Perhaps most impressively, McCaffrey played every single snap in 8 games and played 96.9% of the snaps through week 16, before resting in a meaningless week 17 game. If he has a similar season in 2019, hopefully he won’t be snubbed again. 

Wide receiver Cooper Kupp (LA Rams)

A third round pick in 2017, Kupp looked on his way to making his first Pro-Bowl last season, with 30 catches for 438 yards and 5 touchdowns through 5 games (96/1402/16 extrapolated over 16 games), but he suffered a knee injury week 6 and then ended up tearing his ACL a few weeks later, ending his season. The injury complicates things, but if he can return close to full strength, Kupp could easily have Pro-Bowl level production. 

One thing that may prevent him from that could be his own teammates, as Robert Woods and Brandin Cooks both topped 1000 yards in 2018. Kupp has been quarterback Jared Goff’s most reliable receiver over the past 2 seasons though, completing 68.0% of his 150 targets to Kupp for 1,435 yards, 11 touchdowns, and just 2 interceptions, a 117.5 QB rating. The Rams run three wide receiver sets so frequently that slot receiver is an every down position in this offense, so Kupp should get plenty of targets if he’s close to his old self.

Wide receiver Chris Godwin (Tampa Bay)

The second of three wide receivers selected in the third round in 2017 to make this team, Chris Godwin hasn’t had the opportunity yet to be an every down player in a deep receiving corps, but he’s still totalled 93 catches for 1,367 yards and 8 touchdowns in 32 career games, while averaging 1.91 yards per route run. Now with DeSean Jackson and Adam Humphries both gone, Godwin will have the opportunity to be an every down player, and will line up both outside and on the slot. He could easily top 1000+ yards receiving and make his first Pro-Bowl. 

Wide receiver Kenny Golladay (Detroit)

Also a 3rd round pick in 2017, Golladay was only a part-time player as a rookie, but still managed a 28/477/3 slash line, while averaging 1.66 yards per route run and 9.94 yards per target. In his second season in the league in 2018, Golladay took on a larger role and took a step forward, putting up a 70/1063/5 slash line, while averaging 1.87 yards per route run and 8.93 yards per target. Golladay is the Lions’ #1 wide receiver with Golden Tate gone and he could easily take another step forward in his third season in the league.

Tight end OJ Howard (Tampa Bay)

OJ Howard easily could have made the Pro-Bowl last season if he hadn’t gotten hurt, as his 34/565/5 slash line in 10 games extrapolates to a 54/904/8 slash line across a full 16 game season. Also a strong run blocker, Howard was PFF’s 3rd ranked tight end when he went down for the season with an ankle injury week 11 and his 2.26 yards per route run average also ranked 3rd in the NFL among tight ends. Assuming he stays healthy, the 2017 19th overall pick could easily have a Pro-Bowl caliber season in 2019. Like his teammate Chris Godwin, Howard will benefit from the Buccaneers losing DeSean Jackson and Adam Humphries this off-season. 

Left tackle Dion Dawkins (Buffalo)

Dion Dawkins looked like a future Pro-Bowler as a rookie in 2017, as the second round pick was forced into action at left tackle when long-time starter Cordy Glenn got hurt and allowed just 3 sacks and 3 hits, while committing just 4 penalties, in 11 rookie year starts. Dawkins played well enough for the Bills to trade Glenn in the off-season, but Dawkins was not nearly as good in his second season in the league, allowing 7 sacks and 2 hits, while committing 13 penalties in 16 starts. Dawkins has the potential to bounce back in his third season in the league though and could still develop into a Pro-Bowl caliber player long-term.

Left guard Will Hernandez (NY Giants)

The 34th overall pick in 2018, Will Hernandez’s rookie year was overshadowed by Quenton Nelson, who went 6th overall and made the All-Pro team as a rookie, but Hernandez looks to have a bright future as well, after finishing 22nd among guards on PFF as a rookie. At 6-2 340 pounds, Hernandez was known for his run blocking coming out of college, but he also held up in pass protection as a rookie, allowing just 5 sacks and 3 hits, while committing only 2 penalties total. With the Giants getting rid of Odell Beckham this off-season, they’ll likely try to run the ball more in 2019 and Hernandez fits the hard nosed style of football they want to play. He could easily take a step forward and earn Pro-Bowl consideration in his second season in the league.

Center James Daniels (Chicago)

Daniels primarily makes this list for lack of a better option, but the 2018 2nd round pick was considered by many to be the top center prospect in his draft class. Daniels’ 10 rookie year starts came out of position at left guard, where he held up well in pass protection (0 sacks, 3 hits), but predictably struggled to get push in the run game. His 6-3 295 frame made him one of the smallest starting guards in the league, but now he’s moving back to his natural position of center, where his lack of size will be less of an issue. A second year breakout year is certainly within the realm of possibilities. 

Right guard Chris Lindstrom (Atlanta)

Lindstrom is the only rookie on this list and, like Daniels, largely makes this list of lack of a better option. Lindstrom was selected 14th overall by the Falcons and the former tackle was one of the best pass blocking guards in college football last season. Largely expected to be a week 1 starter, a Pro-Bowl appearance might be a little much to expect him as a rookie, but he could easily develop into that kind of player long-term. 

Right tackle Ryan Ramczyk (New Orleans)

Ramczyk could have easily made the Pro-Bowl in either of his first 2 seasons in the league, as he’s been responsible for just 7 sacks, 7 hits, and 9 penalties in 31 career starts, while finishing 9th and 6th respectively among offensive tackles on PFF. Right tackles don’t always get the Pro-Bowl consideration they deserve, but Ramczyk is arguably the best right tackle in the league and could easily get stronger Pro-Bowl consideration in his 3rd season in the league.

Interior Defender Vita Vea (Tampa Bay)

The 12th overall pick in the 2018 NFL Draft, Vea’s career got off to a rough start when he suffered a calf strain early in training camp that kept him out through week 4. Despite that, Vea had a solid rookie year overall. The 6-4 347 pounder isn’t just a big run stuffer, with 3 sacks and a 10.2% pressure rate as a rookie. He was especially good down the stretch, after he was completely past his injury, with a 12.8% pressure rate in his final 6 games. Vea also saw his snaps per game go up to 46.8 in his final 6 games, after averaging 30.3 snaps per game in his first 7 games. If he can avoid further injury, he could easily have a breakout second season in the league.

Interior Defender Da’Shawn Hand (Detroit)

Hand was just a 4th round pick in the 2018 NFL Draft, but he came with more upside than a typical fourth rounder. Once the top recruit in the country, Hand had an underwhelming collegiate career at the University of Alabama, but he showed off his athletic upside at the combine with a 4.83 40 at 6-4 297, which lead to the Lions taking a chance on him in the 4th round. So far, that chance seems to have paid off. Hand didn’t play a ton as a rookie, but he earned more playing time as the season went on, averaging 39.6 snaps per game in his final 9 games before suffering a season ending knee injury week 14, and he earned above average grades from PFF for both his run stuffing and pass rushing. 

Overall, he was PFF’s 13th ranked interior defender and he had 3 sacks and a 9.5% pressure rate on 263 pass rush snaps. It could be tough for him to see a significantly bigger role with the Lions adding Mike Daniels and Trey Flowers to what looks like a loaded defensive line, but if Hand continues developing it’ll be hard to keep him off the field and 40 snaps per game is plenty of time for him to disrupt offenses. More talent around him could allow him to have more easy shots at the quarterback.

Edge Defender Bradley Chubb (Denver)

It’s a bit of a surprise that Chubb didn’t make the Pro-Bowl as a rookie. Chubb had name recognition as the 5th overall pick in the draft and his 12 sacks were 14th most in the NFL. Chubb wasn’t quite as great as those sack numbers suggest, as much of his pass rush production came from having Von Miller disrupting the passer on the other side, and he finished just 50th among edge defenders on PFF, but Chubb also had a 12.5% pressure rate on his own and could easily take a step forward in his second season in the league. With Miller still lining up opposite him, Chubb has a good chance to break double digit sacks again, which could easily send him to his first Pro-Bowl. 

Edge Defender Carl Lawson (Cincinnati)

A 4th round pick in 2017, Lawson’s career got off to a promising start, when he had 8.5 sacks, 12 hits, and a 15.2% pressure rate as a rookie. Lawson only had 1 sack in 2018, but he added 7 hits and a 13.6% pressure rate in 7 games before going down for the season with a torn ACL. The injury definitely complicates his long-term progression, but Lawson looked like one of the best young edge rushers in the league before getting hurt and could easily pick up right where he left off. If he does, double digit sacks and a Pro-Bowl trip wouldn’t be a surprise from him in his third season in the league.

Linebacker Jayon Brown (Tennessee)

Just a 5th round pick in 2017, Brown struggled when forced into action as a rookie, finishing as PFF’s 76th ranked linebacker out of 99 eligible on 487 snaps. He made a big leap from year one to year two though and finished the 2018 season as PFF’s 9th ranked linebacker on 852 snaps. The undersized 6-0 226 pounder wasn’t great against the run, but he was one of the best coverage linebackers in the league, allowing just 5.09 yards per attempt and no touchdowns on 56 targets. He’s also an adept blitzer, totalling 6 sacks last season and pressuring the quarterback on 18.1% of his 144 career blitzes. He’s a perfect fit as a linebacker in the modern NFL and could easily make his first Pro-Bowl in 2019.

Linebacker Matt Milano (Buffalo)

Milano is similar to Jayon Brown, as an undersized (6-0 223) linebacker who went in the 5th round in 2017. Milano flashed on 450 rookie year snaps and then took a step forward as an every down player in his second season in the league in 2018, ranking 16th among linebackers on PFF before going down for the season with a broken leg in week 14. Like Brown, he isn’t great against the run, but he was one of the best coverage linebackers in the league last season, allowing the 2nd lowest QB rating into his coverage of any linebacker in the league, picking off 3 passes and only allowing a reception every 13.2 coverage snaps (8th in the NFL among linebackers). If he can rebound from his broken leg and make it through the season healthy, he has Pro-Bowl potential.

Cornerback Marlon Humphrey (Baltimore)

The 16th overall pick in the 2017 NFL Draft, Humphrey has allowed just 49.7% completion and 5.87 yards per attempt in two seasons in the league, but he has only started 13 of 30 games, as part of arguably the deepest cornerback group in the NFL. The Ravens still have three other cornerbacks set to make more than 6 million dollars in 2019 (Tavon Young, Jimmy Smith, and Brandon Carr), but Humphrey has shown he deserves an every down role. He looks like a future #1 cornerback and could easily have a breakout third season in the league.

Cornerback Tre’Davious White (Buffalo)

Tre’Davious White easily could have made the Pro-Bowl as a rookie in 2017, when he allowed 50.0% completion, deflected 12 passes, and committed just 3 penalties, but he ended up getting snubbed. In 2018, he wasn’t nearly as good, allowing 57.5% completion, deflecting 5 passes, and committing 10 penalties. Despite the sophomore slump, the 2017 27th overall pick still has a bright future and could easily bounce back to being one of the top cornerbacks in the league in his third season in the league in 2019. If he does that and a couple of those deflections turn into interceptions (just 4 picks as a rookie), he’ll definitely draw Pro-Bowl attention. 

Cornerback Adoree Jackson (Tennessee)

Selected 18th overall in 2017, Adoree Jackson hasn’t quite played at a Pro-Bowl level yet, but his career is off to a solid start, as he’s finished 36th and 31st respectively among cornerbacks on PFF in his 2 seasons in the league. Now going into his 3rd season in the league, he could easily take another step forward. One big thing that would help him make his first Pro Bowl appearance is coming down with more interceptions. He had just 2 in his career so far, but he’s deflected another 23 passes, so it’s not as if he’s not making plays on the ball. 

Safety John Johnson (LA Rams)

Despite playing for a high profile Rams team, John Johnson doesn’t get a lot of national attention, but he looks like a budding young star at the safety position. Drafted in the 3rd round in 2017, Johnson barely played in his first 5 games, but he’s started all 27 games since and has finished 11th and 8th respectively among safeties on PFF. Not even 24 until December, Johnson could easily take another step forward in his 3rd season in the league and earn Pro-Bowl recognition for the first time.

Safety Malik Hooker (Indianapolis)

Malik Hooker went 15th overall in 2017 and was considered a top-10 talent by most, falling because of durability concerns. The scouting report has proven to be accurate with Hooker, as he’s played well when on the field, but he’s missed 11 games with injury in 2 seasons in the league, including a torn ACL that ended his rookie season after 7 games. Hooker was PFF’s 13th ranked safety in 14 games in his first season back after the ACL tear in 2018 and, only going into his age 23 season, he still has a high ceiling if he can avoid injury.

