Eagles Draft Grades

 

23. G Danny Watkins D

They do realize he’ll be 31 when his 5 year first round rookie contract runs up right? The only reason I’m not giving them an F is because he fills a need and I do like Watkins as a short term guard and the Eagles are built to win now.

54. S Jaiquawn Jarrett D

I’ve never bought the Jaiquawn Jarrett hype, but I’m not surprised they took him this early. They really, really were interested in him. This does fill a need given then Quintin Mikell is probably gone as a free agent, but this is a giant reach by my book.

90. CB Curtis Marsh C

Cornerback was one of their biggest needs after the offensive line, but I think Marsh was a reach here.

116. MLB Casey Matthews A

Matthews fills a huge need for them at linebacker. Ernie Sims is a free agent. Stewart Bradley is an injury prone free agent. Jamar Chaney is still developing. Moise Fokou just sucks. They needed two linebackers out of this draft and Matthews is an excellent value at this point.

120. K Alex Henery D

David Akers is 36 years old, but he’s still a functional kicker. They had much bigger needs and I don’t believe in taking kickers before the 5th or 6th round. This is the earliest a kicker has been drafted since Stephen Gostkowski in 2006 was drafted 118th overall. Henery is not on that level.

149. RB Dion Lewis A-

They had bigger needs than another running back, but Lewis is a very good value at this point in the draft.

161. G Julian Vandervelde C-

Right tackle was a bigger need for them upfront then another guard. Vandervelde doesn’t fit the range well either.

191. G Jason Kelce D

Right tackle was a bigger need for them upfront then a 3rd guard. Kelce doesn’t fit the range well either.

193. OLB Brian Rolle A

This is their 2nd linebacker that I said they needed. Rolle is also a great value at this point.

237. MLB Greg Lloyd B+

I don’t think they needed a 3rd linebacker. However, Lloyd fits the range and can play special teams.

240. FB Stanley Havili A

Fullback was a need of theirs and Havili fits the draft range.

Overall:

I don’t think they drafted well at all. I think they made reaches with each of their first 3 picks and didn’t make a good pick until the 4th round. On top of that, they drafted a kicker in the 4th round, something I’m completely against and I’m not even sure it was that big of a need of them. They made some nicer picks in the late rounds, but I don’t think they really made their team that much better in the draft. I don’t think Jarrett and Marsh upgrade their secondary that much and they only upgraded one offensive line spot, guard, and probably only for a few years. They added a few nice linebackers and a nice fullback, two positions of need, but this was one of the worst drafts.

Grade: C-

 

Eagles Draft 2012

 

12. DT Fletcher Cox A

Fletcher Cox would have been a minor reach had they traded up to somewhere like 7 to grab him, but at 12, he makes a lot of sense. He was 13th on my board and fills a primary need.

46. OLB Mychal Kendricks B-

How much rope did it take to tie up Andy Reid so this pick could be made? He never takes linebackers early. They definitely needed one, however, but I had a 3rd round grade on Kendricks. Zach Brown is a more natural outside linebacker and a much better value at this point.

59. DE Vinny Curry C-

I don’t see this as the phenomenal value that many see this pick as. I had a mid 2nd round grade on Curry, so while the late 2nd round is a good value for him, I didn’t see the need for another defensive lineman. They had 50 sacks last year. Trent Cole and Jason Babin combined for 29 and Brandon Graham might finally be healthy in 2012. Cox can also play end. Where does Curry fit?

88. QB Nick Foles C

They needed a quarterback behind an aging and injury prone Vick, but Nick Foles didn’t make a lot of sense over Kirk Cousins. Foles is a mess of a prospect and probably won’t ever be a capable starter in this league. I had a 5th round grade on him.

123. CB Brandon Boykin A

What an excellent value! If Boykin were a few inches taller, I might have had a borderline 1st round grade on him. Instead I had him as a high 3rd rounder so he’s an excellent value in the 4th round and fits very well with the Eagles. They traded Asante Samuel, not just because of his salary, but because they had 3 outside cornerbacks and no one who could play on the slot. Boykin will play there, where his size won’t matter as much and he’s one of the best pure cover cornerbacks in this draft class so he should excel there. That will move Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie to the outside, where he should bounce back from a career worst season. Remember, this guy once made the Pro Bowl. The Eagles could have one of the best secondaries in the league last season.

153. OT Dennis Kelly C

I had Kelly outside of my top 250. That would be fine in the 6th or 7th round, but this is the 5th round. They did need another tackle behind Demetress Bell, but I don’t think Kelly offers much help there. King Dunlap probably remains the superior option in case of another annual Bell injury.

