Ryan Matthews

 

Running Back

Fresno State

6-0 218

40 time: 4.41

Draft board overall prospect rank: #35

Draft board running back rank: #3

Overall rating: 81*

2/28/10: Matthews would have moved up anyway given Jonathan Dwyer’s stink bomb because the two are compared often because both are considered future feature backs. However, that’s not the only reason he’s moving up. A 4.41 40 at 6-0 218 turned a lot of heads. He’s a good pass catcher and a great pass blocker for his age and he also runs extremely well. He could go 28th to San Diego because he has everything they look for in a back.

1/17/10: He’s a bit of a one hit wonder but with 1808 yards and 19 touchdowns on a 6.6 average, some teams are going to look past that like they did with former one hit wonders Donald Brown and Rashard Mendenhall, who both went in the first round. He runs a bit upright, but he has very refined pass blocking and pass catching abilities for his age and doesn’t fumble often. He has all the makings of a future feature back, though admittedly I’d like to see one more great season on his stat sheet just for him to prove that he can do it again and again, though you can’t really blame him because he was mostly a #2 back or goal line back throughout his first two years at Fresno State.

12/12/09: Preferably I like to see two good years out of a player, especially if he plays in a weaker conference, but one excellent year could be enough to shoot Matthews up to the first round like it did with Rashard Mendenhall in 2008 and Donald Brown in 2009. 

            11/27/09: Ryan Matthews is taking college football by storm this year by going from backup to Heisman Trophy candidate in one year. NFL scouts are also noticing him. I have my doubts about him because he’s only been doing this for one year, but that didn’t stop Rashard Mendenhall and Donald Brown from shooting into the first round in each of the last two respective years and Matthews could also go in the first round this year, if he decides to declare, which I believe he will because of the threat of a rookie salary cap in 2011. I think he has a lot of upside and I am giving him a 2nd round grade for now just to be reserved on him because of his lack of experience. I prefer when a player has put together at least two good years in college before I call them a sure fire first round pick. There are also some concerns about his strength of competition playing for Fresno State. As for what I see out of him, he has a good combination of size and speed, but he runs too upright and isn’t as explosive as he could be for that reason. He is an extremely shifty runner and makes good cuts and has amazing vision and creativity. He would be a perfect fit for a zone blocking scheme for that reason. He has good hands out of the backfield. He doesn’t break as many tackles as he should at his size and he will fumble a lot because of his running style in the NFL. He needs to learn to protect the ball and lower his shoulders in the NFL. He blocks very well for a college running back and can be as close to an every down back as an rookie is in the NFL right away. He is the complete package, size, speed, good hands, and good blocking, but definitely has some things to work on.

NFL Comparison: Rashard Mendenhall

Ryan Mallett scout

 

Quarterback 

Arkansas

6-7 247

Draft board overall prospect rank: #55

Draft board overall quarterback rank: #3

Overall rating: 77 (mid 2nd)

40 time: 5.36

4/19/11: A report has come out that Mallett admitted to his drug use in private interviews at The Combine. I’m not moving him down in my mock draft because teams have known about this for months and he’s still getting a ton of first round buzz, but I can’t give this kid a first round grade anymore. You might think it’s just drugs. Plenty of college kids do them. That’s true, but Mallett isn’t just some college kid. He’s a potential NFL franchise quarterback.

Quarterback might be the most cerebral position in all of sports and if your heart and your head aren’t in it, you will fail, even if you can throw the ball 80 yards down field with ease. Just ask JaMarcus Russell. The fact that he did drugs in college shows raises a lot of questions about his commitment. Plus, remember what happened with Aqib Talib, who did drugs in college. He thought he was above the law in college and now a few years later he’s looking about 5 years in jail for aggravated assault with a deadly weapon.

This quarterback class sucks. The top 4 quarterbacks are a one year wonder with off the field issues, a druggie, a spread quarterback with just 16 touchdowns to 9 interceptions, and a quarterback who completed just 54% of his passes last year.

