Vikings Draft Visits

 

DT Chase Baker (Boise State)

WR Justin Blackmon (Oklahoma State)

CB Ron Brooks (LSU)

S DJ Campbell (California)

CB Morris Claiborne (LSU)

OT Tom Compton (South Dakota)

WR Michael Floyd (Notre Dame)

TE James Hanna (Oklahoma)

CB Casey Hayward (Vanderbilt)

WR Stephen Hill (Georgia Tech)

WR Alshon Jeffery (South Carolina)

S Trumaine Johnson (Montana)

OT Matt Kalil (USC)

CB Dre Kirkpatrick (Alabama)

OT Jonathan Martin (Stanford)

DT Dontari Poe (Memphis)

G Amini Silatolu (Midwestern State)

CB Lionel Smith (Texas A&M)

K Greg Zuerlein (Missouri Western State)

 

Vikings Draft Grades

 

12. QB Christian Ponder D

I’m not going to give this one an F because they’re at least trying to add a quarterback. But come on, Christian Ponder #12? Really? Ponder has major trouble with anything more than 15 yards downfield and he doesn’t have the upside of a Jake Locker or a Blaine Gabbert so this one is a borderline failure.

43. TE Kyle Rudolph B+

I’m not going to argue that tight end was their biggest non-quarterback need, but Visanthe Shiancoe is a marginal player and going into a contract year. Plus, the Vikings want to run more two tight end sets. Rudolph was also one of the best available.

106. DT Christian Ballard A

Ballard slips because of his positive drug test, but he’s a great value at this point in the 4th round. I’m not making a huge deal about his positive drug test because he is a non-quarterback and it was just weed. Ballard is a great value and fills a huge hole.

139. CB Brandon Burton A

Another great value getting Burton, a borderline 2nd rounder in my book, in the 5th. He also filled a need. Chris Cook struggled as a rookie. Antoine Winfield will be 34 this offseason. Cedric Griffin can’t stay healthy. Burton could wind up a starter for this team in time.

168. OT DeMarcus Love A

I love Love’s upside here in the 6th round. He’s raw, but he has left tackle upside and as a 6th rounder, that’s a great value, especially for a team that needs it. I don’t know how much longer Bryant McKinnie can stay on the left side and on the right side, where Bryant McKinnie could later play, Phil Loadholt is liability and should be moved inside to guard where there’s a giant hole right now. If Love pans out, they can upgrade 3 offensive line spots at once and just ask Brett Favre how badly this line needs to be upgraded. Excellent pick.

170. S Mistral Raymond C+

There were better safeties available as I had Raymond just outside my top 300, but there’s no denying that incumbent starter Madieu Williams is terrible in coverage and needs to be replaced ASAP.

172. C Brandon Fusco A

Another offensive line upgrade. Fusco is a very good value here in the 6th round and can take over for center John Sullivan sometime during year 1. I always say you can find good guard and center prospects in the mid rounds. Fusco is one of them. He can also play both guard spots if that’s where they decide his future is.

200. OLB Ross Homan A

Ben Leber is marginal and a free agent. Homan is a 4th or 5th round value and could end up being a starter for this team long term. Another excellent value.

215. DE D’Aundre Reed C+

Defensive end was a need with Ray Edwards having one foot out the door and Everson Griffen busy getting arrested, but I think there were better ones available. I didn’t have Reed, a rotational end at Arizona behind Brooks Reed and Ricky Elmore, in my top 300.

236. WR Stephen Burton A

Sidney Rice could be a free agent depending on the new CBA rules and given Minnesota’s problems at quarterback, no one would blame him for leaving. Burton helps give them depth behind Percy Harvin and Bernard Berrian and is a great value in the 7th round.

Overall:

I think taking Christian Ponder at 12 might have been the biggest reach of the whole first round (along with James Carpenter at 25), but unlike Seattle, at least they reached for a quarterback and I loved almost every other pick they made. In Kyle Rudolph, they’re getting a future starter at tight end. In Ballard and Burton I think they’re getting future key depth players, if not starters at defensive tackle and cornerback. In DeMarcus Love, they’re getting a guy with the upside to be their franchise left tackle. In Brandon Fusco, I think they’re getting a future starter at center. In Stephen Burton, I think they’re getting a needed depth receiver with the upside to be a starter. That’s not a bad haul at all. They didn’t fill all of their needs, but this team has so many that doing so would have been impossible. They did fill a need with every single selection and they had very few picks that were reaches by my board. They also had a few that were flat out steals. That first round pick sours this draft for me, but I’m still giving it a very high grade and who knows, if Ponder pans out, we could look back at Minnesota as the big winners of the 2011 NFL Draft in a few years.