2019 NFL Season Previews

Updated 7/19/19


2018 NFL picks (60% against the spread in 2018)


NFC West: Posted 5/18/19

1. Los Angeles Rams

Record: 10-6

Team Score: 76.33 (78.12 offense, 74.53 defense)

2. San Francisco 49ers

Record: 9-7

Team Score: 74.54 (76.03 offense, 72.04 defense)

3. Seattle Seahawks

Record: 6-10

Team Score: 73.76 (75.80 offense, 71.71 defense)

4. Arizona Cardinals

Record: 3-13

Team Score: 72.19 (70.29 offense, 74.08 defense)

AFC East: Posted 5/28/19

1. New England Patriots

Record: 13-3

Team Score: 77.90 (80.44 offense, 75.35 defense)

2. Buffalo Bills

Record: 7-9

Team Score: 73.22 (71.11 offense, 75.32 defense)

3. New York Jets

Record: 6-10

Team Score: 72.96 (71.68 offense, 74.24 defense)

4. Miami Dolphins

Record: 2-14

Team Score: 69.13 (67.43 offense, 70.83 defense)

NFC East: Posted 6/3/19

1. Philadelphia Eagles

Record: 12-4

Team Score: 77.15 (78.37 offense, 75.92 defense)

2. Dallas Cowboys

Record: 10-6

Team Score: 76.45 (76.93 offense, 75.97 defense)

3. New York Giants

Record: 5-11

Team Score: 71.85 (73.39 offense, 70.31 defense)

4. Washington Redskins

Record: 4-12

Team Score: 71.14 (70.68 offense, 71.60 defense)

AFC North: Posted 6/9/19

1. Cleveland Browns

Record: 11-5

Team Score: 75.84 (76.89 offense, 74.78 defense)

2. Pittsburgh Steelers

Record: 10-6

Team Score: 75.74 (77.63 offense, 73.85 defense)

3. Cincinnati Bengals

Record: 8-8

Team Score: 73.80 (74.11 offense, 74.26 defense)

4. Baltimore Ravens

Record: 6-10

Team Score: 72.57 (70.58 offense, 74.55 defense)

NFC South: Posting 6/18/19

1. New Orleans Saints

Record: 12-4

Team Score: 78.30 (80.03 offense, 76.56 defense)

2. Atlanta Falcons

Record: 10-6

Team Score: 76.37 (78.44 offense, 74.40 defense)

3. Carolina Panthers

Record: 9-7

Team Score: 75.11 (76.16 offense, 74.06 defense)

4. Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Record: 4-12

Team Score: 72.30 (73.38 offense, 71.21 defense)

AFC South: Posted 6/26/19

1. Indianapolis Colts

Record: 11-5

Team Score: 77.40 (79.58 offense, 75.21 defense)

2. Tennessee Titans

Record: 8-8

Team Score: 75.06 (74.33 offense, 75.78 defense)

3. Houston Texans

Record: 8-8

Team Score: 74.71 (73.63 offense, 75.78 defense)

4. Jacksonville Jaguars

Record: 5-11

Team Score: 73.49 (71.90 offense, 75.08 defense)

NFC North: Posted 7/2/19

1. Green Bay Packers

Record: 11-5

Team Score: 77.40 (79.24 offense, 75.56 defense)

2. Chicago Bears

Record: 10-6

Team Score: 75.46 (71.75 offense, 79.17 defense)

3. Detroit Lions

Record: 9-7

Team Score: 74.62 (74.67 offense, 74.56 defense)

4. Minnesota Vikings

Record: 7-9

Team Score: 74.29 (73.51 offense, 75.06 defense)

AFC West: Posted 7/8/19

1. Los Angeles Chargers

Record: 11-5

Team Score: 76.55 (77.51 offense, 75.58 defense)

2. Kansas City Chiefs

Record: 10-6

Team Score: 76.15 (79.68 offense, 72.62 defense)

3. Denver Broncos

Record: 5-11

Team Score: 72.94 (70.68 offense, 75.20 defense)

4. Oakland Raiders

Record: 4-12

Team Score: 72.00 (73.67 offense, 70.33 defense)


Team Power Rankings

Team Score Rank
New Orleans 78.30 1
New England 77.90 2
Indianapolis 77.40 3
Green Bay 77.40 4
Philadelphia 77.15 5
LA Chargers 76.55 6
Dallas 76.45 7
Atlanta 76.37 8
LA Rams 76.33 9
Kansas City 76.15 10
Cleveland 75.84 11
Pittsburgh 75.74 12
Chicago 75.46 13
Carolina 75.11 14
Tennessee 75.06 15
Houston 74.71 16
Detroit 74.62 17
San Francisco 74.54 18
Minnesota 74.29 19
Cincinnati 73.80 20
Seattle 73.76 21
Jacksonville 73.49 22
Buffalo 73.22 23
New York Jets 72.96 24
Denver 72.94 25
Baltimore 72.57 26
Tampa Bay 72.30 27
Arizona 72.19 28
Oakland 72.00 29
NY Giants 71.85 30
Washington 71.14 31
Miami 69.13 32

Perfect 53 Man Roster 2019

Last year, I made my own version of Bill Barnwell’s “Perfect Roster.” The idea is, following certain criteria, to build the best team you can fit under the NFL’s 188.2 million dollar cap. This year, I’m bringing it back. This is my version of the team. Below are the criteria in Barnwell’s own words (last year’s version, so all years get moved forward, and the salary cap has increased).


Patrick Mahomes KC QB 2017 1st $4,479,776
Dak Prescott DAL QB 2016 4th $2,120,849
Taysom Hill NO QB 2017 UND $735,000

Last year, there was more debate about the quarterbacks, with Carson Wentz, Jared Goff, Deshaun Watson, and Dak Prescott all on rookie contracts. This year, it would be hard to take anyone but Pat Mahomes. Not only is Mahomes the reigning league MVP, but with a cap hit under 4.5 million for 2019, he’s also easily the league’s best value. Dak Prescott remains on the team as a backup because he gives them a franchise caliber quarterback that can step in if needed at a very reasonable price. Taysom Hill is listed as a quarterback, but he’s mostly on the team for special teams purposes. Hill could see a few snaps as a gadget player, but I wouldn’t want to take Mahomes or any of my other offensive starters off the field regularly for a gadget player, so Hill won’t have much of an offensive role in any capacity.

Running Backs

Alvin Kamara NO RB 2017 3rd $1,050,693
Chris Carson SEA RB 2017 7th $661,282
Phillip Lindsay DEN RB 2018 UND $575,000
James Develin NE FB Veteran $1,600,000

Alvin Kamara is one of the top running backs in the league and a clear choice out of the 2017 3rd round picks. Phillip Lindsay is a bit of a redundant talent, but he’s the obvious choice out of 2018 undrafted free agents, after becoming the first offensive undrafted free agent in NFL history to make the Pro Bowl as a rookie. He provides strong insurance for Kamara. Chris Carson is a power back who can compliment Lindsay and Kamara and is an easy choice among 2017 7th round picks. James Develin is a do everything veteran fullback who comes at a very reasonable price. 

Wide Receivers

Adam Thielen MIN WR Veteran $8,105,000
Michael Thomas NO WR 2016 2nd $1,628,763
JuJu Smith-Schuster PIT WR 2017 2nd $1,144,302
Jakeem Grant MIA WR 2016 6th $755,096
Hakeem Butler ARZ WR 2019 4th $696,126
Kelvin Harmon WAS WR 2019 6th $526,960

Michael Thomas and JuJu Smith-Schuster are arguably the two best rookie contract wide receivers in the league and, while Adam Thielen is on a 4-year, 64.2 million dollar veteran extension, because of how the deal is structured, his cap number is just 8.105 million for 2019, which makes him a bargain. Thielen, Thomas, and Smith-Schuster make a dominant top trio, so depth isn’t a huge concern, but Jakeem Grant gives me a situational deep threat who can also contribute as a return man (and fills the need for a 2016 6th round pick) and Hakeem Butler and Kelvin Harmon are developmental prospects who I thought were the best players selected in their respective rounds in this past draft. 

Tight Ends

Travis Kelce KC TE Veteran $10,718,400
Nick Boyle BAL TE Veteran $3,333,333
Tyler Eifert CIN TE Veteran $3,025,000
Jordan Thomas HOU TE 2018 6th $599,602

Travis Kelce is arguably the top overall tight end in the league, so he was worth splurging for at a 10.718 million dollar cap hit. He’s one of just 5 players on this roster with an 8 figure cap hit. Nick Boyle won’t win any foot races, but he’s arguably the best run blocking tight end in the league and he also provides a reliable set of hands as an underneath receiver at a very reasonable cap number. Tyler Eifert is another inexpensive veteran. He’s an injury risk, but has the talent to be one of the top tight ends in the league when healthy, so he’s worth a shot. Jordan Thomas is a developmental prospect who fills the requirement for a 2018 6th round pick. 

Offensive Line

David Bakhtiari GB OL Veteran $14,200,000
Zack Martin DAL OL Veteran $14,000,000
Rob Havenstein LAR OL Veteran $8,300,000
Joel Bitonio CLE OL Veteran $7,000,000
Mitchell Schwartz KC OL Veteran $6,430,000
Jason Kelce PHI OL Veteran $2,444,000
Austin Blythe LAR OL 2016 7th $2,025,000
Chase Rouiller WAS OL 2017 6th $681,792

Like last year, the offensive line is where I spent the bulk of my cap space on veteran players. David Bakhtiari and Zack Martin are arguably the best offensive tackle and guard respectively in the league and are worth their large cap hits. Joel Bitonio and Jason Kelce are also among the best in the league at their position and have below market cap hits. Same with Mitchell Schwartz and Rob Havenstein at right tackle, though those two will have to compete with each other for the starting job. Autsin Blythe has developed into an above average starting right guard for the Rams, after being a mere 7th round pick in 2016. He provides versatile depth and a spot starter in case injuries strike on the interior and he fills a draft requirement. Chase Rouiller fills my requirement for a 2017 6th round pick and also provides versatile depth, though the Redskins’ starting center is only about an average starter. 

Interior Defenders

Aaron Donald LAR ID Veteran $17,108,000
Kenny Clark GB ID 2016 1st $2,978,707
DJ Reader HOU ID 2016 5th $2,078,845
Da’Shawn Hand DET ID 2018 4th $740,491
Terry Beckner TB ID 2019 7th $523,079

Even at a cap hit of over 17 million, I had to have Aaron Donald, the most dominant player in the NFL, on this team. He’ll start next to Kenny Clark, who has quietly developed into one of the best interior defenders in the league and has just a 2.979 million dollar cap hit, despite going in the first round in 2016. DJ Reader is a situational run stuffer from the 2016 5th round, Da’Shawn Hand is a situational pass rusher from the 2018 4th round, while Terry Beckner is a developmental prospect who was the first pick in the 7th round in 2019 and fills my requirement for a Buccaneer. 

Edge Defenders

Khalil Mack CHI ED Veteran $11,900,000
Josh Allen JAX ED 2019 1st $4,135,025
Lorenzo Alexander BUF ED Veteran $3,750,000
Brandon Graham PHI ED Veteran $3,500,000
Chase Winovich NE ED 2019 3rd $744,328

Khalil Mack has signed a 6-year, 141 million dollar extension, but his cap number is just 11.9 million, so I can sneak him on to my team. Good luck trying to block him and Donald at the same time. Brandon Graham also got a big long-term deal, re-signing for 40 million over 3 years this off-season, but the cap strapped Eagles structured his deal in a way that keeps his cap hit at 3.5 million for 2019. He’s going into his 30s, but is still one of the better pass rushers in the league on a per snap basis. Lorenzo Alexander gives me a versatile player who can rush the passer, play standup linebacker, and play special teams at a very reasonable price. Josh Allen could end up being the top player from the 2019 NFL Draft and he comes at the price of the 7th overall pick (cap hit 2.2 million dollars less than the 1st overall pick). Allen woukd have a situational role as a pass rusher as a rookie, even on a loaded team. Chase Winovich is another developmental prospect and was a strong value pick in the 3rd round. 


Luke Kuechly CAR LB Veteran $9,962,573
Zach Brown PHI LB Veteran $2,500,000
Darius Leonard IND LB 2018 2nd $1,647,228
Leon Jacobs JAX LB 2018 7th $592,670
Blake Cashman NYJ LB 2019 5th $570,773
Te’Von Coney OAK LB 2019 UND $498,000

Luke Kuechly is arguably the top linebacker in the league and he comes at a significant discount compared to his top competition for that role, Bobby Wagner, who has a 14.0375 million dollar cap hit. Darius Leonard is the reigning Defensive Player of the Year and was obviously a smart choice in the second round in 2018, while Zach Brown is a veteran run stuffer who comes at a reasonable price and can play as a 3rd linebacker in base packages. Leon Jacobs, Blake Cashman, and Te’Von Coney fill draft and team requirements and can play special teams. 


Stephon Gilmore NE CB Veteran $9,170,833
Byron Jones DAL CB 2015 1st $6,266,000
Jason Verrett SF CB Veteran $1,500,000
Byron Murphy ARZ CB 2019 2nd $1,452,636
Desmond King LAC CB 2017 5th $714,998

Stephon Gilmore is arguably the top cornerback in the league and his cap hit is reasonable, despite a 5-year, 65 million dollar deal. Byron Jones is also one of the top cornerbacks in the league and he fills my requirement for a 2015 1st round pick on a 5th year option without breaking the bank (like top-10 picks Leonard Williams, Brandon Scherff, and Amari Cooper would have at cap hits of over 12.5 million). Desmond King went in the same round as George Kittle, so he wasn’t a no brainer addition to this team, but he’s already arguably the top slot cornerback in the league and adds value as a return man as well, which gives him the edge over Kittle. Jason Verrett is an inexpensive injury flyer who has the talent to contribute if healthy and he fills the requirement for a 49er. Byron Murphy probably wouldn’t play much, but he was a strong pick in this year’s second round and has a lot of long-term potential. 


Derwin James LAC S 2018 1st $2,815,671
Kevin Byard TEN S 2016 3rd $2,249,265
Justin Reid HOU S 2018 3rd $924,893
Eddie Jackson CHI S 2017 4th $811,449

Derwin James, Kevin Byard, and Eddie Jackson are all among the top safeties in the league and all are on rookie deals. More and more teams and using 3 safeties at the same time with regularity, so I think we’d figure out how to use Byard, James, and Jackson at the same time. Justin Reid wouldn’t play much on defense behind those three, but he was a solid starter as a rookie for the Texans and is one of the most impressive players from the 2018 3rd round. What gives him the edge is his ability to play special teams in addition to defense.

Special Teams

Michael Dickson SEA P 2018 5th $642,537
Aldrick Rosas NYG K 2016 UND $645,000
Josh Harris ATL LS Veteran $930,000

Michael Dickson and Aldrick Rosas are among the best in the league at their position and are inexpensive in terms of draft compensation and salary. I don’t know much about Josh Harris, but I needed a long snapper and someone from the Falcons and he fits perfectly into the remaining cap space I have. He’s been long snapping for the Falcons since 2012, so he has to be doing something right.