There’s a very good chance that we could look back at this quarterback class in 4 years time the way we look at 2007, where the closest thing we got to a franchise quarterback was Kevin Kolb in the 2nd round (JaMarcus Russelll, Brady Quinn, Trent Edwards, John Beck, Drew Stanton all went in the first 3 rounds). There’s also a very good chance that someone like Colin Kaepernick ends up being the best quarterback from this class, if he’s put in the right situation. 

2/26/11: One of the things I was most looking forward to this week was seeing Ryan Mallett’s interview and if any concrete evidence about his supposed drug use would come up. Mallett was asked about his drug use and this was his response

“I’m not going to talk about that right now. I’ve got the interviews with teams, and when teams need to know what they need to know. I’m going to leave it at.” 

If you didn’t take do illegal drugs, say it. Dispel the rumors right then and there. Make a statement. He didn’t do that. I’m not saying he did drugs or anything, but I don’t like the way he handled the situation and with so many prominent draft scouts saying they wouldn’t touch him, I think it’s finally time for me to drop him.

2/10/11: Ryan Mallett is one of the biggest draft enigmas in a while. Two draft experts have come out and said they have character concern type stuff on him. Wes Bunting of NFL Football Post has quotes a scout as saying “I got stuff on Mallett that no one even knows about and I wouldn’t touch him with a ten foot pole.” Albert Breer of the NFL Network backed that up by saying he could drop significantly because of “undisclosed character concerns.” Some mocks have him falling out of the first round completely because of this.

The issue, no one will say what these “character concerns” are. I did some research, but all I could find were a few quotes on message board/forum type site from people who “knew Mallett” that said Mallett frequently used marijuana and often experimented with harder drugs and one person even saying that Mallett deals. However, people who “knew Mallett” could easily be “people who hated Mallett and want to ruin his draft stock” or “people who have never met Mallett and want their 5 minutes of fame.” My conclusion, until I hear something concrete (which we will if there’s something big on him), I’m not holding any character issues against him.

Mallett is my top quarterback in this class, though sort of by default. I’m certainly not sold on him as a franchise quarterback. He’s got crazy upside, but there are a lot of potential “bust” red flags. There’s his terrible footwork and his inconsistent accuracy. There’s his tendency to stare down his first read and his tendency to force things into coverage when nothing’s there. There’s his slower delivery, which could lead to more picks in the NFL than it did in college. There’s the offense he came out of, one that rarely produces NFL quarterbacks. However, he’s got one of the biggest arms I’ve ever seen.

All of his flaws are coachable, unless we find out something big character wise. His completion percentage, despite his poor footwork, was 64.7% last year and he only threw 12 picks to 32 touchdowns, against tough SEC competition. His biggest flaw is throwing when no one’s open. He tends to force things in this situation, rather than putting the ball in a place only his man can get it or simply throwing it away. He doesn’t have the accuracy to thread the needle and he struggles throwing over the middle.

However, as I said, he’s definitely coachable. I think he’s got the highest upside in this class because of his arm strength, though you could say the same thing about Newton. He’s more polished than Locker or Newton as well. I don’t know if I’d use a top 10 pick on him, but he’s worth a top 15, again, barring any solid reports about his character flaws.

NFL Comparison: Jeff George

Ryan Kerrigan Scout

 

Defensive End/Rush Linebacker

Purdue

6-4 274

Draft board overall prospect rank: #10

Draft board overall defensive end rank: #3

Overall rating: 90 (Top 10)

40 time: 4.67

4/23/11: People who pay a lot of attention to the NFL Draft and the NFL in general will tell you that defensive linemen have been busting at a very high rate in the past decade or so. The reason for this, defensive lineman are normally the most athletic guys on the field with their combination of size and speed and they ride this all through college and a lot of them don’t have great work ethics. Then they get to the NFL, get paid millions and millions, and all of a sudden their motivation is much smaller, considering that their job description is basically to wrestle with 300+ pound guys.

Ryan Kerrigan is different. He’s a highly productive, high motor, strong work ethic kid. He truly loves the game. His motor never shuts off. He played on a bad Purdue team last year as poor offensive play led to the team going 4-8 and he still played every down hard. He managed 13 sacks after 12 the year before and 7 as a sophomore. He’s a highly productive 3 year starter who has never taken a play off.