Grade: B+

 

Vikings Draft 2012

4. OT Matt Kalil A

I mocked Matt Kalil to the Vikings in my final mock draft because I thought their interest in Morris Claiborne was just a smokescreen to try to get someone to move up. I didn’t think any team would actually be stupid enough to take Claiborne over Kalil in their situation. Looks like I was right. The Vikings made the smart move as it would be incredibly stupid not to give your first round quarterback a fair shot to prove himself and give yourself a fair shot to evaluate him.

The Vikings aren’t going to be very good this year no matter what, but they need to be able to come out of the season knowing whether Ponder is the guy going forward or not because I have a feeling they’ll be in a situation where a top quarterback prospect is available to them next season. They simply couldn’t evaluate him under the circumstances he played in last season. Props to the Vikings for taking the right guy and also props for getting the Browns to trade up for a guy they didn’t need to trade up for.

29. S Harrison Smith A

Another reason why Morris Claiborne didn’t make any sense to the Vikings: the Vikings run a cover 2. The whole point of a cover 2 is to you don’t need elite cornerbacks to run it. Cornerbacks almost always have safety help over the top. Too bad the Vikings’ safeties were absolute shit last season. This safety class falls off a cliff after the top 2 guys so it was very smart of the Vikings to move up and insure they could get Smith, especially since it didn’t cost them any more than what they got from Cleveland to move down from 3 to 4.

66. CB Josh Robinson A

Another reason why Morris Claiborne didn’t make any sense to the Vikings: this was an incredibly deep cornerback class. Robinson was a 2nd round prospect in my book so he’s a solid value at the top of the 3rd.

118. WR Jarius Wright B

In order to help them evaluate Christian Ponder, they needed receiver help. However, Wright was a slight reach by my board and I don’t think he’s an outside receiver at the next level. They already have a slot guy in Percy Harvin.

128. TE Rhett Ellison C+

Ellison is a great football player, but they already have a fullback and they spent a 2nd round pick on a tight end last year and another 25 million on another one this year so I don’t see where Ellison fits. At the very least, he’s going to be a good special teamer, but the Vikings had bigger needs than that in the 4th round.

134. WR Greg Childs A

Childs is more of an outside receiver than his former (and current) teammate Greg Childs. He’s also a better value.

139. CB Robert Blanton B

The Vikings sure do love golden domers: Smith, Blanton, Kyle Rudolph, John Carlson. They did need another defensive back and Blanton can play both safety and cornerback, but this is a little early for him.

175. K Blair Walsh B+

I had Blair Walsh as a draftable kicker and Ryan Longwell is getting up there in age, but he’s also under contract for 3 more years and he was solid last year. I don’t believe in carrying two kickers, so I don’t quite know what they’re doing here.

210. MLB Audie Cole A-

Cole is a great value in the 7th, but he doesn’t cover well. That’s a problem because the Vikings already have a bunch of linebackers who can’t cover and they run a cover 2 scheme that relies on linebackers being able to cover. It’s just a 7th rounder though and he’s a great value at a position of need.

219. DE Trevor Guyton A

Guyton can play inside or outside depending on where they put Christian Ballard and they needed a defensive lineman like that. I had a 5th round grade on Guyton so he’s a great value in the 7th.

I already went into detail why I love the Matt Kalil pick. Same with the Harrison Smith pick and the Josh Robinson pick. I’m not loving the Blair Walsh pick and I don’t think Audie Cole and Jarius Wright were the best fits for their situations at those respective positions, but this was a very strong draft which should make the Vikings a better team in the long term. At least they’ll be able to evaluate Ponder adequately this year and if he doesn’t succeed, they’ll probably have a high pick to replace him and that high pick will have a good left tackle protecting his blindside. They also filled some major holes on defense, especially in the secondary. I think they got at least 3 starters out of this draft.