194. WR Marvin McNutt A

The Eagles were considering signing Plaxico Burress in free agency to add size to their receiving corps. Now they don’t have to sign the washed up Burress. McNutt fills that role well and is an excellent value in the 6th round. I had a 3rd round grade on him.

200. G Brandon Washington A

Another excellent value in the 6th round. Washington doesn’t fill a need whatsoever, but who cares when the value is this good. You can always use more offensive line help.

229. RB Bryce Brown A

I didn’t have Brown in my top 250, but I get this pick. Brown is a former top recruit who was kicked off of two major college football programs. He’s the type of boom or bust pick it’s absolutely fine to take in the 7th round. Dion Lewis looks entrenched as the #2 back behind LeSean McCoy, but Brown can compete to be the 3rd string with undrafted free agent Chris Polk among others.

The Eagles’ #1 priority of this offseason had to be fixing their linebacking corps. I don’t know how much Mychal Kendricks helps, but he could be a decent starter on the outside and remember, they did trade a 4th rounder from this draft for DeMeco Ryans so that factors into this grade as well. They also had to sort out their secondary and they did that by trading away Asante Samuel, albeit for pennies on the dollar, which factors into this grade, moving DRC to the outside, and getting an exceptional value on Brandon Boykin in the 4th round. He should make an impact right away on the slot. Overall, I think they’ll have a very good secondary next season.

Their first round pick was Fletcher Cox. He was a fine value and filled a need at defensive tackle with Cullen Jenkins and Mike Patterson. Vinny Curry in the late 2nd didn’t make as much sense. There’s already a logjam at defensive end. Curry might not see the field very much in 2012 if Brandon Graham is healthy. Nick Foles and Dennis Kelly were also reaches, but they made up for those with excellent value picks in the late rounds. This was a solid draft.

Grade: B

 

Eagles 2011 Needs

Free Agency Priorities

Offensive Tackle

Why didn’t they draft a replacement for Winston Justice? Hopefully they can find one in free agency because Winston Justice sucks. 

Cornerback 

Can Curtis Marsh or Trevard Lindley step up as the starter opposite Asante Samuel? Maybe, but I’m skeptical and depth is never a bad thing at cornerback.

 

Draft Needs 

Offensive Tackle

Jason Peters has been overrated his entire career, while Winston Justice struggled mightily down the stretch. Overall, they gave up 50 sacks last year, despite having Michael Vick under center for most of the year. That can’t continue to happen. Vick isn’t a big guy and he takes enough hits in the open field anyway. Plus, he really struggled (by his standards) when pressured late last year. They’ll probably upgrade Winston Justice, but they really should bring in two new tackles. Peters’ contract might make that difficult, but either way, Gabe Carimi is definitely an option at #23.

Guard

More offensive line help. Mike Pouncey is definitely an option at #23.

Drafted Danny Watkins (#23), Drafted Julian Vandervelde (#161), Drafted Jason Kelce (#191) 

Cornerback

Dmitri Patterson sucks in coverage and Ellis Hobbs is facing an untimely retirement after a nasty neck injury last year. At least one corner should be added for this team, which ranked 18th against the pass, despite having Asante Samuel and a strong pass rush. They might add two depending on how they feel about 2009 4th round pick Trevard Lindley.

Drafted Curtis Marsh (#90) 

Outside Linebacker

Moise Fukuo needs to be upgraded. If they resign Stewart Bradley, they can move him to the outside and keep Jabar Chaney inside, but Bradley is injury prone and Chaney was a late round rookie last year. Ernie Sims is also a marginal player so I could see them adding one more outside linebacker in the mix.

Drafted Brian Rolle (#193) 

Center

More offensive line help, though this depending on how they feel about Jamaal Jackson coming off an injury.

Defensive Tackle

Depth is needed at the position.

 

Eagles 2010 Recap

This year was supposed to be a rebuilding year for the Eagles. Donovan McNabb and Brian Westbrook were gone, replaced by Kevin Kolb and LeSean McCoy. They were also missing several 2009 starters from their defense, including cornerback Sheldon Brown. However, Michael Vick had something to say about that.

Vick took over for an injured Kevin Kolb week 1 against the Packers and made an immediate impact, almost completing an amazing comeback, passing for 175 yards and rushing for another 103. Vick would stay on as starter, abusing both the Lions’ and the Jaguars’ weak defenses in weeks 2 and 3 before getting hurt on a run (that ironically didn’t even count because of a penalty) week 4 against the Redskins.