He’s not the most gifted athletically, but all that means is that he’s had to work harder to get where he is and he can’t rely on his natural athletic gifts. For this reason, I think he has a never low probability of busting. His measurables aren’t terrible either with a 4.67 40 at 6-4 274. He also benched 31 reps of 225. He’s bulked up about 10 pounds from the end of last season, maintaining his speed in the process. This probably eliminates him from being a 3-4 linebacker, but I would have had some doubt about his ability to play the position even if he was in the 260s. He doesn’t have very fluid hips.

He’s going to be best in a 4-3 as a right end, a dynamic, tough to block, tenacious edge rusher with a non-stop motor. He refuses to be blocked. He’s not that sturdy against the run and he doesn’t have a great initial burst, but he’s already a very refined and proven pass rusher. He doesn’t need a lot of work and he won’t get complacent.

NFL Comparison: Chris Long

 

Ryan Glab

Ryan Glab

BearsBeat.com

ryan@bearsbeat.com

twitter.com/bearsbeat 

I was born, raised and currently reside in the northwest suburbs of Chicago. I’ve been a Bears fan for more than 20 years and have not missed a game in that timespan, at least not to my recollection. I have every Bears game since 2001 recorded on tape, and with the advent of DVR I often watch games two or three times a week. I played football for 10 years and was a kicker in college where I was a four-year starter at Division III Aurora University.

Ryan Broyles Scout

 

Wide receiver

Oklahoma

5-10 192

Draft board overall prospect rank: #42

Draft board overall wide receiver rank: #5

Overall rating: 78 (2nd round)

40 time: 4.57

Games watched: Oklahoma/Texas TechOklahoma State/OklahomaOklahoma/BaylorOklahoma/Kansas StateOklahoma/Texas

Positives

·         The NCAA’s all time leading receiver (349 catches for 4586 yards and 45 touchdowns)

·         Incredibly adept at getting open

·         Deadly after the catch, with the ball in his hands

·         Works the middle of the field incredibly well

·         Quicker than fast

·         Some deep ability

·         Great hands, very reliable

·         Not afraid to go over the middle

·         Incredibly tough

·         Great work ethic

·         High character, team leader

·         Worked back from torn ACL to a 4.57 40 in 5 months

·         4.4 speed when at 100%

·         Cuts well

·         Great in the open field

·         Very good route runner

·         Oklahoma’s offense went in the toilet when he got hurt

Negatives

·         Undersized

·         Coming off a torn ACL

·         Lacks elite speed to compensate for his lack of size

·         Played in a pass heavy, explosive offensive that could have inflated his stats

·         Always had a great quarterback throwing to him

·         A willing blocker, but too small to be a good blocker

·         Spread offense and a limited route tree (but did incredibly well with what he was given)

NFL Comparison: Poor man’s Wes Welker

Wes Welker is such a unique player and everyone is always trying to find the “next” one. It seems there is one prospect every year compared to Wes Welker. Every top slot receiver prospect is deemed the next Wes Welker and none pan out as so. I’ve never given this comparison, but of any of the wide receiver prospects in the past few years, Broyles has the most similarities to the Patriots slot receiver. He probably won’t be quite as good, but as a Patriots fan, with Welker aging, I would be ecstatic if they were to use a 2nd or 3rd round pick on Broyles to be his successor. He’s a very similar style player and he would compliment Tom Brady very well.

I think he’s the most underrated prospect in this draft class. I had a 1st round grade on him before he got hurt. The ACL tear was damaging to his stock, but it also did two things to improve it. For one thing, Oklahoma’s offense went into the toilet without him (and tanked Landry Jones’ draft stock at the same time). For another thing, it solidified his amazing toughness and work ethic. In just 5 months, he went from tearing his ACL to running in the 4.5s at his Pro Day. He described himself at 75%, which is amazing (and not unlike Welker’s recovery from a similar injury). He’s a hard worker and a high motor player who is a great locker room guy.