2019 Week 1 NFL Picks

Instead of doing full write ups for each week 1 game, I’m going to have all of my week 1 picks here. If I were to do full write ups, a lot of the material would be redundant to my season previews, so I’ll keep it brief and link to my previews. From week 2 on, I will have full write ups as usual. 

For now, these are just my early thoughts, with a few picks locked in. I will have final updates, full score predictions, confidence rankings, and a Pick of the Week in the days leading up to the first Sunday of the season. 

Green Bay Packers at Chicago Bears (-3.5)

The Bears are favored by more than a field goal because they were the better team last season, but I could see that being flipped in 2019. The Bears had an easy schedule and no injuries last season and lost a pair of defensive starters this off-season. The Packers, meanwhile, should have a more productive passing game with a new offensive system in place and young receivers getting more experience. With a defense that was improved through free agency and what looks like a very promising running game, the Packers could be the most well rounded team in the league this season unless Aaron Rodgers continues to struggle by his standards. Even if the Bears are a tough opponent, I love getting more than a field goal with Green Bay here. 

Pick Against the spread (Locked): Green Bay +3.5

Confidence: High (Potential Pick of the Week)

Upset Pick: Green Bay +160

Atlanta Falcons at Minnesota Vikings (-4)

The Falcons went just 7-9 last season, but their defense was much better in the second half of the season when Deion Jones returned from injury and now they get safeties Keanu Neal and Ricardo Allen back as well. On offense, they get running back Devonta Freeman back and should be better on the offensive line. They could easily get back to the post-season and I have them a few spots better in my rankings than the Vikings, who still have offensive line problems and might not be as good on defense with Sheldon Richardson gone and several other key players getting up there in age. The Falcons have a good chance of winning this one outright even on the road, so getting 4 points with them is great value.

Pick Against the spread (Locked): Atlanta +4

Confidence: High (Potential Pick of the Week)

Upset Pick: Atlanta +170

Washington Redskins at Philadelphia Eagles (-8)

This line is one of the highest of the week, but I don’t think it’s high enough, as this is a matchup between one of the worst and one of the best teams in the league. The Redskins will either be starting a rookie quarterback with just one year of college experience or veteran journeyman Case Keenum, with arguably the worst receiving corps in the league to throw to. Even with all of their quarterback moves this off-season, they will still really miss having a healthy Alex Smith. They weren’t bad defensively last season, but they weren’t good either, despite having next to no injuries, and they have big question marks at middle linebacker and safety after some off-season departures. The Eagles, meanwhile, should be much healthier this season, including Carson Wentz, who dealt with knee and back problems even when on the field last season. This line would be at least two touchdowns if these two teams were to meet in week 6, but I don’t think the public realizes how bad Washington is yet. 

Buffalo Bills at New York Jets (-3)

I have these two teams about even in my roster rankings, so this line seems about right. The Bills are a little bit better, especially with the Jets missing tight end Chris Herndon to suspension, but I don’t think I’d bet on this one.

Baltimore Ravens (-4.5) at Miami Dolphins

Miami is probably going to be the worst team in the league this year, but Baltimore is also likely to be much worse than last season. Their offensive efficiency actually dropped when they went from Joe Flacco to Lamar Jackson down the stretch last season and their 6-1 record in Jackson’s starts was largely the result of an easy schedule and a dominant defense. That defense lost several starters in free agency this off-season, most of whom were not replaced, which really hurts a team that wants to be run heavy and hide Jackson’s accuracy problems. Jackson will likely have to pass much more than he did last season, in part to avoid the injury risk of carrying the ball 15-20 times, and he has a very unproven receiving corps to throw to. I probably wouldn’t bet on Miami, but this line is a little too high and Baltimore should be a good team to pick against for at least the first month of the season.

Kansas City Chiefs (-3.5) @ Jacksonville Jaguars

For now, I am assuming Tyreek Hill will not be playing in this game, as he seems likely to be suspended for at least some period of time. Without Hill and already without Kareem Hunt, suddenly Pat Mahomes’ weapons are not nearly as impressive. Mahomes should still be one of the top quarterbacks in the league this season, but this could be one of his worst games of the season, on the road, against a tough defense, without his top receiver. Jacksonville still has problems on offense, but they upgrade at quarterback with Nick Foles and they have a healthy Leonard Fournette and a healthier offensive line. Against a Chiefs defense that looks likely to be one of the worst in the league again in 2019, I like getting more than a field goal with the Jaguars at home. 

Update: Tyreek Hill will not be suspended. I will update this pick near the start of the season once there is a new line.

Tennessee Titans at Cleveland Browns (-5.5)

This line is about right. I think I’d lean towards Tennessee because Marcus Mariota is healthy for now and the Browns could take a few weeks to find their stride, with all of their new off-season additions, but the Browns have a clear talent edge and could easily win by a touchdown or more at home.

Los Angeles Rams (-3) @ Carolina Panthers

The Panthers were 6-2 last season before Cam Newton got hurt and even when Newton was playing hurt many of their losses were close. The Panthers finished last season 12th in first down rate differential, 2nd best among non-playoff teams behind the Steelers, and Cam Newton should be healthy for week 1 after off-season surgery. They might not make the playoffs in the loaded NFC, but I like their chances of pulling the upset here at home week 1, as field goal underdogs. The Rams should still be good this season, but they lost a pair of offensive linemen in free agency and they still have question marks on defense around Aaron Donald.

Pick Against the spread (Locked): Carolina +3

Confidence: High (Potential Pick of the Week)

Upset Pick: Carolina +135

Cincinnati Bengals at Seattle Seahawks (-8)

The consensus seems to be that the Bengals will struggle this season, but I wouldn’t be so sure. Remember they were one of the better teams in the league last season before injuries struck, especially on offense when Andy Dalton, Tyler Eifert, and AJ Green were all healthy. They’re not necessarily a playoff team, but neither are the Seahawks and I have these two teams about even in my rankings, so we’re getting great value with the Bengals at +8. The Seahawks made the playoffs last season on the strength of a +15 turnover margin, but turnover margins are inconsistent on a year-to-year basis and the Seahawks continued shedding talent this off-season, with Frank Clark and Doug Baldwin no longer on the team. They have one of the weakest rosters in the league around quarterback Russell Wilson.

Pick Against the spread (Locked): Cincinnati +8

Confidence: High (Potential Pick of the Week)

Indianapolis Colts at Los Angeles Chargers (-3)

These should be two of the best teams in the AFC in 2019 and no one should be surprised if this ends up being an AFC Championship preview, but the Colts are the better of the two teams, even if only slightly, and the Chargers have never gotten much help from their home crowd in Los Angeles, so they shouldn’t be getting the full field goal here. I probably wouldn’t bet on the Colts, but they look like the right side.

San Francisco 49ers at Tampa Bay Buccaneers (Even)

This line is about right as this game is close to a toss up, but I have the 49ers projected to win just slightly, so they would be my pick for pick ‘em purposes.

Detroit Lions (-2.5) at Arizona Cardinals

This line seems about right, but I like the Lions for two reasons. For one, this will be the first NFL start for Kyler Murray, who was only a starter for about a year in college. Two, the Lions have dominated against non-playoff teams in recent years and that’s what I expect the Cardinals to ultimately end up being. In the past three seasons, the Lions are 22-9 against non-playoff teams and just 2-16 against playoff qualifiers. I like their chances of covering in a game in which they basically just need to win to cover.

New York Giants at Dallas Cowboys (-7.5)

The Cowboys haven’t been great at home as big favorites in recent years, but I don’t think this line is high enough, as the Cowboys are one of the better teams in the league, with the Giants are one of the worst. One thing to monitor with this game is that Dallas defensive end DeMarcus Lawrence is still considered questionable for week 1 after off-season shoulder surgery. Missing him would be a big blow to the Cowboys’ chances of winning by more than a touchdown. 

Pittsburgh Steelers @ New England Patriots (-6)

I’ve gone back and forth on this one and probably will continue to do so over the next few weeks. On one hand, the Patriots have the talent advantage and have always played Pittsburgh very well. On the other hand, the Steelers beat the Patriots last year and this is probably a bigger game for them, as they’ll want a statement win to show they are still a threat, while the Patriots usually spend the first month of the season figuring things out.

Houston Texans @ New Orleans Saints (-6.5)

I have the Saints as the most talented team in the league, but they’ll likely be without Sheldon Rankins, who is still rehabbing from a torn Achilles he suffered in the playoffs last season, and fellow starting defensive tackle David Onyemata will also miss this game, due to a suspension. On top of that, they’ve traditionally started slow, going 2-12 ATS in the first 2 weeks of the season over the past 7 seasons. Remember last year when they lost at home to the Buccaneers? The Texans are a tougher opponent than Tampa Bay and steal a win here. At the same time, I don’t know if we’re getting enough line value at +6.5 to take the Texans with any confidence.

Denver Broncos @ Oakland Raiders (-2)

This line seems about right. I have the Raiders projected to win, but only by a slim margin. That slim margin is more likely to be a field goal than a single point though, so Oakland is probably the right side for pick ‘em purposes.

2018 Picks (59.74% ATS)

Oakland Raiders 2019 NFL Season Preview


It’s hard to believe the Raiders won 12 games in 2016. They were never as good as their record suggested that season, finishing 19th in first down rate differential and winning 12 games largely because of an unsustainably high turnover margin (+16) and a 8-1 record in games decided by a touchdown or less, but they fell from grace very quickly. In 2017, they went 6-10 with largely the same roster, going just 4-3 in games decided by a touchdown or less and finishing the season with a -14 turnover margin. 

That led to them firing head coach Jack Del Rio and replacing him with former head coach and long-time ESPN commentator Jon Gruden. In order to get Gruden, the Raiders had to commit to a ten year deal that basically gives him total control over the roster. With total control and complete job security, Gruden decided to take apart the team and rebuild it with his own guys, particularly on defense. 

Of their top-11 in terms of snaps played on defense in 2017, only 4 returned for 2018, with only two (Reggie Nelson and Bruce Irvin) starting week 1. Irvin was then later released mid-season in order to free up playing time for younger guys, while Nelson got benched quickly and finished the season with just 370 snaps played. Their biggest move on defense was sending away contract year edge defender Khalil Mack to the Bears for a pair of first round picks, rather than giving him the big money deal he wanted (Chicago re-signed him for 141 million over 6 years). 

On offense, they didn’t make quite as many changes, with 8 of their top-11 in terms of snaps played in 2017 returning as starters for week 1 of 2018, but they made a big splash move at last year’s trade deadline to send #1 receiver Amari Cooper, who was going into the final year of his rookie deal in 2019, to the Cowboys for another first round pick. The result of their teardown was a treasure chest of draft picks, including a trio of 2019 first round picks, and among the most cap space in the NFL this off-season, but it also led to an ugly product on the field in Gruden’s first year as head coach. They Raiders went just 4-12 and finished 28th in the NFL in first down rate differential. 

There was a lot of speculation that Gruden would move on from highly paid quarterback Derek Carr as well, but it doesn’t look like that was ever a serious consideration. Carr wasn’t bad last season all things considered, completing 68.9% of his passes for an average of 7.32 YPA, 19 touchdowns, and 10 interceptions, while finishing 21st among quarterbacks on Pro Football Focus, and his 20 million dollar salary isn’t cost prohibitive for a team with plenty of financial flexibility. He has a poor supporting cast around him on both sides of the ball, as they finished 24th in first down rate allowed on defense and just 26th in first down rate on offense, despite Carr’s decent season. Carr is not the problem with this team. 

In 5 seasons in the league, Carr has started 78 of 80 games for the Raiders and he has earned an average or better grade from PFF in each of the past 4 seasons, including a career best 5th ranked finish in 2016. It’s possible Gruden could change quarterbacks at some point in the future if one that really catches his eye is available, but for now Carr’s job looks very safe. The Raiders only ended up signing veteran backup Mike Glennon (84.0 QB rating in 22 career starts) this off-season, so Carr doesn’t have a legitimate challenger for his job and should start all 16 games if he stays healthy. Whether or not he leads this team back into post-season contention depends on how improved his supporting cast is from 2018 to 2019.

Grade: B

Receiving Corps

One of Carr’s big problems was his receiving corps. Amari Cooper only had a 22/280/1 slash line in 6 games and he was inconsistent throughout his tenure in Oakland, but without him and with veterans Martavis Bryant and Brandon LaFell going down for the season, Carr was left with veteran Jordy Nelson, slot receiver Seth Roberts, and 7th round rookie Marcell Ateman as his top-3 receivers down the stretch. As a result, Carr went from a 72.3% completion percentage, 7.79 YPA, and 10 touchdowns in his first 8 games to a 65.3% completion percentage, 6.83 YPA, and 9 touchdowns in his final 8 games, though his interceptions did drop from 8 to 2 as he grew more comfortable in Gruden’s system.

Tight end Jared Cook led the team with a 68/896/6 slash line and was Pro Football Focus’ 8th ranked tight end overall, while Jordy Nelson was their leading wide receiver with a 63/739/3 slash line, but had just 1.41 yards per route run. Both Cook and Nelson are no longer with the team, Cook signing with the Saints as a free agent and Nelson retiring ahead of what would have been his age 34 season, but the Raiders are still expecting to have a better receiving corps, after making some splash moves this off-season.

Their biggest move was trading a 3rd and 5th round pick to the Steelers for disgruntled wide receiver Antonio Brown, who they then gave a new 3-year, 50.125 million dollar deal to make him the second highest paid wide receiver in the league in average annual salary. Brown caused distractions in the locker room in Pittsburgh, but has been one of the best wide receivers in the league for years, as he’s topped a 100/1250/8 slash line in 6 straight seasons, with an average slash line of 114/1524/11 over those 6 seasons and a 104/1297/15 slash line in 2018. He’ll likely see his numbers go down in a worse offense in Oakland and his age is becoming a concern in his age 31 season, but he undoubtedly makes this offense better. Whether or not he becomes a problem in the locker room if the Raiders struggle remains to be seen. 