Grade: A 

Vikings/Bears Preview

By Ryan Glab 

Bears offense vs. Vikings defense

Last week against the worst run defense in the NFL, the Bears managed just 62 yards on 24 carries between Matt Forte and Chester Taylor, a 2.5 average. The most discouraging thing is that the Bears stayed committed to the run game and still couldn’t have success. This week the Bears face the Vikings’ No. 6 run defense and I’d be surprised if they ran the ball more than 12-15 times for anywhere between 35-45 yards. Of course, one broken play can skew those statistics, but that would be about average production for them. Mike Martz figures to dial up quite a few passing plays in this one, especially if the Bears are down early. Minnesota is slightly more susceptible to the pass, but by the slimmest of margins. The Vikings are mostly healthy on the defensive side of the ball and won’t be missing any key players. After having an unusually slow start to the season with just one sack in the team’s first seven games, defensive end Jared Allen registered two and a half sacks last week against Arizona and just might have gotten the jump-start he needed to return to Pro Bowl form. Allen is joined on the line by the familiar faces — and enormous wide bodies — of tackles Pat and Kevin Williams and end Ray Edwards. Of the team’s 12 sacks — which is the fourth-lowest mark in the league — the defensive line has eight of them, which means those guys are going to bring the heat. This game reminds me an awful lot of the New York Giants one in which the Giants recorded 10 sacks against the Bears, most of which came from just the front four. Offensive line coach Mike Tice knows the challenge his unit has in protecting Cutler against the Vikings’ defensive line and he said this week, “We’re going to find out if we’re man enough.” I don’t question the will or mental toughness of the offensive linemen, but I do have my reservations about their talent and physical toughness. Another thing to keep an eye on is that center Olin Kreutz missed practices this week, although he did participate on Friday, and he’s likely to play Sunday, but who knows how effective he’ll be. For the Bears to avoid getting Cutler concussed again, they need to get the ball out of his hands quickly and probably utilize Greg Olsen, Matt Forte, and Chester Taylor early and often. The Vikings have the No. 5 overall defense in the league and I see a lot of struggles for the Bears offense.

Advantage: Vikings

Bears defense vs. Vikings offense

If the Bears are going to beat their division rivals, the game has to be won on this side of the ball. The Bears are ranked No. 8 overall on defense, which is incredible if you think about it because that ranking is based on yards allowed and the defensive scheme they run normally yields a lot of yards. That’s reflected in their pass defense, which is allowing an average of 225.8 passing yards per game and is currently ranked 19th. What’s most impressive is the way the Bears have defended the run this season. The Bears began the season with a solid effort against the Lions which landed them in the top spot and they haven’t wavered much since, never falling out of the Top 6, if memory serves. They’re currently ranked No. 3 while allowing just 83.9 rushing yards per game. They’re also yielding just 3.5 yards per carry, third-best in the league. Here’s an ironic statistic: the Bears have the third-best run defense yet have also allowed the third-most rushing touchdowns in the league. They have the 19th-ranked pass defense, yet they have allowed a league-low five touchdown passes. How can we interpret that? Simple: the Cover 2 defense is working — for the most part — as it should. It prevents offenses from getting the big play down the field but it’s giving up big yards because it allows long drives due to shorter and intermediate routes. When an opponent gets closer to the end zone, the field shrinks and it’s harder to pass for a touchdown in a confined space. Meanwhile, opposing offensive coordinators don’t run as much on the Bears because they know they can move down the field with the pass. But when it comes to power football, the Bears get overrun in the red zone. Perhaps the one reason I most feel the Bears will struggle in this game is that Brett Favre is notorious for evading a pass rush — even with his decrepit body — and he also has long had success at picking apart zone coverage. The Bears are going to have to bring pressure with blitzes because I don’t think the front four will generate enough on their own. I think the safety blitz with Chris Harris has been an effective tool this season. The Bears will also get their toughest test of the season against the league’s top back in Adrian Peterson. Peterson has had plenty of success against the Bears in his career and is averaging over 100 yards per game. He also seems to have a nose for the end zone against them. I expect an inspired effort against Peterson and if the Bears do not have a broken play, I feel they can hold him under 100 yards. Still, Minnesota has the weapons to pick apart the Bears’ defense.