At full speed, he’s probably a 4.4 player. He doesn’t have the elite speed to make up for his lack of size, but you can say the same thing about Welker. He’s quicker than fast and an incredible route runner who finds the seams in the defense, gets open short with ease, and can make tough catches over the middle. He’s got great hands and rarely drops a pass. He’s going to catch a lot more balls (already the FBS’ all time leading receiver) in the slot in the NFL in the right system. After the 2nd round, he’d be an absolute steal. I have a high 2nd round grade on him.

 

Russell Okung

 

Offensive Tackle 

Oklahoma State

6-5 310

40 time: 5.17

Draft board overall prospect rank: #3

Draft board offensive tackle rank: #1

Overall rating: 98*

1/19/10: He’s got excellent footwork and good zone versatility. He has the agility, athleticism, and footwork to be an elite zone blocking left tackle, but he also has good strength, though not elite, and can take down defensive ends one-on-one. His footwork is his best attribute and he is strong as a run blocker and as a pass blocker. 

6/27/09: Russell Okung is that franchise type left tackle that teams have been taking in the top 5 over the past few years. In 2007 we had Joe Thomas, in 2008 Jake Long, and last year Jason Smith. He doesn’t really have any weaknesses. He has great footwork and plays with great leverage. He has great size and while he doesn’t have good timed speed, he has good lateral quickness that can be used to block quicker defenders. Some of the faster defensive ends and rush linebackers will still be able to blow right past him. He has a ton of experience and a great track record. He played left tackle for Oklahoma State’s dynamic offense last season and was a huge part of it. The left tackle is the 2ndmost important position on an offense. He started week 1 as a true freshman and hasn’t missed a game in 3 years since. In addition to being a great pass blocker, he’s also a terrific run blocker, especially for a left tackle, a position that mainly used as a pass blocker. He doesn’t let off blocks until the play is completely over, which is rare for a college kid, and he never takes plays off. He has an amazing work ethic. He can play right tackle, in addition to left, and he can play some guard, though he doesn’t have as much value as a guard.

NFL Comparison: Ryan Clady

*=For a breakdown of what this means, click here

Rush Linebackers 2012

Updated 4/4/12

QB RB FB WR TE OT G C DE RLB DT NT 3-4 DE OLB MLB CB S K P 

Scoring System

100 Once in a decade prospect 
95-99 Elite talent 
90-95 Solid top 10 pick 
85-90 Solid first round pick 
80-85 Late 1st-early 2nd 
75-80 Solid 2nd round pick 
70-75 Solid 3rd round pick 
65-70 3rd-4th round pick 
60-65 4th-5th round pick 
55-60 5th round pick 
50-55 6th round pick 
45-50 7th round pick 
40-45 Undrafted, invite to training camp 
<40 No NFL Future

 

1. Courtney Upshaw (Alabama) 87

2. Melvin Ingram (South Carolina) 86

3. Shea McClellin (Boise State) 81

4. Andre Branch (Clemson) 79

5. Vinny Curry (Marshall) 77                                  

6. Ronnell Lewis (Oklahoma) 73

7. Jonathan Massaquoi (Troy) 66

8. Kyle Wilbur (Wake Forest) 62

9. Bruce Irvin (West Virginia) 61

10. Donte Paige-Moss (North Carolina) 58

11. Cordarro Law (Southern Mississippi) 56

12. Brandon Lindsay (Pittsburgh) 54

13. Olivier Vernon (Miami) 51

14. Tim Fugger (Vanderbilt) 49

15. Miles Burris (San Diego State) 47

 

Rush Linebackers 2011

 

Updated 4/26/11

QB RB FB WR TE OT G C DE RLB DT 3-4 DE NT MLB OLB CB S K P

Scoring System 

100 Once in a decade prospect 
95-99 Elite talent 
90-95 Solid top 10 pick 
85-90 Solid first round pick 
80-85 Late 1st-early 2nd 
75-80 Solid 2nd round pick 
70-75 Solid 3rd round pick 
65-70 3rd-4th round pick 
60-65 4th-5th round pick 
55-60 5th round pick 
50-55 6th round pick 
45-50 7th round pick 
40-45 Undrafted, invite to training camp 
30-40 Career practice squader 
20-30 No NFL future 
0-20 No football future 