Kevin Kolb came in and did a solid job in his next 2 starts, winning both games and pushing the Eagles’ record to 4-2. Michael Vick would return soon, but many, including me, argued that they should stick with the young Kolb because Vick was a free agent after the season and Kolb, a 2007 2nd round pick, had never gotten his fair shot. Well, all of us, including me, were wrong. Nothing against Kolb, but when Michael Vick came back to the 4-3 Eagles week 9, they were noticable better.

In Vick’s first start, he outdueled Peyton Manning in a 26-24 Eagles victory over the Colts. The next week, however, was Vick’s Madden Bowl. Vick abused the Washington Redskins like he was playing Madden, scoring 4 first quarter touchdowns in route to a 59-28 Eagles win IN Washington. Vick was 20-28 for 333 yards, 4 touchdowns, 8 carries for 80 yards and 2 more scores. All of a sudden, a potential Super Bowl trophy was in sight.

Vick wouldn’t be quite the same down the stretch, but it’s hard to say 137-219 (62.6%) for 1668 yards (7.6 YPA), and 10 touchdowns to 6 picks in his final 6 games was a bad performance. The Eagles had clinched the NFC East once again by week 16, thanks to an amazing comeback against the Giants. Down 31-10 with 8 minutes left in the game, the Eagles once again showed their explosive potential, winning 38-31.

Despite a loss to Minnesota week 16, the Eagles still had high hopes heading into the playoffs as a #3 seed. They had Michael Vick at quarterback, and explosive playmakers like DeSean Jackson, LeSean McCoy, and Jeremy Maclin all over the field. However, they would still fall in the first round of the playoffs to the Green Bay Packers, 21-16.

Still, it was a very impressive season for the Eagles. Michael Vick was impressive enough to make most of America forgive him for dogfighting. Andy Reid cemented his status as an elite developer of quarterbacks. Say what you want about him, he’s fat, he doesn’t know how to manage a clock, he hates to run the football, Michael Vick completed 6.2% more percent of his passes this season than any season before and Donovan McNabb had arguably his worst season of his career in Washington without Reid. 

 

Dwight Lowery Jaguars

 

Dwight Lowery played alright at safety for the Jaguars last season, ranking slightly above average in coverage and slightly below average against the run. ProFootballFocus had him as their 35th ranked safety last season. 4 years might seem a little much for a safety who doesn’t even have a full season at safety, but the Jaguars have so many other needs and this is such a weak safety class in free agency and in the draft, that this is a reasonable deal (13.6 million over 4). He didn’t get a ton of guaranteed money either, 4 million.

Grade: B

 

Dwight Jones Scout

 

Wide receiver

North Carolina

6-3 230

Draft board overall prospect rank: #87

Draft board wide receiver rank: #16

Overall rating: 70 (3rd round)

40 time: 4.55

Games watched:  North Carolina/LouisvilleClemson/North CarolinaNC State/North CarolinaVirginia Tech/North Carolina

Positives

·         Great size (6-3 230)

·         2 years of strong production (62/946/4 85/1196/12)

·         Incredibly consistent (70+ yards in 12 of 13 games as a senior)

·         Produced on a weak passing offense

·         Physical and willing to run block

·         Tough to bring down in open field

·         Big strong hands

·         Catches the ball well in stride

·         Good 40 for his size (4.55)

·         End zone threat

·         Great athlete for his size

·         Uses his body well

Negatives

·         Got into some off the field trouble that temporarily made his ineligible for their Bowl Game this season

·         Struggles to get separation (especially at Senior Bowl)

·         Not as fast as his 40 would suggest

·         Looked out of shape at The Combine

·         Work ethic could use help

·         Poor explosion (1.62 10 yard dash)

·         Not fast off the line of scrimmage

·         Poor Combine performance

·         Has some problems with drops

NFL Comparison: Roy Williams

At one point, Dwight Jones was one of my more underrated prospects. I liked his size and consistency and his athleticism for his size. He had a great senior season on a mediocre passing offense, catching 85 balls for 1196 yards and 12 touchdowns with at least 72 yards in 12 of 13 games. He was super physical with great size.

However, it was all kind of downhill from him after the season. Once seen as a 2nd round prospect, Jones has fallen into the 4th round range at best. Character issues surfaced about problems with his coaches and an off the field incident which almost cost him eligibility in his team’s bowl game. He really struggled in the Senior Bowl. He was one of the highest rated prospects there coming in, but struggled to get separation all week in practice and in the game. There were rumors he was out of shape.

He didn’t help himself at The Combine. His 40 was fine, but his vertical (33 inch) and broad jump (9 foot 1), were underwhelming, as were his drills. He is an incredibly physical player with a ton of upside, but lethargy and drops are major problems with him. His lack of elite speed isn’t a huge problem because he can still be a #2 receiver and end zone threat, but I worry he won’t reach his full potential as a player.