The Raiders also signed ex-Charger Tyrell Williams to a 4-year, 44.3 million dollar deal in free agency to start opposite Brown. Williams was the Chargers’ #1 receiver in 2016 with Keenan Allen injured and put up a 69/1059/7 slash line, but he’s seen that dip to 43/728/4 and 41/653/5 in the past 2 seasons as the #2 receiver with Allen back healthy. With Antonio Brown hogging targets opposite him on a worse offense in Oakland, it’s hard to see him putting up much better numbers than that, but he should get plenty of one-on-ones with Brown being the focus of opposing defenses and he has the speed and size to make some big plays down the field. His 16.3 yards per catch average over the past 4 seasons is 4th in the NFL among players with at least 150 catches. 

Depth is still a problem behind Brown and Williams though. The Raiders only used a 5th round pick on the position in the draft, but 5th round rookie Hunter Renfrow is a natural slot receiver and could push to start as a rookie at a thin position. Last year’s 7th round pick Marcell Ateman could be in the mix, but he showed very little as a rookie, averaging just 0.69 yards per route run and finishing as PFF’s 8th worst ranked wide receiver. The Raiders also have veterans Ryan Grant and JJ Nelson in the mix, but they’ve never topped 573 yards in a season in a combined 9 seasons in the league and neither is a lock for the final roster.

Tight end is also a problem. Not only did they lose Jared Cook, who had 68 of their 91 catches by a tight end last season, but they also lost blocking specialist Lee Smith, who excelled as a blocker on 284 snaps last season. With no real starting options added this off-season, this is a wide open position group. Derek Carrier is a blocking specialist who has never topped 404 snaps in a season and has just 43 career catches in 7 seasons in the league. Foster Moreau is a fourth round rookie who could play a significant role in year one for lack of a better option. 

Darren Waller has earned a lot of praise this off-season, but that could just be off-season hype for a player with 18 career catches in 22 games in 4 seasons in the league. The 2015 6th round pick has never played more than 237 snaps in a season, including just 42 snaps last season, and he missed all of 2017 with suspension. The Raiders also added veteran Luke Willson, but he’s never topped 22 catches in 6 seasons in the league and isn’t a great run blocker either. Erik Swoope has shown a lot of promise as a receiver in his career in very limited action, averaging 2.63 yards per route run, but he missed all of 2017 with injury and played just 78 snaps last season. It’s unclear if any of these players can emerge as starting caliber. Outside receivers Brown and Williams figure to get the lion’s share of the targets in a thin receiving corps.

Grade: C+

Running Backs

Carr also didn’t get much help on the ground last season, as the Raiders finished 23rd in the NFL with 4.21 YPC. Week 1 starter Marshawn Lynch lasted 6 games (90 carries) before going down for the season with injury. In his absence, ex-Buccaneer Doug Martin wasn’t bad, averaging 4.20 YPC on 172 carries, but he’s going into his age 30 season, doesn’t do much in the passing game (99 catches in the past 6 seasons), and has a history of inconsistency on the ground (below 4 YPC in 4 of 7 seasons in the league), so the Raiders shot higher at the position this off-season, taking Alabama’s Josh Jacobs with the 24th overall pick. Jacobs was the first running back off the board. 

Jacobs has feature back potential long-term, but might not have a huge workload immediately as a rookie. Doug Martin is still on the team and, while it’s unlikely he has the 172 carries he had in 2018, he’ll likely still be involved in a rotational role as an early down runner unless Jacobs starts to completely outperform him. The Raiders also still have passing down back Jalen Richard, who had a 68/607/0 slash line last season and could be similarly productive in 2019 in an offense that really lacks a 3rd option in the receiving corps. Richard also provides a change of pace on the ground and has averaged 5.28 YPC on 194 carries in 3 seasons in the league. This is a solid group.

Grade: B

Offensive Line

The Raiders also had serious problems on the offensive line last season, leading to Derek Carr taking 51 sacks, 3rd most in the NFL. Part of that was Carr holding the ball a little too long and he ranked 4th in the NFL by taking a sack on 27.3% of his pressured drop backs, but the offensive line had a lot of problems as well and ranked 26th in the NFL in pass blocking efficiency. The biggest problem was the offensive tackle position, where veteran Donald Penn was limited to 188 snaps in 4 games by injury, leaving rookie first and third round picks Kolton Miller and Brandon Parker to start on the left and right side respectively for most of the season. A big part of Gruden’s first draft class in Oakland, Miller and Parker struggled mightily, finishing 81st and 83rd respectively out of 85 qualifying offensive tackles on Pro Football Focus and allowing 26 sacks combined. 

Penn is no longer with the team, but the Raiders made a big financial investment at the offensive tackle position this off-season, signing Trent Brown to a 4-year, 66 million dollar deal that makes him the highest paid offensive lineman in the NFL. He’s been a solid starter over the past 3 seasons (42 starts), but has never finished higher than 27th among offensive tackles on PFF. On top of that, he’s expected to play right tackle, which is generally the lesser valued offensive tackle position. Only 5 other right tackles make at least 8 million annually. Brown makes more than double that annually on his new deal (16.5 million). He played the left side in New England last season, but the Raiders seem to want to keep Kolton Miller there, despite his disastrous rookie season. He still has upside and could easily be better in his second season in the league, but he was a questionable pick at the time (especially over Derwin James and Leighton Vander Esch) and his career has gotten off to a rough start.

In part to free up money to sign Brown, the Raiders sent incumbent left guard Kelechi Osemele to the Jets in what amounted to a salary dump, getting out of the final 2 years and 22.9 million of his contract. Osemele struggled in an injury plagued 2018 season, finishing 64th out of 88 qualifying guards on PFF on 735 snaps, but he’s been a much better player in the past and the Raiders don’t have an obvious replacement for him. They could move Brandon Parker inside with Brown taking his spot at right tackle, but he was horrendous as a rookie and wouldn’t necessarily be better at a new position.

Veteran Richie Incognito is penciled in as the starter at left guard, but he comes with plenty of uncertainty. Incognito has earned an above average grade from PFF in his past 9 seasons, maxing out at 6th among guards in 2015 and finishing 18th at his position as recently as 2017, but he has a history of discipline issues, he spent 2018 out of the league, and is now going into his age 36 season. He could give them solid play, especially as a run blocker, but that’s far from a guarantee. Along with Parker, Incognito also could face competition from Denzelle Good, who started the final 3 games of the season at right guard last season and has 23 career starts in 4 seasons in the league. He’s always been an underwhelming player though and it’s very possible left guard remains a position of weakness in 2019.

At center and right guard, Rodney Hudson and Gabe Jackson remain as starters. Hudson is their best offensive lineman, even with the addition of Brown in free agency. He was PFF’s 4th ranked center in 2018, his 5th straight season in the top-9 at his position (75 starts). Going into his age 30 season, his age is becoming a concern, but interior offensive linemen can often play well into their 30s, so he isn’t necessarily about to start declining. Even if he does a little bit, he should still remain one of the top centers in the league.

Gabe Jackson isn’t the same caliber player, but he’s a solid starter at the very least, making 72 of 80 starts in 5 seasons in the league since being drafted in the 3rd round in 2014 and finishing in the top-32 among guards on PFF in each of the past 4 seasons, including a 17th ranked season in 2018. Still in the prime of his career in his age 28 season, Jackson should continue giving them solid play. The left side of this offensive line is a big question mark, but Trent Brown upgrades the right tackle spot significantly and Hudson and Jackson are also strong starters at center and right guard respectively.

Update: Richie Incognito will be suspended for the first 2 games of the season, but that won’t have a significant effect on this line.

Grade: B

Edge Defenders

By far the Raiders’ biggest weakness on defense last season was their pass rush. In a season in which no other team finished with fewer than 30 sacks, the Raiders had a league low 13. For comparison Khalil Mack had 12.5 by himself in 14 games with the Bears. In Mack’s absence, the Raiders’ pass rush production from their edge defenders was pathetic as they managed just 4 sacks on the season, with 3 of them coming from Bruce Irvin, who was cut mid-season. Third round rookie Arden Key was the only edge defender with a sack still on the roster by season’s end and he had just 1 sack and a 9.1% pressure rate, while leading the team with 644 snaps played at the position. 35-year old Frostee Rucker finished second at the position with 549 snaps played, but didn’t have a single sack and had just a 6.1% pressure rate.

Despite having cap space, the Raiders didn’t do much to address the edge defender spot in free agency, but they did in the draft, using their 4th overall pick on Clemson’s Clelin Ferrell and then adding Eastern Michigan’s Maxx Crosby in the 4th round as well. Ferrell was a surprise pick at #4, over players like linebacker Devin White, interior defender Ed Oliver and fellow edge defender Josh Allen, but he’s a great fit for the Raiders’ 4-3 defense.

Even if Ferrell isn’t as good of a pass rusher as Allen, he still has great upside as a pass rusher and can play the run in the NFL from day 1. He was a reach, but should have come off the board from like 8-12, so it’s not like he was huge reach and he could easily still develop into a great player. Crosby, meanwhile, was a good value in the 4th round and should be able to contribute as a rotational player as a rookie. He’ll rotate with Ferrell and Arden Key, who the Raiders are hoping can be better in his 2nd season in the league, after a disappointing rookie season. 

The Raiders’ one free agent edge defender addition was veteran Benson Mayowa, who was signed to just a one-year, 1.7 million dollar deal. Mayowa has the potential to exceed his contract value though, especially at an unsettled position group. He played a career high 550 snaps last season with the Cardinals and has a career best year as well, playing the run well and finishing with 4 sacks, 7 hits, and a 9.9% pressure rate. He’s a one-year wonder in terms of being a starting caliber player, but he wasn’t bad as a rotational player from 2014-2017, averaging 375 snaps per season, and, in his age 28 season, could easily continue being an effective rotational player. He’s the veteran of a very young group and definitely has opportunity for playing time.

Grade: C

Interior Defenders

The Raiders didn’t make a big addition at on the interior of their defensive line in free agency either, nor did they address the position through the draft. They didn’t necessarily need to make a big splash addition at the position though. They return their top-3 defensive tackles from last season in terms of snaps played and, as much as this defense struggled, they weren’t a bad group. Two of those three defensive tackles are going into just their second year in the league as well, so they have the potential to be better in 2019. 

PJ Hall was the higher pick, going in the 2nd round, but 5th round pick Maurice Hurst was the better of the two players. Hall was a solid run stuffer, but didn’t have a sack and managed just a 5.0% pressure rate. Hurst, meanwhile, played well in both aspects and led the team with 4 sacks on just 472 snaps. He only fell in the draft because of concerns about his heart, but as long as he stays on the field the Raiders appear to have gotten a steal. Both he and Hall could take another step forward in their second season in the league in 2019.

Veteran Johnathan Hankins led this position group with 573 snaps played last season and returns on a 2-year, 8.5 million dollar deal as a free agent this off-season. He struggled mightily as a pass rusher, with just a 2.9% pressure rate, but he’s a strong run stuffer and has been a slightly better pass rusher in the past, with 12 sacks, 22 hits, and a 6.1% pressure rate in 82 career games. Still only in his age 27 season, he should have another solid season in 2019 and could easily bounce back as a pass rusher. 

Fourth defensive tackle Clinton McDonald (419 snaps) is no longer with the team, but he won’t really be missed and the Raiders should get a healthier year from Justin Ellis. A foot injury limited Ellis to poor play over 133 snaps in 6 games last season, but he’s been better in the past. He’s not much of a pass rusher, with a 3.9% career pressure rate, but the 6-2 330 pounder is a strong run stuffer when he’s right and he’s still only going into his age 29 season. If healthy, he should be valuable in a situational role as a base package run stuffer. This is a decent group, but they lack a standout player.

Grade: C+


The Raiders also didn’t make a big addition at linebacker in free agency either, opting inside to take flyers on a pair of veterans in Vontaze Burfict and Brandon Marshall on one-year deals worth just 2 million and 1.2 million respectively. Both players have seen better days and the Raiders are hoping one or both of them can bounce back. Marshall was a top-14 off ball linebacker on Pro Football Focus in 3 straight seasons from 2014-2016, but he’s missed 12 games with injury over the past 5 seasons and has only been a middling starter in the past 2 seasons when on the field. Going into his age 30 season, with the injury history that he has, it’s likely his best days are behind him.

Burfict has had injury issues as well. He was a Pro Bowler in 2013, but has missed 37 of 80 games in 5 seasons since and, while he’s played well for stretches since when on the field, including a 21st ranked finish among off ball linebackers on 589 snaps on PFF as recently as 2017, the injuries seemed to catch up to him in 2018, as he finished 83rd among 96 qualifying off ball linebackers on 298 snaps. Only going into his age 29 season, Burfict could bounce back at least to his 2017 form, but that’s far from a guarantee and he’s likely to miss at least some time with injury. He’s the victim of his own violent playing style and adds yet another mercurial personality to this locker room with Richie Incognito and Antonio Brown. 

Tahir Whitehead led this linebacking corps with 1,025 snaps played last season, playing all but 3 snaps, but he struggled and is likely to take on a much smaller role with Marshall and Burfict coming in. He’s a solid run stuffer, but has a lot of trouble in coverage and would ideally be a 3rd linebacker in base packages and come off the field in obvious passing situations for a 5th defensive back. In order for that to happen, Marshall and Burfict will both need to stay healthy.

Marquel Lee and Nicholas Morrow played 448 snaps and 416 snaps respectively last season, but both struggled. Added in 2017 as a 5th round pick and an undrafted free agent respectively, neither has shown much in 2 seasons in the league and would be best as reserves. They could be pressed back into action though if Marshall and/or Burfict get hurt or struggle. This group has upside, but they didn’t add a true difference maker this off-season.