 

1. Robert Quinn 95 (North Carolina)

2. Von Miller 93 (Texas A&M)

3. Ryan Kerrigan 90 (Purdue)

4. Akeem Ayers 87 (UCLA)

5. Aldon Smith 87 (Missouri)

6. Justin Houston 85 (Georgia)

7. Brooks Reed 80 (Arizona)

8. Sam Acho 77 (Texas)

9. Dontay Moch 76 (Nevada)

10. Ricky Elmore 74 (Arizona)

11. Jabaal Sheard 71 (Pittsburgh)

12. Chris Carter 70 (Fresno State)

13. Steven Friday 69 (Virginia Tech)

14. Thomas Keiser 64 (Stanford)

15. Bruce Miller 61 (UCF)

16. Cliff Matthews 53 (South Carolina)

17. Rodney Gnat 52 (Louisville)

18. Ugo Chinasa 51 (Oklahoma State)

19. Eddie Jones 49 (Texas)

20. Brian Duncan 44 (Texas Tech)

21. Justin Trattou 42 (Florida)

22. Cheta Ozougwu 42 (Rice)

 

Rush Linebackers

 

QB RB WR TE OT G C NT DT 3-4 DE DE RLB OLB MLB CB S K P

Updated: 4/17/10

100 Once in a decade prospect 

95-99 Elite talent 

90-95 Solid top 10 pick 

85-90 Solid first round pick 

80-85 Late 1st-early 2nd 

75-80 Solid 2nd round pick 

70-75 Solid 3rd round pick 

65-70 3rd-4th round pick 

60-65 4th-5th round pick 

55-60 5th round pick 

50-55 6th round pick 

45-50 7th round pick 

40-45 Undrafted, invite to training camp 

30-40 Career practice squader 

20-30 No NFL future 

0-20 No football future 

 

1. Brandon Graham (Michigan) 87                 

3/1/10: Graham wasn’t expected to run well but a 4.69 40 at 6-1 268 showing some surprisingly athleticism. He also put up 31 reps of 225 pounds.

1/30/10: Graham had a huge Senior Bowl week. It started out bad when he measured up at just over 6 feet and with the shortest arms of any defensive lineman, but he really impressed in practice and even more so in the game. He won Senior Bowl MVP with 2 sacks, 1 forced fumble, a tackle for a loss, and 5 tackles. He was disruptive on almost every play and had more signature plays than any other player. He really hustled and earned a lot of praise from the commentators. He chased down Jarrett Brown, the fastest quarterback on either roster, from behind, something that will only show up on the stat sheet as a tackle. He’s a former linebacker, with an excellent motor and an excellent pass rushing repertoire, but he’s also extremely stout and disruptive against the run. He can play both 4-3 left end and 4-3 right end, in addition to rush linebacker. The commentators compared him to LaMarr Woodley of the Pittsburgh Steelers and I think that comparison is dead on. I think he cemented himself as a 1st round pick. 

1/27/10: Measuring in at just over 6 feet at his weigh in isn’t good, but he’s making scouts forget about his lack of height, with his play at practice this week. He has a very solid base and looks like a legitimate defensive line player in the NFL. His form against the run needs to be improved, but he has shown great speed rushing moves in addition to being one of the best young bull rushers at the Senior Bowl. If he can impress in coverage, he could be a 1st round pick as either a defensive end or rush linebacker.

With 29 sacks in the last 3 years against Big 10 competition, Graham is a pass rushing machine, but despite his size, he isn’t great against the run. He’s best fit as a rush linebacker at the next level and I can’t see him fitting all schemes. His 40 time isn’t great either so he’ll be viewed as a bit of a tweener by the scouts and that could drop him down in the 3rd round. He has first round upside as a rush linebacker though despite his lack of height and timed speed, assuming he can transition to a new position well and hold up in pass coverage

2. Everson Griffen (USC) 85

3/1/10: Griffen put on about 10 pounds this season bulking up to 273 and there were some concerns about how he would carry the weight. After he ran a 4.64 40 today, those concerns should be gone. He also put up 32 reps of 225 pounds.