Advantage: Vikings

Special Teams

Devin Hester has had a great deal of success in his career against the Vikings both offensively and on special teams. Minnesota punter Chris Kluwe has made the mistake more than once of kicking to Hester, who has burned the Vikings for touchdowns. Rather than kick the ball out of bounds as most teams have done during the Hester reign, Kluwe tries to punt it high and deep which causes him to outkick his coverage. Assuming Kluwe hasn’t learned his lesson yet, I like Hester’s chances of having a nice day in the return game. The Bears pulled Danieal Manning off the kickoff return duties last week against the Bills and I’m still not sure why. My best guess is that after Buffalo sustained long drives against the Bears’ defense, Dave Toub preferred to put a fresh Johnny Knox in the game instead of a winded Manning. Knox had three returns for a 23-yard average with a long of 27 yards. I’m comfortable with both players back there. I’d prefer Manning’s straight up the field approach to Knox’s slower method of waiting for his blockers to set up. But Knox does have explosive speed and if he does get a crease, he could go all the way. Robbie Gould has struggled a bit this year, missing three field goals, although he did have one blocked. He also sent a kickoff out of bounds last week. Still, he’s an extremely reliable kicker on field goals and he’s had nine touchbacks on kickoffs, 10th-most in the league. Brad Maynard has had a rough season but he’s a weapon when attempting to pin opponents deep in their own territory. Hopefully the Bears don’t need him to kick from his own end zone this week because his lack of leg strength hurts their ability to flip field position.Vikings kicker Ryan Longwell has been a dependable kicker for a long time. He, too, is getting old and his leg strength is waning. He kicks in a dome and yet he has just one touchback this year. He’s made all eight of his field goals but only has a long of 41 yards, the shortest of any kicker in the league with as many attempts.
Advantage: Bears

Intangibles

The Vikings are one of the toughest teams in the league when playing in the friendly confines of Mall of America Field, but their recent struggles on the road have to be disconcerting for them. They’ve lost their last eight road games in a row, including the NFC Conference Championship game in New Orleans and the 36-30 overtime loss to the Bears in December. A turf team playing on grass has to at least be considered a factor in the losing streak. The Bears and Vikings have truly had a close and entertaining rivalry over the past decade. During Lovie Smith’s tenure alone, the teams have split their 12 battles. Four of the six years the series was split, 1-1. The Bears swept the Vikings in 2006 and the Vikings swept the Bears in 2007. The weather shouldn’t play a big factor in the game on Sunday. Temperature at kickoff calls for mid-40s with wind gusts up to 18 mph. That means the playbooks for both teams should be open and almost everything should be in the game plan. From a coaching perspective, both teams have had an outcry of public complaint. But even the most hard-headed Lovie Smith haters out there should be able to realize that the better of the two head coaches will be wearing blue and orange on Sunday. Smith has the respect of his players and if the Bears are to pull off a victory over the Vikings, it could be the cohesiveness of the locker room that makes the difference. Still, I’m not sure a bad head coach and a road losing streak of eight games will be enough to deter the Vikings in this one. They have better talent despite their 3-5 record and they’ll probably be playing with a bigger sense of urgency than the Bears will. The Vikings know that this is a do-or-die game for them. If they lose, they’ll be three games behind the co-division leaders, the Packers and Bears. They’ll have six losses on the season and they may have to run the table to make the playoffs. I expect a close game with careless turnovers from both quarterbacks. Peterson, who had 20 fumbles in the first three seasons of his career, has yet to fumble this season. That could change against the Bears’ opportunistic defense. However, unless the Vikings completely implode on Sunday, I don’t think the Bears have the offensive talent to match up with their Vikings’ counterparts.
Advantage: Vikings

Final Score: Minnesota 20, Chicago 17

http://www.bearsbeat.com/

Vikings at Saints

By Eric Karkovack 

Finally, the regular season is here.  And what better way to start the season than with a rematch of last year’s NFC Championship Game between the Saints and Vikings?

In last season’s tilt, New Orleans edged Minnesota, 31-28 in an overtime thriller.  The Vikings may have dominated a lot of statistical categories, but their 5 costly turnovers did them in.  The Saints, meanwhile, had just 1 turnover and kept plugging away to create opportunities.

The hype surrounding the Thursday night opener is intense.  Vikings coach Brad Childress has essentially called the Saints a “dirty” team for the many hits they laid on quarterback Brett Favre.  Maybe the Vikings are still kicking themselves for losing a game they thought they should have won?  The Saints, for their part, are downplaying the any hint of a true rivalry.  Usually the teams on the winning side of things do, you know.