Grade: C+


The one big free agent addition the Raiders did make on defense this off-season was safety LaMarcus Joyner, who comes over from the Rams on a 4-year, 42 million dollar deal. Joyner was Pro Football Focus’ 2nd ranked safety in 2017, but is largely a one-year wonder, never finishing higher than 27th at his position in his other 3 seasons. He should have a solid season at the very least though and he’s especially valuable because he can play both free safety and slot cornerback. The Raiders also used their final first round pick, 27th overall, on safety Johnathan Abram, who is expected to be the strong safety. He could easily be an every down player as a rookie.

Fourth year safety Karl Joseph could also have a role as the third safety, when Joyner moves to the slot. A first round pick in 2016, Joseph was a solid starter in his first 2 seasons in the league (21 starts), but Gruden benched him and he played just 55 snaps in the first 8 games of the 2018 season, before moving into the starting lineup and playing 454 snaps in the final 8 games. He actually had the best stretch of his career during those 8 games, but the Raiders still declined his 5th year option for 2020 this off-season and added a pair of safeties to start over him. 

Joseph could still see a significant role though, since Joyner could be on the slot a fair amount in sub packages. Cornerback was a position of weakness for the Raiders in 2018, when they started 6 different players, and only 3 of those players remain. In addition to drafting a safety in the first round, they also used a second round pick on Clemson cornerback Travyon Mullen. He’ll compete for the outside cornerback spots with holdovers Gareon Conley, Daryl Worley, and Nick Nelson. 

Conley seems to have the best shot to lock down a starting job. Injuries have limited him to just in 14 starts in 2 seasons in the league, but he was a first round pick in 2017 and has played pretty well when on the field. He played a career 679 snaps last season and, only in his age 24 season, could easily take a step forward in his 3rd season in the league in 2019 if he can stay healthy. That’s far from a guarantee though.

Daryl Worley and the rookie Trayvon Mullen have the best shot to win the other starting job. Worley has made 34 starts in 3 seasons in the league since being drafted in the 3rd round in 2016 and is still only in his age 24 season, but has been an underwhelming player and finished last season as PFF’s 116th ranked cornerback out of 131 qualifying on 505 snaps. He could easily lose a training camp competition to Mullen, though Mullen wouldn’t necessarily be a huge upgrade.

2018 4th round pick Nick Nelson could also be in the mix for a role outside, but mostly likely he’ll try to carve out a role on the slot, where he played 230 of 311 snaps as a rookie. Nelson struggled mightily as a rookie and doesn’t have the size or speed to play outside, so he may be best as a dime cornerback. The Raiders have some promising young defensive backs and the addition of LaMarcus Joyner in free agency should help, but this isn’t a great group either. By default, it’s their best defensive unit.

Grade: B


The Raiders are rebuilding from the ground up around Derek Carr. Their offense should be better with the additions of Trent Brown, Antonio Brown, and Tyrell Williams, but most of their defensive additions were either rookies and washed up veteran flyers, with defensive back LaMarcus Joyner being the one exception. They have some upside on defense and it wouldn’t be hard for them to be better than they were last season defensively, but this still looks like one of the least talented teams in the league on paper.

Prediction: 4-12, 4th in AFC West

Team Score: 72.00 (29th in NFL)

Offensive Score: 73.67

Defensive Score: 70.33

Team score is based on a weighted average of individual player grades (certain positions valued higher than others, score out of 100)

Kansas City Chiefs 2019 NFL Season Preview


During the 2017 off-season, the Chiefs had veteran Alex Smith as starting quarterback, going into his 5th season in that role. He hadn’t played badly, but the Chiefs still had higher ambitions at the position and opted to trade a pair of first round picks to the Bills (27th in 2017 and what became 22nd in 2018) to move up to select Texas Tech quarterback Pat Mahomes to be their quarterback of the future. Quarterback didn’t seem like an obvious need and the Chiefs paid a steep price to select him, but the hope was that Mahomes would give them a younger, cheaper starting option long-term.

Smith had arguably the best season of his career in 2017, but the Chiefs lost early in the post-season again and continued forward with their plan to start Mahomes long-term, sending Smith to the Redskins for a 3rd round pick and starting cornerback Kendall Fuller last off-season. Mahomes became the starter and played at a level that no one expected in 2018, completing 66.0% of his passes for an average of 8.79 YPA, 50 touchdowns, and 12 interceptions, while adding 270 yards and 2 touchdowns on 60 carries (4.53 YPC). He was Pro Football Focus’ 2nd ranked quarterback, only behind Drew Brees, who threw almost 100 fewer passes, and he ultimately ended up winning the NFL’s MVP award over Brees at the end of the season. 

Mahomes obviously deserves most of the credit, but he’s been fortunate to work with head coach Andy Reid, who has always gotten the most out of his quarterbacks, including Alex Smith. Reid had never gotten the opportunity to work with a talent like Mahomes before and now it’s clear that the two have the ability to produce tremendous results together on offense. The Chiefs led the league last season with a 45.18% first down rate, 2% more than any other team in the league last season and the best by any team in recent memory. 

Mahomes probably isn’t going to do what he did last season every single season, but given that he won the MVP in his age 23 season in his first season as a starter, the sky’s the limit for his potential. Barring a catastrophic injury, Mahomes should remain one of the top few quarterbacks in the league again in 2019. If he were to get hurt, the Chiefs would have to turn to failed Dolphins and Jaguars starter Chad Henne, who has a 75.5 QB rating in 53 career starts. Needless to say, he’d be a massive downgrade.

Grade: A

Running Backs

One thing that could slow down Mahomes is personnel losses around him. During their week 12 bye week last season, Mahomes lost feature back Kareem Hunt, who was kicked off the team for domestic violence. Their offense was still strong in the final 5 games of the season, with a 42.77% first down rate, but that’s down from 46.31% through 11 games. Replacement starter Damien Williams averaged 5.12 yards per carry on 50 carries, but he was still a downgrade, for a couple reasons. For one, he’s not nearly the same threat in the receiving game, averaging just 7.0 yards per catch, compared to 14.5 for Hunt. He’s also not the kind of player who defenses have to commit a lot of attention to, which makes life harder for Mahomes. 

Williams is very inexperienced, with a 4.01 YPC average on 183 carries in 5 seasons in the league, but the Chiefs didn’t add much at the running back position this off-season, so he looks likely to be the lead back. They added veteran Carlos Hyde in free agency, but only on a 1-year, 2.8 million dollar deal. He also had just a 3.32 YPC average on 172 carries last season with the Browns and Jaguars and his career 3.99 yards per target average makes him a poor fit for an Andy Reid offense that likes to throw the ball to the backs. 

Hyde has been a better runner in the past than he was last season, so he could contribute in a situational role as a pure early down back, but he’s unlikely to have a big role. The Chiefs also added Darwin Thompson in the 6th round of the draft. Thompson is undersized at 5-8 200, but he has intriguing upside in this offense. He gives them a change of pace to the bigger Hyde (6-0 229) and Williams (5-11 224) and he can contribute as a receiver as well. He might not have much of a role to start the season, but could emerge as a factor down the stretch. In close to two seasons in Kansas City, Kareem Hunt averaged 4.75 yards per carry across 453 carries, 10.5 yards per catch across 79 catches, and scored 25 times in 27 games with the Chiefs. It’s unlikely any of these backs emerge as the threat he was. 

Grade: C+

Receiving Corps

Mahomes might also be losing Tyreek Hill because of off-the-field issues, which would be an even bigger loss, as Hill was Mahomes’ top target in 2018, posting an 87/1479/12 slash line. Hill has averaged 2.42 yards per route run in 3 seasons in the league and his deep speed makes him a great fit with Mahomes and his cannon arm. Mahomes and Hill connected 20 times last season on passes that went more than 20 yards downfield for 754 yards. No other receiver had more than 15 catches or 543 yards on balls that far downfield.

Hill was only a 5th round pick by the Chiefs in 2016, but the primary reason he was available then was a conviction for domestic violence while in college. Now a few years later, Hill was investigated this off-season for potential child abuse. The investigation turned up no charges and recent reports suggest the NFL believes Hill’s side of the story, but this whole situation is a PR nightmare for the NFL, so Hill could still be looking at a minimum 4 game suspension, especially given his history.

Still, from a football perspective, that’s about as good as the Chiefs could have hoped for when this story initially broke. Around draft day, it looked like Hill’s long-term future could be in doubt after the release of an audio recording that seemed to implicate Hill, so the Chiefs used a 2nd round pick on Georgia’s Mecole Hardman, who is a similarly fast player. Instead of replacing Hill, it’s looking more and more likely that he’ll be playing alongside Hill long-term. Hardman is very raw though and, as a rookie, almost definitely would not be able to replace Hill effectively if he was to get suspended.

If Hill is unable to play, Sammy Watkins would become the #1 receiver. Watkins was the #2 receiver last year, but was limited to a 40/519/3 slash line in 10 games due to injury, Injuries have unfortunately become expected from him, as he hasn’t played all 16 games since his rookie season in 2014 and has missed 18 of 64 games in 4 seasons since. He averages a 60/922/7 slash line per 16 games in his career, despite playing many games at less than 100%, and the former 4th overall pick is still only in his age 26 season. He doesn’t have Hill’s speed, but he definitely has deep ball ability with a career 15.4 yards per catch average. As long as he’s healthy, he should be an effective top target in Hill’s absence.

Hill’s absence would have a ripple effect farther down the depth chart though. Fourth receiver DeMarcus Robinson played 419 snaps last season, 252 of them in the 6 games Watkins missed, and the 2016 4th round round pick would ideally compete for the #3 receiver job with Hardman. If Hill is out, both Hardman and Robinson will likely have to play significant snaps. Both Hardman and Robinson have upside, but Hardman never topped 35 catches in a season in college and figures to have a lot of growing pains as a rookie, while Robinson has averaged just 0.81 yards per route run on 615 routes in 3 seasons in the league.

Especially without Hill, Mahomes figures to rely heavily on tight end Travis Kelce, who is one of the best in the league at his position. He was just about as productive as Hill last season, with a 103/1336/10 slash line, and averaged a 77/975/6 slash line 4 seasons in the league even before being paired up with Mahomes. Also a solid blocker, Kelce has finished in the top-3 among tight ends on Pro Football Focus in 4 of the last 5 seasons. He’ll turn 30 later this year, which is a concern, but he hasn’t missed a game with injury in 5 seasons and has shown no signs of slowing down. 

If anything was to happen to Kelce, the Chiefs would be in a lot of trouble because they really lack depth at tight end. Demetrius Harris played 371 snaps as the #2 tight end last season, but he’s no longer with the team and the only replacements they added were Blake Bell and Neal Sterling, a pair of bottom of the roster types. Both drafted in 2015, Bell has played 825 snaps since being drafted in the 4th round, while Sterling has played 402 snaps since being drafted in the 7th round. Combined, they have just 54 career catches. Neither is a lock for the final roster, but one will have to see a role because all of the Chiefs’ other tight ends are former undrafted free agents with no experience. The Chiefs have a talented top-3 in Hill, Kelce, and Watkins, but Hill is facing a possibly long suspension and they have very uncertain depth behind those three. I will revise this grade based on the length of Hill’s suspension, but for now I’m assuming 6-8 games.

Update: Tyreek Hill will not be suspended for any games. I have adjusted this team’s projection accordingly.

Grade: B+

Offensive Line

As good as the Chiefs’ offense was last season, their offensive line was a bit of a problem. Mahomes was only sacked 26 times because he’s so hard to take down, but he took another 45 hits, including a league leading 16 hits while throwing. Mahomes takes off and runs a few times per game, so he’s already taking more hits than your average quarterback. They need to limit the amount of times he’s getting hit in the pocket if they want him to continue avoiding injury. 

Despite that, the Chiefs didn’t really do much to address the offensive line this off-season. They do get right guard Laurent Duvarney-Tardif back from a broken leg that ended his 2018 season after just 5 games. Duvarney-Tardif was Pro Football Focus’ 19th ranked guard in 2017 and he’s still only in his age 28 season, so he has bounce back potential, but he’s also largely a one-year wonder, earning an average grade from PFF in his other 3 seasons as a starter. He should still be a welcome re-addition if healthy, but he’s had durability issues, also missing 7 games between 2016-2017.

The Chiefs lost center Mitch Morse in free agency though, which kind of cancels out the re-addition of Duvarney-Tardif, and the Chiefs had the 9th fewest adjusted games lost to injury in the league last season, so it’s not like they can necessarily count on better health in 2019. Morse actually missed 5 games with an injury of his own last season, but he still finished 15th among centers on PFF. Injury replacement Austin Reiter wasn’t bad in his absence last season, but the 2015 7th round pick is very inexperienced, with 5 career starts. He’ll likely remain the starter in 2019, for lack of a better option, and could easily struggle as a 16-game starter.

At left guard, incumbent Cam Erving will compete with Andrew Wylie, who made 10 starts at right guard last season in Duvarney-Tardif’s absence. Erving was a first round pick in 2015 and has made 34 career starts at 4 different positions (13 at center, 1 at left tackle, 15 at left guard, and 5 at right guard), but he’s struggled mightily regardless of where he’s played, most recently finishing 83rd out of 88 qualifying guards on PFF last season in 13 starts. 

Wylie wasn’t great at right guard last season, but he wasn’t bad either and even though that was the first starting experience of the 2017 undrafted free agent’s career, he could still be an upgrade at left guard over Erving. Erving, meanwhile, could potentially kick inside to center, but he wouldn’t necessarily be an upgrade. Regardless of how it works out, left guard and center figure to be positions of weakness.

This offensive line is much better outside, as left tackle Eric Fisher and right tackle Mitchell Schwartz are one of the top tackle duos in the league. Drafted first overall in 2013, Fisher was a bit of a late bloomer, but he’s earned an above average grade from PFF in 4 straight seasons, maxing out at 24th in 2016 and finishing 28th in 2018. Still in his age 28 season, he should remain an above average left tackle. 