It’ll be interesting to see what he runs at the combine. He’s rumored to be able to run a 4.5 40, but he also put on 10 pounds of muscle this season so I’m not sure he can still run that fast. If he can, his stock could soar even though he never really did anything of note at USC in 3 seasons. 7 sacks this year after 9 combined in his first two years show good improvement and his run blocking form got a lot better this season with the added weight, but if his 40 time suffers, he may only be looked at as a left end, rather than a right end or rush linebacker. He’s still a major project either way.

3. Jerry Hughes (TCU) 83

26 sacks in the last 2 years for TCU for a guy just learning the defensive end position, after playing running back for most of his football career, is amazing, but he may be maxed out bulk wise at 257 pounds and he doesn’t have ideal height at 6-2. He’s a better fit as a rush linebacker, but he can play on the line some, though he’d be a liability against the run. He has a great motor and has shown plasticity and ability to learn new positions in the past. He also has good hands because he’s played on the offensive side of the ball before, but I’m not sure about his ability in pass coverage.

4. Eric Norwood (South Carolina) 82

He has experience playing standing up at South Carolina, despite being a defensive end, and he has looked dropping back into coverage on occasion as well so those are major pluses for rush linebacker prospects that can be so unpredictable. He also has 30 sacks in his 4 year career at South Carolina and had 7.5 this year, so he’s a good pass rusher as well, though not a great one. He’s versatile and can play 4-3 strong outside linebacker and maybe even some 3-4 middle linebacker. His 40 time for his weight could keep him out of the first round.

5. Jason Pierre Paul (South Florida) 79                         

2/27/10: Weighing in at 6-5 270, JPP looked like an absolute physical freak. I can’t wait until his 40 yard dash. He hasn’t performed on a high level yet, but the upside is certainly there

He’s a junior college legend, but didn’t impress in his first season in Division I with only 6.5 sacks. He’s a really fluid athlete who is comfortable dropping into coverage and he did get into the backfield a lot, though his sacks total was low, so I think he has a good future as a rush linebacker and he does have huge upside, but if he can’t dominate Division I, how can we expect him to the dominate the NFL. He can also play as a 4-3 defensive end, but I think he’s a better fit at rush linebacker.

6. Jermaine Cunningham (Florida) 77                        

2/27/10: As if he wasn’t already my favorite mid round sleeper, Cunningham measured in at 266 pounds today showing that he has the ability to play in the trenches in any 4-3 scheme. This defensive end class gets thin in the mid rounds so Cunningham could be looking at early 3rd late 2nd now.

He doesn’t have amazing athleticism, but he has an amazing motor and that’s really half of the battle. He would fit very well as a rush linebacker or a cover 2 defensive end. I think a lot higher of him than most places do and he’ll probably be drafted in the 4th round at the highest, but he has borderline 2nd round skills. His fundamentals are very sound.

7. Sergio Kindle (Texas) 74

He’s former top 10 pick prospect, but he only managed 6 sacks this year without Brian Orakpo drawing double teams across from him, after having 10 sacks last year. He’s still a highly rated defensive prospect and would make a great rush linebacker with his athleticism and the fact that he already played some outside linebacker in college so he has experience with his hands off the ground and dropping back into coverage. He’s a solid tackler and big hitter as well so he can play some strong outside linebacker in a 4-3.

 

8. Ricky Sapp (Clemson) 73

A low sack total, but a high amount of tackles for losses, so there are indications that can grow into an elite pass rusher. He’s small at 245 pounds, but has experience playing outside linebacker, in addition to defensive end, and didn’t look bad in coverage, so he definitely has a huge upside as a rush linebacker. He can also play some outside linebacker in a 4-3, but he’s mostly a rush linebacker or pass rushing specialist.