Roster turnover wasn’t a big issue for either team during the offseason.  So, you would expect these two NFC contenders to have the same strengths that they had in 2009.

The biggest concerns for the Saints are that they are missing two starters on defense.  Safety Darren Sharper, a catalyst for so many big plays last year, is on the PUP list and won’t be back for at least 6 weeks.  Linebacker Jonathan Casillas is going to miss the entire season with a foot injury.  Casillas was to replace former Saint Scott Fujita, who left for Cleveland via free agency.

It will be interesting to see how Sharper’s replacement, Malcolm Jenkins, will perform in his new role.  Jenkins was drafted as a corner and converted to safety in the offseason.  Coach Sean Payton has said he’s very comfortable with what Jenkins can bring to the table.  Still, Sharper is a seasoned veteran and it’s hard to replace that wealth of experience.

On offense, the Saints are going to have to do a lot better job of controlling the line of scrimmage than they did in the NFC Championship.  Minnesota’s front seven made things very difficult in that game.  Running backs Pierre Thomas and Reggie Bush must work in tandem to keep the Vikings off balance.  That’s going to allow Drew Brees more time to look down the field.

Defensively, you have to like a lot of what the Saints did in last season’s matchup.  Vikings running back Adrian Peterson may have had a good day in terms of yardage, but his costly fumbles were a huge factor.  Brett Favre may have had a 300 yard day, but the key 4th quarter interception by Saints’ corner Tracy Porter rendered the yardage numbers irrelevant.  The Saints, as they so often did last year, bent but didn’t break.

If the Saints can pressure Favre as they did last year (and do so without any roughing the passer calls), it can go a long way in making the Vikings a one-dimensional offense.  Favre himself wasn’t sure how his surgically repaired ankle will hold up this season.  If he takes another pounding in week 1, the defense may get in his head as much as they do his ankle.

And, as if the emotions heading into this game weren’t enough, the Saints’ championship banner ceremony is sure to get the Superdome crowd into some kind of frenzy.  The atmosphere of this game should just be electric, even for those of us not fortunate enough to be in the dome.  Enjoy it, Saints fans!

Keys to the Game:

1. Don’t get carried away – The emotion may be the biggest hurdle for the Saints in this game.  The fact that the banners will be unveiled, the electricity in the crowd, and the anticipation of a new season will all be wrapped up in those pregame ceremonies.  The Saints have to use that to their benefit, while being careful not to lose focus on playing smart football.

2 Pierre and Reggie – The Saints’ talented running back duo can play a significant role in helping the offense put up some big numbers.  I’d look for the Saints to use them both not only as runners, but as threats in the passing game as well.  A few well-timed screen plays can slow down the Vikings pass rush.

3. Drew it again – We all know what Drew Brees is capable of doing.  But perhaps the best thing he did in the Super Bowl run was avoiding the costly turnover.  Again, this is where the emotion comes into play.  Let’s look for a cool Brees on Thursday night.

4. Get Brett – The Vikes are already ticked-off about the pounding their elder statesman QB took last season.  Putting pressure on Brett Favre can not only disrupt a play, it can also get this Vikings team off of their game.

5. Stay special – The Saints’ special teams were outstanding in 2009.  However, their coverage units had some struggles in the preseason.  This unit will have to return to their 2009 form to help keep the Vikings’ dangerous attack pinned back in their own end of the field.

Prediction: Saints 27 – Vikings 24

http://www.nosreview.com/

Vikings 38 Bills 14

By Steve Janis

·  Stevie Johnson still sucks

·  Lee Evans had a good game by his standers, not a $7 mil per guy though.

·  Ryan Fitzpatrick taught us all we need a real QB

·  The offensive line troubles I blame on injuries. I would still take a tackle like 3rd round next draft.

·  Don’t cross the Moats Brent Fever

·  Aaron Maybin AND John McCargo sightings, sorta

·  This team needs a tight end

·  This team needs to learn how to cover a tight end

·  I would resign Donte Whitner

·  This L was embarrassing but it got us closer to a better draft pick

·  We’ll fuck up our 1st round draft pick if we don’t trade up for Luck (meaning 3 first round picks)

·  Clifford Spiller needs more touches and we don’t know how to use him

·  Chris Kelsay didn’t make me say I hate you at all today

·  Why was that play blown dead when Kleinsasser fumbled and we recovered it and would have scored a touchdown? That play will not show up on the score sheet.

