Dmitri Patterson struggled mightily as a starter in 2010 with the Eagles, ranking 95th among ProFootballFocus’ 100 eligible cornerbacks, but settled in to a nickel back role with the Browns in 2011. The Browns and Patterson were undoubtedly looking at Richard Marshall’s deal when they agreed to terms as they got the exact same deal (3 years, 16 million, with 6 million in guarantees).
At first glance, they’re comparable players. Marshall allowed a completion percentage of 51.9% last season, Patterson allowed one of 52.2%. Marshall allowed 7.3 YPA, Patterson allowed 6.4 YPA. Marshall allowed 2 touchdowns to 3 interceptions, Patterson didn’t have one of either. Marshall allowed a QB rating of 64.9, Patterson allowed one of 72.3.
In fact, Patterson actually ranked slightly higher in ProFootballFocus’ rankings (36th to 52th). However, Patterson doesn’t have Marshall’s ability to step in as a starter when needed nor does he have Marshall’s ability to play free safety. Patterson is essentially stuck in the nickel back slot. For the reason, he wasn’t worth as much as Marshall. Unlike the B I gave the Marshall deal, this is a C.
Grade: C
Football Fan Spot 