9. Austin Lane (Murray State) 66

1/27/10: First he showed up looking great at his weigh in, weighing in at 265 pounds at 6-6, adding a necessary 8-10 pounds to his frame, and to back that up, he’s looked great on the field in practice showing that this small school kid can hang with the big boys. He has the athleticism to play rush linebacker in addition to defensive end.

The level of competition is an issue for him, but he certainly looks the part of an NFL pass rusher. He has a good refined repertoire of passing moves, but he lacks elite size and doesn’t have very fluid hips. It’ll be interesting to see whether or not he projects as a rush linebacker at the next level because he’s a little small for the trenches in the NFL.  

10. Willie Young (NC State) 66

He had eight sacks this season and has good long arms and athleticism, but at his size, 250 pounds, he’s probably only a nickel rusher in 4-3 systems, so he’ll have to try to convert to rush linebacker and I’m not yet convinced he can. He’s poor against the run, even for his size and his 40 time (4.68-4.72) isn’t going to blow anyone out of the water. 

11. Jason Worilds (Virginia Tech) 64

3/20/10: I rarely care when a player runs a faster 40 at his Pro Day than his Combine, but Worilds’ 4.47 makes me take notice. He ran a very solid 4.61 at his Combine, but a 4.47 at 6-1 254 puts him on a completely different level. He didn’t do much last year, but he has experience playing rush linebacker and has amazing athleticism. His athleticism is right behind that of Jason Pierre Paul and Sergio Kindle and his production was only slightly less than either of theres. He could sneak into the 2nd round, but, like Kindle and JPP, I have him ranked lower than he could go because I like to see a player actually produce on the college level before I use a pick in the first 3 rounds on him.

Very athletic, but lacked the production to match last year with only 4 sacks, though he did have 8 sacks in 2008. He has upside and the athleticism to play rush linebacker, but he’s a project and he could be a nickel rusher as well.

11. Koa Misi (Utah) 63

1/27/10: Believe it or not, Misi played defensive end at Utah. You wouldn’t know it from looking at him play linebacker this week in Mobile. He has shown great fluidity in pass coverage and looked like a natural linebacker. He’s also making a lot of nice hits. That definitely helps his stock as he doesn’t have the size to play in the trenches in the NFL.

He’s an undersized defensive end with a strong motor to make up for it, but he looked like a natural outside linebacker playing that position in the Senior Bowl. He’s a risk because he has to play rush linebacker, a position he didn’t play in college, but I love his motor and I think he could be a solid rush linebacker in the future.

13. Daniel Te’o-Nesheim (Washington) 58

An unknown pass rusher with an unpronounceable name, who has quietly put up 18 sacks over the last 2 years against some good Pac 10 competition. He was a little small before the combine, but bulked up and still managed to shave some time off of his projected time. The elite natural athleticism is not there, but he has the work ethic and the on the field motor to make up for it. He should have a future in the NFL as either a defensive end or a rush linebacker.

14. Lindsey Witten (Connecticut) 56

Started off 2009, with a bang, but ended quietly. He lacks the size to be an every down trench rusher at the next level and the tape is really inconsistent on him. There is some upside here, but not a ton. 

15. Thaddeus Gibson (Ohio State) 56

A very raw and unrefined pass rusher, he got into the backfield a lot last year, but only had 4.5 sacks to show for it and he’s severely undersized at just a few ounces above 240 so he’ll have to make the dreaded position switch to rush linebacker from down lineman, which could be dangerous for him because he’s never played anything remotely like the position. The athleticism and fluidity are there though for him to be a decent rush linebacker if he puts it all together.

16. Brandon Lang (Troy) 55

He’s undersized pass rusher who ran in the 4.9s at the Combine so he may have trouble getting drafted in the first 4 rounds as a future starting type defensive end. He could be a decent nickel rusher in the future, because his 17.5 sacks in the last 2 years are fairly impressive, but the lack of speed and weaker competition makes that less likely. I think it’s safe to say that he won’t be as good as Troy’s last elite pass rusher, DeMarcus Ware.