Schwartz, meanwhile, has been one of the best right tackles in the league since his rookie year in 2012, earning an above average grade from PFF in all 7 seasons in the league, including 2 seasons in the top-14 and a career best 5th place finish in 2018. Going into his age 30 season, he could start to decline soon and it may be tough for him to repeat his career best year, but he should remain one of the top right tackles in the league in 2019. Left tackle, right tackle, and right guard are positions of strength, but left guard and center are positions of weakness and they have questionable depth if injuries strike.

Grade: B

Edge Defenders

It’s a good thing the Chiefs were so dominant on offense last season, because their defense was horrendous. They finished dead last in first down rate allowed, with their 419 first downs allowed leading the league by a wide margin and only Oakland and Tampa Bay topping the 49 touchdowns they allowed. They had one of the better pass rushes in the league last season, ranking tied for first in the NFL with 52 sacks, but they allowed the 2nd most pass completions (406), the 6th most rushing yards (2,114), and the 2nd most rushing yards per carry (4.97). As good as their offense was, their defensive struggles limited them to only finishing 9th in first down rate differential at 2.98%.

Mahomes doesn’t have quite the same supporting cast around him in 2019 as he had in 2018 and is unlikely to have a record setting year every year, so the Chiefs need their defense to turn things around. The Chiefs also struggled on defense in 2017, finishing 31st in first down rate allowed, so they understandably felt the need to shake things up on defense this off-season. They fired basically their entire defensive staff, including defensive coordinator Bob Sutton, who had been in that role since Andy Reid first took the job with the Chiefs in 2013. Sutton was replaced by former Saints and Giants defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo, who is an experienced coordinator and also was once the head coach of the Rams, but he has had mixed results throughout his career. 

The changes didn’t stop with the coaching staff. Spagnuolo will transition this defense from a 3-4 to a 4-3 and the Chiefs made several significant moves this off-season to try to fit their personnel to their new scheme better. The biggest moves involved getting rid of edge defenders Dee Ford and Justin Houston, who combined for 22 sacks last season, but were seen as a poor fit for the new 4-3 defense. Ironically, both Ford and Houston ended up on teams that primarily run a base 4-3 defense, in San Francisco and Indianapolis respectively. Ford brought back a 2020 second round pick via trade and the Chiefs avoiding having to give him the 5-year, 85.5 million dollar deal the 49ers gave him to stay long-term, while Houston’s release saved the Chiefs 17 million, but Ford and Houston ranked 11th and 12th respectively among edge defenders on Pro Football Focus last season and will be tough to replace.

The Chiefs used the money they freed up by moving on from Ford and Houston to trade for and extend ex-Seahawks defensive end Frank Clark and to sign ex-Saints defensive end Alex Okafor. Clark and Okafor figure to be their starting defensive ends in 2019. Clark has been a strong starter for 3 seasons and is only in his age 26 season. He’s totalled 32 sacks, 29 hits, and a 12.8% pressure rate over those 3 seasons and was PFF’s 21st ranked edge defender in 2018. 

He was very expensive to bring in though, especially compared to what Dee Ford cost the 49ers. Clark was given a 5-year, 104 million dollar extension that makes him the 4th highest paid defensive player in the NFL in terms of average annual salary and the Chiefs also surrendered a 2019 first round pick and a 2020 second round pick via trade to the Seahawks. He should remain a strong starter for years to come, but the Chiefs probably overpaid. I think Dee Ford being a poor scheme fit was overblown, so they would have been better off extending instead.

Okafor was much less expensive than Clark, coming over from the Saints on a 3-year, 17.9 million dollar deal, but he doesn’t nearly have Clark’s upside. A 4th round pick in 2013, Okafor didn’t show much on his rookie contract, but has proven to be a late bloomer, breaking out as solid starter in the past 2 seasons in New Orleans. He started all 26 games he played, playing an average of 46.8 snaps per game, and totalled 8.5 sacks, 15 hits, and a 9.3% pressure rate, while finishing 28th and 37th among edge defenders on PFF. That’s despite the fact that he tore his Achilles late in the 2017 season. Still only in his age 28 season, Okafor should remain a solid starter in Kansas City on a similar snap count.

The Chiefs also added former Browns starting defensive end Emmanuel Ogbah via trade and they are hoping to get more from 2018 2nd round pick Breeland Speaks, who struggled on 475 rookie year snaps (1.5 sacks and an 8.7% pressure rate in 16 games). Ogbah was a second round pick by the Browns in 2016 and he started all 40 games he played in 3 seasons in Cleveland, but he was a pretty mediocre starter and totalled just 12.5 sacks, 17 hits, and a 7.8% pressure rate. It’s possible he takes a step forward in his 4th season in the league in 2019, but that’s far from a guarantee. 

Other potential depth options include 2017 2nd round pick Tanoh Kpassagnon, who has played just 273 snaps in 2 seasons in the league, and veteran free agent acquisition Jeremiah Attaochu, who had 6 sacks, 10 hits, and a 12.5% pressure rate in 2015 with the Chargers, but has played just 408 snaps in 3 seasons since, in part due to injury. Only in his age 26 season, Attaochu still theoretically has bounce back potential, while Kpassagnon still has great physical tools and could take a step forward in his 3rd season in the league. Neither are locks for the final roster, but it wouldn’t be a surprise to see either one carve out a situational role. This is a pretty deep group, but they’re unlikely to be as good as they were last season, when Ford and Houston were arguably the best edge defender duo in the NFL.

Grade: B+

Interior Defenders

The Chiefs’ defense struggled last season even with Ford and Houston playing at a high level, so Kansas City needs the rest of this defense to step up, now with Ford and Houston gone. One thing the Chiefs did this off-season to try to improve the rest of their defense was letting Allen Bailey, who led Chief interior defenders with 848 snaps last season, leave as a free agent and replacing him with 3rd round rookie Khalen Saunders. Saunders might not make a big impact as a rookie, but Bailey didn’t play well last season, managing 6 sacks, but just 4 hits and a 5.9% pressure rate and he struggled against the run as well, so getting rid of him could be addition by subtraction. 

Saunders will compete for a starting defensive tackle job with Xavier Williams and Derrick Nnadi, who played 424 snaps and 448 snaps respectively last season. Both are solid players against the run, but they managed a combined 2.5 sacks, 1 hit, and 5.6% pressure rate last season. Williams was an undrafted free agent in 2015 and last season was his career high in snaps, so he’s probably maxed out as a player, but Nnadi was a 3rd round pick in 2018 and could take a step forward in his 2nd season in the league. The 6-1 317 pounder likely doesn’t have the athleticism to ever develop into a pass rushing threat, but he could develop into a strong run stuffer. The 6-2 309 pound Williams and 6-0 324 Saunders are both bigger defensive tackles as well and is unlikely any of them get much pass rush in 2019. 

Fortunately, Houston and Ford were part of a trio of dominant pass rushers in 2018 and the third member of that trio, defensive tackle Chris Jones, is still on the team. In fact, Jones actually led this team with 15.5 sacks, and he added 14 hits a 14.3% pressure rate as well, despite rushing the passer from the interior. He’s not great against the run, but still finished as Pro Football Focus’ 8th ranked interior defender overall in 2018. The 2016 2nd round pick is no one-year wonder either, finishing 8th among interior defenders on PFF in 2017 as well, and pressuring the quarterback at an 11.7% rate in 3 seasons in the league. 

Only going into his age 25 season, Jones could keep getting better and will likely become one of the highest paid defensive players in the league (upwards of 20 million dollars) on his next contract. Moving on from Ford and Houston was partially about freeing up money long-term to extend Jones, which will likely happen before the start of the season, with Jones going into the final year of his rookie deal in 2019. Arguably the second best interior pass rusher in the league behind Aaron Donald, Jones elevates an otherwise underwhelming position group, even if he isn’t great against the run.

Grade: B


The Chiefs’ defensive front was pretty good last season, led by the trio of Dee Ford, Justin Houston, and Chris Jones, but the back seven had serious problems. If this defense is going to take a step forward in 2019, they’ll need to be better in the back seven, especially their off ball linebackers, which were arguably the worst in the league last season. They didn’t make a major addition, but they signed ex-Cowboy Damien Wilson to a 2-year, 5.75 million dollar deal and sent a 6th round pick to the Jets for middle linebacker Darron Lee, who lost his job when the Jets signed CJ Mosley this off-season.

Wilson has never topped 321 defensive snaps in a season, but he’s a capable run stuffer and plays special teams as well. Lee, meanwhile, could prove to be a steal, as he was a first round pick in 2016, has started 36 games in 3 seasons in the league, and is still only going into his age 25 season. He’s had disciplinary problems and he struggles against the run, but he’s developed into a strong coverage linebacker, finishing 3rd among off ball linebackers in coverage grade on Pro Football Focus last season. Even if he only plays a sub package role, he’ll be a welcome addition for a team with a big need at linebacker. 

Wilson and Lee will compete for playing time with Anthony Hitchens, Reggie Ragland, and Dorian O’Daniel, who finished 1st, 2nd, and 3rd on the team in snaps among linebackers with 944, 583, and 303 respectively last season. O’Daniel wasn’t bad, but the 3rd round rookie didn’t really play that much as purely a situational coverage linebacker, while Hitchens and Ragland finished 95th and 72nd respectively among 96 qualifying off ball linebackers on PFF. 

Hitchens has been inconsistent in his career, but he’s been better in the past, even finishing 20th among off ball linebackers on PFF as recently as 2017. Only going into his age 27 season, he has bounce back potential and could benefit from a switch to a 4-3 defense, which he played in with the Cowboys in his first 4 seasons in the league. Owed a non-guaranteed 8.5 million in 2020, in the third year of a 5-year, 45 million dollar deal, Hitchens needs to bounce back in a big way or this could easily be his final season in Kansas City.

Ragland, meanwhile, was a second round pick by Buffalo in 2016, but hasn’t had a great career, missing his rookie year with a torn ACL, getting traded to the Chiefs from the Bills before ever playing a snap for the team, flashing against the run on 321 snaps in 2017, but then struggling in a larger role in 2018. Already in his age 26 season, he still has some upside, but it’s likely he maxes out as a solid run stuffer, if that. 

I’d expect Hitchens to play every down with Ragland and Lee splitting snaps in the middle based on situation and Wilson playing as a third linebacker in base packages, but these roles will be sorted out in training camp. Dorian O’Daniel could also continue seeing a role as a situational coverage linebacker, which would likely come at the absence of Hitchens’ sub package snaps. This isn’t a strong group, but it would be hard for their linebackers to be worse than last season.

Grade: C


The secondary was also a problem last season and, unlike in their linebacking corps, the Chiefs made significant changes in the secondary this off-season. Their biggest addition was signing safety Tyrann Mathieu to a 3-year, 42 million dollar deal in free agency. Mathieu effectively replaces long-time Chief Eric Berry, who was released ahead of a 12.5 million dollar non-guaranteed salary this off-season, but Berry has barely played in the past two seasons, limited to 169 snaps total due to injury. In Berry’s absence, the Chiefs started four other safeties, Daniel Sorensen (3 starts), Ron Parker (14 starts), Eric Murray (9 starts), and Jordan Lucas (4 starts), but all of them finished below average on Pro Football Focus. 

Mathieu is an obvious upgrade over all four players, but it’s fair to wonder if they overpaid him, making him the highest paid safety in the league in average annual salary. A 3rd round pick in 2013, Mathieu was PFF’s 6th ranked safety as a rookie, but tore his ACL at the end of the season and was limited to 428 underwhelming snaps in 2014. He bounced back to finish 1st among safeties in 2015, but tore his ACL again at the end of that season. The Cardinals still gave him a 5-year, 62.5 million dollar extension the following off-season, but he wasn’t the same in 26 starts from 2016 and 2017 and was cut just 2 years and 21.67 million dollars into that extension. 

Mathieu was then forced to settle for a 1-year, 7 million dollar deal from the Texans last off-season, but, after a 2018 season in which he finished 20th among safeties on PFF, the Chiefs are now valuing him among the top safeties in the league. He hasn’t missed a game in two seasons in the league and he’s still in his prime in his age 27 season, but he hasn’t shown his top form since before his second ACL tear in 2015 and the Chiefs are paying him like he’s one of the top few in the league at his position. He helps this secondary, but at a steep price.

The Chiefs also added Juan Thornhill in the second round of the draft. Two safeties who started last season, Daniel Sorensen and Jordan Lucas, both remain on the roster, but they’re both backup caliber players, so Thornhill is likely to start week 1. Thornhill might not have a great rookie year, but he profiles as a long-term starter and it wouldn’t be hard for him to be an upgrade over the safeties the Chiefs had to start last season. 

The Chiefs also made significant changes at cornerback this off-season, though not necessarily for the better. Steven Nelson and Orlando Scandrick, who weren’t bad on 1,164 snaps and 788 snaps respectively last season, are no longer with the team and the only addition the Chiefs made was signing veteran Bashuad Breeland to a 1-year, 2 million dollar deal (incentives up to 5 million). Breeland will start opposite incumbent 15-game starter Kendall Fuller, but the Chiefs will also be counting on 2018 undrafted rookie Charvarius Ward and 2018 6th round pick Tremon Smith to play a bigger role in their second season in the league. They struggled on just 140 snaps and 74 snaps respectively last season and are no guarantee to be any better in 2019.

Fuller is still probably their best cornerback, although he was a lot better in 2017 with the Redskins than he was in 2018 after he was traded to the Chiefs, falling from 2nd among cornerbacks on PFF to 34th. He played a larger role in 2018, playing 1,078 snaps after playing just 720 snaps as primarily a slot specialist in 2017, but he even had issues on the slot last season, going from 0.74 in yards per slot coverage snap in 2017 (3rd in the NFL) to 1.26 in 2018 (32nd). Still only going into his age 24 season, the 2016 3rd round pick still has a bright future and could easily have somewhat of a bounce back year in 2019. He’ll play outside in two-cornerback formations and move to the slot in sub packages. 