I still have a 3rd round grade on him and I’m higher on him than most are, but he does remind me a little too much of Roy Williams. His career could be similar, a few good years, before eventually declining while still young and ending up out of the league, where Williams could be after this season. However, if he reaches his full potential, he’s got the ability to like Roy Williams when he was at his best.

<p> </p><p id=”dontshowthis”> </p>
<script type=”text/javascript”

Dunta Robinson Falcons

The Falcons desperately needed a cornerback. They resigned Brian Williams yesterday, but he’s barely a #2. Robinson was the best cornerback on the market and, though they overpaid for him a little, they needed him. He will instantly upgrade their pass defense and allow them to focus on taking a defensive end like Brandon Graham in the 1st round, to further upgrade their pass defense.

Grade: B+

Duke/Virginia

Spotlight #1: Virginia CB Chase Minnifield

Spotlight #2: Duke S Matt Daniels 

1st quarter

11:36: Minnifield good use of hands in press, strong.

11:26: Matt Daniels with a tackle, but also unnecessary roughness, good effort to play through whistley, but needs to be smarter about things like this.

10:44: Daniels helps bring a guy down after a sizeable again.

8:54: Minnifield with a good open field tackle after the ball carrier breaks a couple closer to the line.

5:36: Minnifield gives up inside position on a slant on the goal line, catchable ball, could have been a touchdown but physical play by Minnifield helps contribute to eventual drop.

3:00: Daniels misses a tackle, tough play, good explosive to even take a shot at it.

1:58: Daniels overpursues to the inside on a run play, good instincts to come and play ball, but poor angle.

2nd quarter

14:05: Donovan Varner breaks a 64 yard touchdown on a crossing route over the middle.

9:22: Minnifield thrown on in the end zone with a fade route, incomplete, could have been ruled holding or pass interference.

9:12: Minnifield stays away from sticking his nose in on a goal line run, Cam Johnson with the clutch tackle.

8:25: Daniels shoots up and makes a great open field tackle, doesn’t get juked out.

3:38: Daniels has one on one coverage deep, thrown on, not the best coverage, but overthrown and incomplete.

3:34: Daniels makes a nice play to take the ball carrier down for a gain of a yard or two.

2:25: Daniels blown past downfield, could have been a long downfield, but overthrown.

1:36: Cam Johnson with a sack.

 

3rd quarter

14:40: Cam Johnson deflects a short one, still complete, good motor to go back and get in on the tackle after a gain of a few.

13:56: Minnifield with the tackle on an end around by Varner for a few.

13:06: Cam Johnson hits the quarterback as he throws, faces an ill advised throw, Minnifield jumps it, pick six.

11:54: Connor Vernon beats Chase Minnifield for a big gain, tackle by Minnifield from behind to prevent touchdown, 51 yards.

11:29: Minnifield soft on a goal line run.

8:49: Matt Daniels makes a stop short of the sticks on a run, fundamental open field tackle on 2nd down.

5:37: Minnifield blocked well on a screen for a first, can’t disengage.

1:05: Cam Johnson with a tackle for loss.

4th quarter

11:57: Minnifield gets another interception, nullified by pass interference.

11:46: Minnifield in on a tackle after another man allows a short catch.

11:15: Varner just overthrown over the middle for a long gain that could have gone for a touchdown, just can’t quite make the tough catch in stride.

8:46: Virginia goes deep on Daniels again, should have been caught, very catchable ball, dropped.

7:54: Varner just drops one over the middle, this time actually in the end zone. Tough catch, but catchable.

7:48: Minnifield allows a reception on a slant over the middle short to convert, Minnifield had his hands on it, Vernon just rips it out of his hands.

5:54: Johnson hits the quarterback as he throws, having a dominant half since Duke’s left tackle got hurt. Varner drops another tough catch, but catchable ball on this one.

4:01: Minnifield one of two in the area on a short throw, leads with his helmet forcing the drop, not called, incomplete. Pro scouts won’t like to see that.

2:31: Daniels blocked off the play in a 9 man box on a run play.

1:02: Daniels on a 3rd down tackle right after the sticks, game over.

0:00: Duke has two talented wide receivers, junior Conner Vernon and Donovan Varner. Virginia has a talented potential first round pick at cornerback and chose to put him on Vernon rather than Varner, which makes sense as Vernon is Duke’s leading receiver and Varner normally lines up in the slot. Vernon missed a few snaps with injury, but for the most part he played most of the game and Minnifield was on him all game. Vernon had just 3 catches for 64 yards.