·  We would have been better off with Farve staying healthy today. The defense was so scared of Tarvaris running the ball and the LBs are too slow to catch him.

·  Ayodele you god damn suck.

http://wnywatercooler.blogspot.com

Go back to Bills Fan Spot 

 

Vikings 2011 Needs

Free Agency Priorities

Quarterback

They liked Christian Ponder enough to take him at #12, but history shows that quarterbacks do better when they aren’t forced to start week 1 of their rookie year. Right now, that’s their only option really. Look for them to add a veteran either through trade or free agency. They’ve been linked to Donovan McNabb. 

Guard 

Anthony Herrera is one of the worst starting guards in the league. They drafted some nice interior linemen in the draft, but I think they’re best off with a different veteran at the position for 2011. 

Safety

Madieu Williams sucks. Husain Abdullah could be a free agent depending on the new CBA rules regarding restricted and unrestricted free agents. They didn’t address this need until late in the draft, though you can’t blame them given how many needs they had. Look for them to try to sign a safety or two in free agency. 

Wide Receiver 

Sidney Rice could be a free agent depending on the new CBA rules regarding restricted and unrestricted free agents. No one outside of Minnesota would really blame him for leaving if he did leave because this team is clearly rebuilding. Aside from him, they have Percy Harvin and Bernard Berrian at wide receiver so they’d have to bring someone in through free agency. Even if they keep Rice, Berrian is overpaid and he could be cut and replaced with a cheaper veteran. 

Outside Linebacker 

Ben Leber is a below average starter at outside linebacker and a free agent. They drafted Ross Homan in the 6th round, but I don’t think he’ll be able to start as a rookie. They should either resign Leber or at least bring in some competition for the rookie Homan, who I think was a steal in the 6th round.

 

Draft Needs 

Quarterback

Brett Favre says he is planning on retiring, but even if that once again proves to be false, I doubt this team wants him back after everything that happened last season. Tarvaris Jackson and Joe Webb didn’t cut it either and new head coach Leslie Frazier has already expressed interest in bringing him his own guy, particularly a rookie. They should have several options available to them at #12. They could also bring in Kyle Orton from Denver if they hire former Denver Head Coach Josh McDaniels as offensive coordinator.

Drafted Christian Ponder (#12) 

Defensive Tackle

Pat Williams is expected to retire and even if he doesn’t, he’ll turn 39 next season and already was the oldest defensive player in the league last year. The former Pro Bowler looked like a fraction of his former self last year. They need a replacement for him.

Guard

An upgrade inside opposite Steve Hutchinson is necessary. This team has struggled to run block for a couple years now.

Safety

They have yet to replace Darren Sharper. They could use an upgrade at both safety positions this offseason, especially free safety where Madieu Williams struggles in coverage.

Drafted Mistral Raymond (#170)

Defensive End

Ray Edwards is a free agent. If he doesn’t get resign and if they don’t feel like 2010 4th round pick Everson Griffen is a capable defensive end of the future, they could target one early. Even if they do like Griffen, you can never have enough defensive ends, especially for a team that managed just 31 sacks last season, and Griffen could always use some competition.

Drafted Christian Ballard (#106), Drafted D’Aundre Reed (#215) 

Outside Linebacker

Ben Leber struggles and is a free agent.

Drafted Ross Homan (#200) 

Cornerback

They went cornerback in the 2nd round last year, but with Cedric Griffin’s injury history and Antonie Winfield turning 34 this offseason, they need young depth.

Drafted Brandon Burton (#139)

Center

They still have not effectively replaced Matt Birk.

Drafted Brandon Fusco (#172) 

Offensive Tackle

Depth is needed in case the wildly disappointing Bryant McKinnie and Phil Loadholt struggle again. Brett Favre took a ton of hits this season and they can’t allow a rookie quarterback to be under that much pressure.

Drafted DeMarcus Love (#168) 

 

Vikings 2010 Recap

In hindsight, maybe we shouldn’t have been expecting great things out of a team that had to drag their 40 year old starting quarterback out of Mississippi in mid-August. Favre followed his career best season in 2009 with one of, if not the worst season of his career. Favre completed a mere 61% (down 7% from 2009) for 7.0 YPA (down .9 from 2009) and had 11 touchdowns (as opposed to 33 in 2009) and 19 picks (as opposed to 7 in 2009). His turnovers alone cost this team at least one win this season, if not more.