Bashaud Breeland will play outside opposite Fuller in two-cornerback formations and opposite either Charvarius Ward or Tremon Smith in sub packages, with Fuller on the slot. Breeland had an up and down tenure in 4 seasons with the Redskins (58 starts), finishing above average on PFF in 2015 and 2017 and below average in 2014 and 2016, but he still was set to sign a 3-year, 24 million dollar deal with the Panthers last off-season as a free agent, before an off-season injury voided the deal. Breeland eventually ended up taking an incentivized minimum deal from the Packers and struggled on 330 snaps in an injury plagued season. The 2014 4th round pick is still only in his age 27 season and has some bounce back potential, but he’s far from a sure thing and the Chiefs don’t have another good option. They’re better at safety this season, but cornerback figures to be a position of weakness unless one of the young players steps up. 

Grade: B-


The Chiefs were able to mask their significant problems on defense last season with an offense that was one of the best in recent memory, but they probably won’t be quite as good this season. Kareem Hunt is gone, Tyreek Hill is facing suspension, and, as good as Mahomes is, he might not be quite as good as he was last season every year. The Chiefs tried to fix their defense, but they still have a lot of problems on that side of the ball, problems which will become much more noticable if their offense can’t be historically good again. The Chiefs should be able to qualify for the post-season in the AFC, but they’re a little overrated right now. 

Update: The Chiefs will have Tyreek Hill for the full season, but still may find it tough to match last season’s offensive performance and their defense remains a significant concern.

Prediction 10-6, 2nd in AFC West

Team Score: 76.15 (10th in NFL)

Offensive Score: 79.68

Defensive Score: 72.62

Team score is based on a weighted average of individual player grades (certain positions valued higher than others, score out of 100)

Denver Broncos 2019 NFL Season Preview


The Broncos won Super Bowl 50 at the end of the 2015 season, in Peyton Manning’s final season with the team, but Manning really struggled that season, as did backup Brock Osweiler, who made 7 starts while Manning was out with a foot injury. Manning and Osweiler finished the regular season with a combined 76.3 QB rating and Manning wasn’t much better in the post-season after he returned from injury, but their defense was so dominant that it was able to carry the Broncos to a Super Bowl victory. 

In 3 seasons since, the Broncos have started four different quarterbacks, Trevor Siemian, Paxton Lynch, Brock Osweiler, and Case Keenum, none of whom have had much success. Their defense has remained strong, finishing in the top-10 in first down rate allowed in all 3 seasons since their Super Bowl appearance, but it hasn’t been as good as it was in 2015 and, as a result, the Broncos have missed the post-season in all 3 seasons. That might not seem like that long, but 24 of 32 NFL teams have made the post-season in the past 3 years, with the Broncos joining the Bengals, Buccaneers, Browns, Jets, Redskins, Cardinals, and 49ers as the only teams that have not made the post-season in the past 3 seasons. 

The Broncos’ quarterback problems have not been for lack of trying. When Manning retired after the Super Bowl, the Broncos traded up in the first round to select Paxton Lynch 26th overall to be his long-term replacement. Due to a combination of injury and ineffectiveness, Lynch made just 4 underwhelming starts in 2 seasons in Denver and was sent packing last off-season when he continued not to make any progress. The Broncos then turned to the free agent market, signing veteran journeyman Case Keenum to a 2-year, 36 million dollar deal, following a career best year in which he had a 98.3 QB rating and led the Vikings to the NFC Championship as a backup quarterback.

Keenum started all 16 games in 2018, but he much more closely resembled the quarterback he was prior to his surprise 2017 season, when he had a 77.8 QB rating in the first 5 seasons of his career (24 starts). Keenum completed just 62.3% of his passes for an average of 6.64 YPA, 18 touchdowns, and 15 interceptions, while finishing 26th out of 39 qualifying quarterbacks on Pro Football Focus. That lead the Broncos to give up on him after 1 year and 22 million, sending him to the Redskins for a swap of late round picks.

Now the Broncos are moving forward with off-season acquisition Joe Flacco as the starter. The Broncos only had to give up a 4th round pick to acquire Flacco, but he has a salary of 18.5 million in 2019 and would be owed 20.25 million in 2020 and 24.25 million in 2021 if the Broncos keep him on the roster, so they’re paying a significant price to bring in the ex-Raven. Flacco might have been worth that salary in his prime, but he’s been a pretty underwhelming starter in the past 4 seasons, completing just 63.9% of his passes for an average of 6.32 YPA, 64 touchdowns, and 46 interceptions. 

Part of his statistical struggles can be blamed on his lack of offensive supporting cast in Baltimore, but Flacco has also finished below average among quarterbacks on PFF in all 4 seasons, with his last above average season coming in 2014, when he finished 10th among quarterbacks. His decline led to the Ravens using a first round pick on Lamar Jackson in the 2018 NFL Draft, who took over as the starter midway through last season, after Flacco completed 61.2% of his passes for an average of 6.50 YPA, 12 touchdowns, and 6 interceptions in 9 starts. Now going into his age 34 season, it’s unlikely Flacco suddenly finds his old form with the Broncos. 

The Broncos also used a second round pick on Missouri quarterback Drew Lock. Lock was seen by some as a potential first round pick and has the upside to develop into a long-term starter. He’s unlikely to see much action as a rookie, but his contract (about 6.8 million over 4 years) is much more cap friendly than Flacco and if he shows well behind the scenes it wouldn’t be a surprise to see the Broncos move on from Flacco next off-season, in favor of starting the cheaper Lock. Lock also could be a solid backup option in case Flacco gets hurt this season. Neither he nor Flacco are unlikely to be an average or better starting quarterback in 2019 though, so this figures to be a position of weakness again.

Grade: C+

Running Backs

Even with mediocre quarterback play, the Broncos were better than their 6-10 record suggested last season. They had one of the toughest schedules in the league to start the season (7 of their first 10 games were against eventual playoff teams) and, when their schedule got easier down the stretch, they lost a bunch of players for the season due to injury and were not nearly the same team they were at the beginning of the season. They lost right guard Ronald Leary in week 6, center Matt Paradis in week 9, and both cornerback Chris Harris and wide receiver Emmanuel Sanders in week 13. Those four were among their best players and were seriously missed. Earlier in the year they beat the Chargers and Seahawks and came within a touchdown against the Chiefs (twice), Rams, and Texans, but down the stretch they lost games to the Raiders and 49ers. 

All things considered, the Broncos didn’t have that bad of a season in 2018 and they finished better than their record would suggest in first down differential at +0.47%, 15th in the NFL. Their defense, which ranked 9th in first down rate allowed, was their best unit, but their offense wasn’t that bad, finishing 19th in first down rate. The biggest reason for that was probably the play of lead running back Philip Lindsay, who averaged 5.40 yards per carry on 192 carries, the 3rd highest YPC average of any running back in the league (minimum 100 carries). Lindsay also ended up suffering a serious injury, but because it happened during week 16 he only ended up missing one game. He’s missed a lot of this off-season as his wrist healed, but is fully expected to be ready for training camp and shouldn’t have any long-term complications.

Lindsay’s strong season really came out of nowhere. He was not one of the 20 running backs drafted in 2018 and his size at 5-8 190 does not suggest he’s lead back material, but he had a strong off-season, won a rotational role at the running back position to start the season, and ran so well that they had to keep giving him more and more action. He topped 15 carries just 3 times on the season and at his size he could probably never be a true feature back, but he’s one of the fastest running backs in the NFL and he’s not a bad receiver either, adding a 35/241/1 slash line through the air. He was Pro Football Focus’ 10th ranked running back and was the first undrafted offensive player ever to make the Pro Bowl as a rookie.

It’s unlikely Lindsay will be quite as effective as a runner in 2019 though, for a few reasons. For one, it’s very tough to average 5+ yards per carry in back-to-back seasons. 63 of the last 69 running backs to top 5 yards per carry on 150+ carries did not repeat the feat the following season, including much more proven runners than Lindsay. Two, his average was kind of distorted by a few long runs. He finished just 22nd in running back carry success rate at 49%, which isn’t bad, but it’s not as good as his average would suggest. The final reason is simply that he was passed on by the entire league a year ago (including the Broncos) and, while the NFL certainly isn’t 100% with these things, I’ve seen plenty of former late round picks and undrafted free agents have strong seasons early in their career and eventually regress. Lindsay should still have a strong year, but I wouldn’t expect him to have the same average per carry as he did last season.

Number two running back Royce Freeman was also a rookie last season. Drafted in the 3rd round, Freeman was expected to have a bigger rookie year role, but it was hard for the Broncos to take Lindsay off the field and Freeman ended up finishing with just 130 carries in 14 games. He only averaged 4.01 yards per carry, but he didn’t finish much behind Lindsay in carry success rate, ranking 29th at 46%, and he has the size at 6-0 228 to be an effective complement for the smaller, speedier Lindsay. 

These two backs should continue working in tandem in 2019 and could see a more even carry split if Lindsay’s average regresses and Freeman takes a step forward. The Broncos also had a pretty uneven pass/run split last season (622 pass plays to 393 run plays) and will probably run the ball more with a new coaching staff coming in, led by defensive minded head coach Vic Fangio. Lindsay and Freeman could both have productive seasons on the ground.

Freeman doesn’t do much in the passing game (14 catches for 72 yards), but the Broncos still have passing down specialist Devontae Booker, who lead this team with 38 catches by a running back last season. A 4th round pick by the Broncos in 2016, Booker hasn’t been that effective as a runner in his career, averaging 3.81 yards per carry on 87 career carries, but he’s topped 30 catches in all 3 seasons in the league and should continue having a role as a passing down specialist. As long as Freeman and Lindsay are healthy, he won’t be needed much as a runner (34 carries in 2018). 

Grade: A-

Receiving Corps

Not only did the Broncos lose Emmanuel Sanders to injury down the stretch, but they also had already traded away veteran wide receiver Demaryius Thomas at that point, leaving them with a really thin receiving corps. Down the stretch, the Broncos’ top-3 receivers were second round rookie Courtland Sutton, fourth round rookie DaeSean Hamtilon, and 2017 undrafted free agent Tim Patrick, who might as well have been a rookie, since he didn’t play a single snap in 2017.

Sanders’ injury was an Achilles tear and he suffered it in December, making him very questionable for the start of the season (roughly 9 months from the injury). The Broncos had the opportunity to move on from him this off-season, rather than pay him 10.25 million non-guaranteed in the final year of his contract, but without him they wouldn’t have another veteran wide receiver. He was on pace for a 95/1157/5 slash line when he got hurt last season, which would have been his fourth 1000+ yard season in the past 5 seasons, but, not only is he coming off of a serious injury, he’s also going into his age 32 season, making his 2019 projection murky even if he can return for week 1. 

Even with Sanders still on the team, the Broncos will still need their young receivers to play a big role in 2019. Courtland Sutton was their top target down the stretch last season and is likely to be a starter regardless of whether or not Sanders is healthy. He only caught 50% of the passes thrown to him as a rookie, but he showed his deep ball ability with 16.8 yards per catch, 7th most in the NFL (minimum 30 catches). He finished with a 42/704/4 slash line and could easily take a step forward in his 2nd season in the league. Depending on Sanders’ health, it wouldn’t surprise me to see Sutton lead this team in receiving.

DaeSean Hamilton and Tim Patrick are likely to compete for reserve roles and would likely need Sanders to miss time to lock down a significant role. Neither showed much last season, averaging 0.88 and 1.29 yards per route run respectively and managing just 30/243/2 and 23/315/1 slash lines respectively, but Hamilton has the higher upside and is the more natural fit on the slot, so he should be considered the favorite for the third receiver job. Patrick could still see a rotational role, but his playing time is probably going to be dependant on Sanders’ availability.

In order to mask their issues at wide receiver, the Broncos will probably try to emphasize the tight end in the passing game more this season, after completing just 68 passes to tight ends in 2018. 31 of those 68 completions were to Jeff Heuerman, who lead Bronco tight ends with a 31/281/2 slash line, despite being limited to 11 games by injury. Heuerman returns this season and the Broncos also used the 20th overall pick on Iowa tight end Noah Fant (after trading down from 10). Fant isn’t much of a blocker, but he is incredibly athletic and should play ahead of Heuerman as a pass catcher. Heuerman will still be their primary run blocker and could see some balls in two-tight end sets, though pass catching is not as strength for him, as he has just 49 catches in 37 career games, since being drafted in the 3rd round in 2015. 

The Broncos also have Jake Butt in the mix as the third tight end. Butt was seen as a likely second round pick in the 2017 NFL Draft before tearing his ACL in a bowl game and falling to the Broncos in the 5th round. He didn’t play as a rookie because of the injury and right as he seemed to be rounding into form in 2018 he tore his ACL again, his 3rd ACL tear dating back to college. He’s caught just 8 passes on 97 snaps in 3 career games, but still potentially has upside and, even with a pair of tight ends currently ahead of him on the depth chart, he could carve out a role in an unsettled receiving corps.

Grade: C+

Offensive Line

The Broncos’ offensive line was probably their most injury plagued unit. Not only did they lose guard Ron Leary and center Matt Paradis for the final 10 games and 7 games of the season respectively, but right tackle Jared Veldheer also missed 4 games during the season. Veldheer isn’t as valuable as Leary or Paradis, but he was still a capable starter. Leary returns for 2019, but Paradis and Veldheer are both no longer with the team, so the Broncos are reworking their offensive line.

The Broncos made a pair of big additions this off-season, signing ex-Dolphins right tackle Ja’Wuan James to a 4-year, 51 million dollar deal and using a second round pick on Kansas State’s Dalton Risner. James will replace Veldheer at right tackle. He’s overpaid as the second highest paid right tackle in the league, as he’s never finished higher than 27th among offensive tackles on Pro Football Focus, but he’s younger and better than Veldheer. The former first round pick is only going into his age 27 season and has earned an average or better grade from PFF in all 5 seasons in the league (62 starts). He should remain a solid starter in 2019, but the Broncos could have gotten a comparable player at a cheaper price.