One catch he beat Minnifield over the middle for 51 yards one on one. He got separation and Minnifield needed to tackle him from behind to prevent the touchdown. His 2nd catch was wide open in space on a screen, but Minnifield couldn’t get off a block to make the tackle, which someone else had to do after a gain of few. His 3rd catch could have been an interception, but Vernon simply outmuscled him and ripped the ball out of his hands for a completion on a slant.

Other than that though, Minnifield limited a talented receiver well. The athletic 6-1 195 pounder is a physical player who plays with great technique and is a student of the game. He sends his game tape every week to his dad Frank Minnifield, a former Pro Bowl cornerback, and goes over it with him. He’s had a bit of an inconsistent senior year, but solid stats, 50 tackles, 7 for loss, 8 deflections, 1.5 tackles for loss, and 3 interceptions, including one in this game which was his first pick six of his career and his 13th interception of his career, including 6 in a fantastic junior year.

He hasn’t great lived up to his junior season this year, but still figures to get drafted in either the 2nd round or even the late 1st round. He could have had a couple more interceptions in this game, but he had one ripped out of his hands, and another one nullified by pass interference. There was also another play in the end zone which should have been pass interference. He also should have been whistled for leading with his helmet. He was generally solid against the run, but struggled to get off a couple blocks and missed a tackle, finishing with, 5 tackles in the game. He’s a long, lanky player who needs to get stronger and become more physical against the run. He’s already physical in pass coverage and would be best in a man press scheme. In my book, he’s a 2nd rounder.

With Vernon kept in check for most of the game by Minnifield, Duke threw to Varner instead. Varner was a frequent target and caught 7 passes for 132 yards and a score, but could have had more. He dropped 3 tough, but catchable balls, including two which could have been touchdowns. They were all tough, but I would have liked to have seen him catch at least 1 or two. He still did have a good game and showed himself again to be a good route runner and possession receiver at 5-9 175. His stats aren’t great with 61 catches for 713 yards and 3 scores on the season, but he’s had a good career and he has a talented Vernon takes catches away from him on already an average at best passing offense. He could still end up as a depth receiver at the next level, but it’ll probably have to be as an undrafted free agent.

Another talented defensive player on the Virginia side is defensive end Cam Johnson. He had a huge game with 2 tackles for loss, a sack, a deflection, a couple of quarterback hits and generally consistent pressure. One of those quarterback hits occurred on the Minnifield interception and the hit definitely forced the bad throw that was jumped by Minnifield. I’m torn on where to stand on him.

I’ve seen a couple of Virginia games, this one and one against Miami, and he’s been awesome in each, but generally his numbers haven’t been that great this season as he has just 30 tackles, 11 for loss, and 4 sacks, but 4 of those tackles for loss and 2 sacks have been in games I’ve seen him. The 6-4 275 pound defensive end is generally regarded as a mid rounder, but the tape I’ve seen on him suggests a 2nd round or even a 1st rounder. It’s worth noting that Virginia had the most success in this game against Duke’s backup left tackle.

Duke’s best defensive player is safety Matt Daniels. The safety has 126 tackles on the season and is a 3 year starter, but needed to prove he was more than a box safety because at 6-1 210 he’s a little small to be just a box safety at the next level. He didn’t do that and really struggled in coverage. He was consistent beat deep and looked really stiff in coverage, but luckily for him Virginia’s quarterback was inaccurate on all 3 plays he was beaten deep on because he could have surrendered 3 huge gains. He had another solid game in run support with 9 tackles. He’s a fundamentally sound player who has a nose for the ball and takes good routes to the ball, though he tends to be a little overly aggressive. He looks like a mid to late day 3 prospect.

 

Drew Stanton Colts

 

Trade for Jets: Stanton demanded a trade after the Jets signed Tim Tebow as the career backup was promised he’d be the 2nd string quarterback in New York when he signed. When I heard this I tweeted “Drew Stanton demands a trade. Uh…you’re Drew Stanton. You don’t demand a trade. You just get cut.” Looks like the Jets found a taker, however. They’re not getting much in return (they get a 6th rounder for Stanton and a 7th rounder), but it’s better than nothing.

Grade: A

Trade for Colts: The Colts needed a veteran backup for Andrew Luck and I guess they liked Stanton more than the other available options, guys like Billy Volek, AJ Feeley, Vince Young, Matt Leinart, Charlie Batch, and Curtis Painter (LOL). I don’t see much difference between Stanton and someone like Volek or Batch, but whatever, they didn’t give much up.

Grade: B