Favre also dealt with injuries. He came in from Mississippi with a surgically repaired ankle from the 2009 playoffs. He also dealt with elbow tendonitis, shoulder soreness, reinjured his ankle, needed stitches on his chin, and eventually had to miss a game because of an AC joint sprain in his shoulder. About the absence, which broke his 297 straight starts straight, Favre said “it’s tough to throw a football when you can’t feel your hand. His offensive line simply couldn’t keep him upright this year, proving that they were more overrated than anything else (big names, big guys, mediocre production.)

In addition to the injuries, Favre dealt with an off the field saga with Jenn Sterger. Sterger accused Favre of sending unwanted pictures of his penis to her when she was a sideline reporter (with large breasts) for the New York Jets in 2008. Pictures of Favre’s 4 inch penis surfaced on the internet and then all of sudden, you could add an injured ego to Favre’s list of injuries.

You can’t blame this whole season on Favre. After an 0-2 start, this team simply stopped trying hard for Brad Childress. In fact, Favre was one of the few still playing his heart out for the team. Chilly was fired after a week 11 loss that sunk the team’s record to 3-7 and the team immediately won 2 straight for interim coach Leslie Frazier.

However, that didn’t last. Before a week 14 game with the Giants, the roof of the Metrodome collapsed from so much snow and the game had to be moved to Detroit. This game also coincided with Favre sitting for the first time in over 18 years. A homeless Vikings team lost to the Giants 21-3 in Detroit that week and then went on the lose 40-14 the next week to the Bears at “home” on the University of Minnesota’s TCF Bank Stadium. Favre started the game again, but went down with a concussion after his head hit the frozen turf, which had been described by Vikings punter Chris Kluwe as unplayable.

The Vikings finished 6-10. They will start completely anew next season. Favre won’t be back, even if he does decide to play again. Interim Coach Leslie Frazier is now coach Leslie Frazier. The Vikings will likely use their 12th overall pick on a quarterback. They will hope to get back into the Metrodome next season, though another year in TCF might be in their future. 

 

Vick Ballard Scout

 

Running Back

Mississippi State

5-10 219

Draft board overall prospect rank: #109

Draft board overall running back rank: #8

Overall rating: 65 (3rd/4th round)

40 time: 4.63

Games watched: LSU/Mississippi State, Mississippi State/Wake Forest

Positives

·         Powerful runner

·         Good size (5-10 219)

·         Great north/south runner

·         Runs well between the tackles

·         Explosive to the hole

·         Powerful lower body

·         Tough to tackle

·         Good pad level

·         2 year starter

·         Productive in tough conference (2010: 186 carries for 968 yards and 19 touchdowns, 2011: 193 carries for 1189 yards and 10 touchdowns)

·         Succeeded with little supporting cast

·         Improved pass catcher (20 catches as a senior)

·         Great work ethic (not highly recruited, went to JuCo, turned into Mississippi State’s leading rusher)

·         Good pass protector

Negatives

·         Poor 40 time (4.63)

·         Not a good outside runner

·         Doesn’t have breakaway speed

·         Not quick

·         Doesn’t break a lot of tackles in space

·         Never carried a big load

·         Not a good natural athlete

·         Pass catching still could improve (wouldn’t trust on 3rd down right away)

·         Durability?

·         Ball security?

·         Struggled against Alabama and LSU (who didn’t?)

NFL Comparison: Daniel Thomas

Vick Ballard reminds me of Daniel Thomas. Thomas was a 2nd round pick last year after 2 years as a starter at Kansas State. Like Ballard, he’s a former JuCo player. Both are powerful backs without a ton of speed or mobility. Thomas ran a 4.60 at 6-1 228. Ballard ran a 4.63 at 5-11 218. Both are also solid pass catchers with some fumble problems. They have very similar running styles.

I thought Thomas was a bit overdrafted in the 2nd round last year. Ballard will probably be a 5th round pick or so and I think he’ll be a little underdrafted. He can be a solid tandem back at the next level, which is what Thomas became as a rookie in Miami with Reggie Bush. That appears to be his best role going forward, rather than a 3 down back, which is what you’re typically looking for in the 2nd round. I have a borderline 3rd/4th grade on him and I think he’ll make some team very happy in the mid to late rounds. He’s an underrated back who put up good numbers on a poor team against tough competition in the SEC.