Risner, meanwhile, played both right tackle and center in college, but is expected to play right guard for the Broncos. Connor McGovern started last season at right guard, but moved to center down the stretch with Paradis out and that appears to be where the Broncos want to leave him. McGovern was a 5th round pick in 2016 and he made all 16 starts last season, but he wasn’t particularly good at either position and he was even worse in the first 5 starts of his career in 2017, when he finished the season as the starter at right guard. McGovern will likely struggle as a 16-game starter at center, but, aside from flipping Risner and McGovern, the Broncos don’t have another good option at center and McGovern wouldn’t necessarily be better at guard. Both players would be clear downgrades from Paradis, who was PFF’s 2nd ranked center last season before getting hurt. 

Ron Leary is expected to return from injury week 1, but, like Emmanuel Sanders, he’s coming off of a torn Achilles. That’s not as serious of an injury for an offensive lineman and his injury came two months earlier, but Leary is also getting up there in age, going into his age 30 season, and he didn’t play all that well before getting hurt last season. He was PFF’s 16th ranked guard in 2016 and their 15th ranked guard in 2017, so he has some bounce back potential, but his best days could be behind him. Even still, he should be a solid starter and an upgrade on his injury replacement Elijah Wilkinson, a 2017 undrafted free agent who was underwhelming in his first 7 career starts last season. 

Left tackle Garett Bolles finishes off this offensive line. The 20th overall pick in the 2017 NFL Draft, Bolles has made all 32 starts in 2 seasons in the league and there’s been a lot to like, as he’s allowed just 10 sacks and 16 hits total and is a solid run blocker as well, but he’s also committed a position leading 28 penalties. Bolles was an older rookie and is already going into his age 27 season, so it’s unclear if he’ll ever be able to get his penalty problem under control, but even with 13 penalties he was PFF’s 33rd ranked offensive tackle last season and he still has a high ceiling if he can learn to play more under control and still be effective. Even with a few off-season additions, this is an underwhelming group upfront.

Grade: B-

Edge Defenders

As mentioned, the Broncos had a strong defense once again in 2018, finishing 9th in first down rate allowed at 34.70%. The strength of their defense was the edge defender position. Not only were starting edge defenders Von Miller and Bradley Chubb the only edge defender duo in the NFL to both have double digit sacks, but the Broncos also had good depth at the position, as Shaq Barrett has the talent to start for a lot of teams and Shane Ray is a former first round pick. Those two were limited to just 276 snaps and 253 snaps respectively last season because of how good the duo of Miller and Chubb were. Barrett and Ray are no longer with the team, making depth a problem, but Miller and Chubb remain as the starters, which is obviously more important.

Miller is the better and more proven of the two and is one of the top defensive players in the entire NFL. Since being drafted 2nd overall in 2011, Miller has made 120 starts in 8 seasons in the league, totalling 98 sacks, 111 hits, and a 15.9% pressure rate, and he has finished in the top-4 at his position on Pro Football Focus in all 8 seasons. His 98 sacks over the past 8 seasons lead the league over that time period. He’s now going into his age 30 season and could start to decline over the next few seasons, but he showed no signs of decline in 2018, finishing 4th among edge defenders on PFF and totalling 14.5 sacks, 11 hits, and a 12.6% pressure rate. Even if he’s not quite at his best in 2019, he should still be one of the top edge defenders in the league.

Chubb also had a strong pass rushing season last year with 12 sacks, 9 hits, and a 12.5% pressure rate, but he only finished slightly above average on PFF, as much of his pass rush production came as a result of having Miller opposite him taking on double teams and forcing the quarterback off of his spot frequently. Chubb was the 5th overall pick in the 2018 NFL Draft though, so he still has a sky high upside and he showed a lot of promise as a rookie. He could easily take a step forward in 2019, even if that doesn’t necessarily lead to more pass rush production. He also needs to improve his tackling, as his 11 missed tackles were 4th most at his position last season.

Depth is now a serious concern with Barrett and Ray gone and no obvious replacements added. Jeff Holland, who played 43 snaps as an undrafted rookie last season, is the only other returning edge defender who played a snap last season. He’ll likely have a bigger role in his second season in the league, whether he’s ready for a bigger role or not. Fifth round rookie Justin Hollins could also be in the mix. Miller and Chubb won’t come off the field often (13th and 14th respectively in snaps played among edge defenders last season), but when they do their absence will be missed and they’ll be in big trouble if either one suffered a significant injury.

Grade: A-

Interior Defenders

Even with Miller and Chubb combining for 26.5 sacks, the Broncos still ranked just 8th in the NFL with 44 sacks last season, as a result of their inability to get pass rush from the interior. No interior defender topped 3 sacks on the season and their peripheral pass rush stats are not much better. While Miller and Chubb both topped 50 pressures on the season, no other Bronco had more than 27 and those were from Derek Wolfe, who only reached that total because he was an every down player who played 710 snaps on the season. He had an underwhelming pressure rate at 6.1% and only added 1.5 sacks and 5 hits in 16 games. 

A 7-year veteran, Wolfe had a solid pass rushing stretch from 2015-2016, with 11 sacks, 19 hits, and a 9.8% pressure rate, but his pressure rate in his other 5 seasons is a combined 6.4% and he’s finished below average as a pass rusher on Pro Football Focus in all 5 of those other seasons. He’s always been a strong player against the run, but he can’t be depended on for consistent pass rush. He’d be best as a pure base package player, but he’ll likely continue playing an every down role, for lack of a better option. He’s owed 9 million non-guaranteed in 2019 and the Broncos likely would have let him go if they weren’t planning on continuing to use him in a similar role. 

In order to boost their interior pass rush, the Broncos used their 3rd round pick on Ohio State’s Dre’Mont Jones. Jones was part of a deep defensive line class and easily could have gone in the top-50 picks, so he was a great value in the third round. The 6-3 281 pounder lacks ideal size against the run, but he was one of the most productive interior pass rushers in college football last season and could contribute immediately as a situational interior rusher. 

Adam Gotsis will likely remain the starter opposite Wolfe in base packages. He played 513 snaps last season and 555 snaps in 2017, but ideally he’d be a pure base package player this season. A 2016 2nd round pick, Gotsis has developed into a solid run stuffer and he did lead the interior with 3 sacks last season, but he also had just a 5.7% pressure rate and he has a 4.5% pressure rate for his career. Already going into his age 27 season, it’s unlikely he suddenly develops into a strong pass rusher, but he’s a solid base package starter.

The one loss on this defensive line is nose tackle Domata Peko, who gave them strong play against the run on 523 snaps as the starter last season. With Peko gone, Shelby Harris and Zach Kerr will compete for the nose tackle job. Harris doesn’t have traditional nose tackle size at 6-3 300, but he has experience at the position and is the better player, both as a run stuffer and also as a pass rusher. He was just a 7th round pick in 2014, but he’s shown a lot of promise over the past 2 seasons on a combined 907 snaps and could easily prove to be a late bloomer. He’s totalled 7 sacks, 12 hits, and a 7.3% pressure rate, while earning an above average grade from PFF as a run stopper in both seasons, including an 18th ranked finish in 2018. He’s deserving of a bigger role and could stay on the field even in sub packages.

Kerr, meanwhile, has traditional nose tackle size at 6-2 334, but is not as good against the run and only has a 5.6% career pressure rate. He’s also never topped 394 snaps in a season in 5 seasons in the league. He has a shot to win the starting nose tackle job, but Harris seems like the better option. The loser of that position battle will remain as a rotational reserve. This is a solid group of interior defenders, but they lack a standout player and could struggle to get consistent pass rush again.

Grade: B


The Broncos didn’t have as many injuries on defense as they had on offense last season, but they were without middle linebacker Brandon Marshall for 5 games. Marshall made 63 starts for the Broncos over the past 5 seasons and was an above average starter in his prime, but he was only an adequate starter even when on the field last season and the Broncos opted not to bring him back for his age 30 season in 2019 at a 7 million dollar non-guaranteed salary. Even though Marshall wasn’t great last season, he’ll still be missed, as the Broncos did nothing to replace him. 

Todd Davis was the other starting linebacker opposite Marshall in the middle of the Broncos’ 3-4 defense last season. He was arguably their best linebacker and will remain in the same role. Davis has made 45 starts over the past 3 seasons, but had struggled in coverage until last season. Always a solid run stuffer, Davis seemed to put it all together in 2018, finishing 24th on Pro Football Focus among off ball linebackers on a career high 842 snaps. A 2014 undrafted free agent, it’s possible Davis regresses a little bit this season, but he’s still only in his age 27 season and should remain an adequate starter at the very least for the next few seasons. 

The other middle linebacker spot is the bigger question mark. The Broncos will probably start 2018 4th round pick Josey Jewell in base packages. He played 460 rookie year snaps and was a solid player against the run, but struggled in coverage and was limited mostly to base packages even when Marshall got hurt. In the 5 games Marshall missed last season, the Broncos used safety Su’a Cravens as a coverage linebacker. A 2nd round pick by the Redskins back in 2016, Cravens hasn’t shown much in 3 seasons in the league, limited to 411 snaps total, in part due to injury, but he’s still only going into his age 24 season and has the potential to develop into a good coverage linebacker. 

Cravens played 23.4 snaps per game when Marshall was out last season and will likely see a similar role in 2019. Jewell, meanwhile, played 25.3 snaps per game with Marshall in the lineup and 36.4 snaps per game with Marshall out of the lineup last season and should be much closer to the latter number now in his second season in the league. This group should be solid against the run, but covering tight ends and running backs over the middle may be a problem unless Cravens has a breakout year. 

Grade: C+


The other big injury the Broncos had on defense was losing Chris Harris to a broken leg week 13. Behind Von Miller, he’s probably their best defensive player, so he was a huge loss and his absence was a big part of the reason why they ended the season on a 4 game losing streak. As consistent year in and year out as any cornerback in the league, Harris has finished in the top-18 among cornerbacks on Pro Football Focus in all 8 seasons in the league, including 5 seasons in the top-5 (5th in 2018), and he plays equally well on the slot and outside. 

Despite that, Harris could be entering the end of his time in Denver. Harris is going into the final year of his contract in his age 30 season and the Broncos did not give him the long-term extension he was looking for this off-season. They did give him a well deserved raise for 2019 from 8.76 million to 12.05 million, in order to avoid a holdout, but the Broncos also made a couple of other big long-term investments at the cornerback position this off-season, rather than extending Harris, so it looks likely he’ll be playing elsewhere in 2020 and he could be moved at the trade deadline if the Broncos get off to a slow start.

Not only did the Broncos make a pair of big additions at cornerback this off-season, but both cornerbacks they added can also play the slot, which has traditionally been where Harris plays in 3+ cornerback sets. Harris was 4th among cornerbacks last season, only allowing 0.75 yards allowed per slot coverage snap, but the Broncos still added ex-Bear Bryce Callahan on a 3-year, 21 million dollar deal. Callahan ranked 2nd last season among cornerbacks with 0.69 yards allowed per slot coverage snap. Kareem Jackson, meanwhile, wasn’t far behind them at 1.14 and signed a 3-year, 33 million dollar deal. 

Callahan is the best of three on the slot and doesn’t have the size to play outside at 5-9 185, so he’ll likely be their primary slot cornerback. Undrafted in 2015, Callahan has gotten better in every season in the league and finished 2018 as PFF’s 11th ranked cornerback on 676 snaps. In addition to his coverage ability, he also is a good blitzer off the edge, with 4 sacks and 4 hits on just 56 career blitzes. He’s arguably the best pure slot cornerback in the entire NFL and is paid like it. 

Jackson has experience at outside cornerback and safety as well as on the slot. He’ll likely start outside opposite Harris, but the Broncos have already discussed moving him to safety long-term and, going into his age 31 season, he could see some action at safety in obvious passing situations this season. Jackson has been a solid starter for years (124 starts in 9 seasons in the league) and finished last season 14th in coverage grade on PFF, but he could begin to decline over the next couple seasons. On the occasions Jackson plays safety, they’ll likely play Isaac Yiadom outside. Yiadom struggled mightily on 264 snaps as a rookie last season, but the Broncos are still high on the 2018 3rd round pick’s upside.

Part of the reason why Jackson could see some action at safety in 2019 is that they got rid of Darian Stewart, a 14-game starter in 2018, rather than paying him 5 million non-guaranteed for his age 31 season. Stewart struggled, but the Broncos didn’t do much to replace him and instead will turn to 2016 6th round pick Will Parks. Parks has shown potential in 3 seasons in the league, but has never been an every down safety, seeing action at both slot cornerback and linebacker throughout his career. He should be close to an every down player in 2019, but if he struggles Jackson could see more action at safety. 

Justin Simmons, a 16-game starter at safety in 2018, returns and will continue to start. A 3rd round pick by the Broncos in 2016, Simmons is a strong run stuffer, but has some struggles in coverage, especially last season, which led to him finishing 77th out of 101 qualifying safeties on PFF. He ranked 30th overall among safeties as a 13-game starter in 2017 and, still only in his age 26 season, Simmons obviously has bounce back potential. With some needed additions made at cornerback in Kareem Jackson and Bryce Callahan, the Broncos should have an improved secondary in 2019.

Grade: A-


The Broncos are banking on Joe Flacco being a significant upgrade on Case Keenum and leading this team back to the post-season. Based in his play over the past few seasons, that seems unlikely. This team was better than their 6-10 record in 2018, but if they’re going to get back into the post-season it’s going to be because of the players at other positions besides quarterback. Their defense should be strong again, but they have issues in the receiving corps and on the offensive line and might not be quite as effective on the ground. They won’t be a bad team, but there are other more talented teams in the AFC with a better shot of securing a wild card spot. 

Prediction: 5-11, 3rd in AFC West

Team Score: 72.94 (25th in NFL)

Offensive Score: 70.68

Defensive Score: 75.20

Team score is based on a weighted average of individual player grades (certain positions valued higher than others, score out of 100)