17. Brandon Sharpe (Texas Tech) 53

18. Antonio Coleman (Auburn) 53

19. George Selvie (South Florida) 52

20. Cameron Sheffield (Troy) 52 

21. Adrian Tracy (William and Mary) 51

22. Dane Fletcher (Montana State) 49

23. Kevin Basped (Nevada) 47

24. Danny Batten (South Dakota State) 46

25. O’Brien Schofield (Wisconsin) 45

26. Chris McCoy (Middle Tennessee State) 45

27. Jarvis Geathers (Central Florida) 41

 

Rush Linebacker Bust

 

Rush linebacker is the position on a 3-4 defense that is most normally responsible for rushing the passer, hence its name. The rush linebacker lines up fairly close to the line of scrimmage, but not on the line of scrimmage, and also far more to the outside than a defensive end, about halfway between the 4-3 defensive end position and the nickelback position. They play standing up, meaning they do not start the play with their hand on the line of scrimmage. They aren’t required to do as much physical run stuffing as 3-4 defensive ends, but they are required to drop back into coverage a lot more. Part of the mystique of the 3-4 defense is the rush linebacker position because offensive players and coordinators simply don’t know if a rush linebacker is going to rush the quarterback or drop back into coverage. Based off that description, the position seems like an ideal position for those smaller college defensive ends that would struggle in the trenches in the NFL. Those smaller ends normally have the fluid athleticism needed to drop back into coverage and the speed to cover and also a set of smooth pass rushing moves to penetrate the backfield from an outside position. So, you’d think with so many teams switching to 3-4 defenses in recent years, smaller defensive ends would be getting excited knowing that there is a position for them in the NFL. Well, as recent history has shown that is not the case. The case has been that, because the rush linebacker position pretty much does not exist in the college game, players have had a hard time transitioning to the rush linebacker position in recent years. In fact, you have to go back to the 2005 draft to find a defensive end that was able to transition to the rush linebacker position with good success (DeMarcus Ware and Shawne Merriman).

Kamerion Wimbley

Wimbley came into the league at 245 pounds so he could not play the defensive end position in the NFL, as he had in college, but with a solid 4.67 40 time, the Browns believed he could make the transition to the 3-4 rush linebacker in Romeo Crennel’s defense and for a while they were right. In his first year in the league, Wimbley had 11 sacks, most among rookies and put himself into consideration for Rookie of the Year. However, in order for me to consider him a success at the position, he would have had to sustain that success and he hasn’t. In the 3 years since, Wimbley has a grand total of 15.5. Not bad, but not great. He wasn’t a complete failure as a rush linebacker, at least not compared to some other rush linebackers.

Manny Lawson

Lawson was 241 pounds when he weighed in at the combine, but with his amazing 4.43 40 time, teams quickly forget about that and viewed him as an elite future rush linebacker. Mike Nolan of the San Francisco 49ers pulled the trigger on him with the 22nd pick in 2006. However, Lawson proved quickly to be a bust. Lawson managed 8 sacks through the first three and a half years of his career. He did show some signs of hope late last season with 4 sacks in the Niners last 8 games giving him 6.5 for the season, most on the team, but its safe to say he hasn’t been worth the 22nd overall pick.

Vernon Gholston

Nowhere is there a better example for this article than Gholston. Gholston was a safe pick in 2008. At 266 pounds he could have played defensive end and given his 14.5 sacks as a defensive end in his final year at Ohio State, he probably could have played the position well. He fell to the Jets at 6 in 2008 and since he had top 5 talent and the Jets desperately needed a pass rusher, the Jets took him at 6 and tried to fit him into their 3-4 scheme as a rush linebacker. It was a reasonable decision given his 4.58 40 time at the combine, but in the two years since being drafted, Gholston has not had a single sack and could be cut this offseason.

Larry English

(did not play enough as a rookie for me to use him in this article)

Clay Matthews

Clay Matthews is the one success story with 10 sacks in his rookie year after being drafted 26th overall. Why did he succeed? He played linebacker at USC. Though USC does not use a true rush linebacker position, they do blitz their strong side linebacker very often and Matthews was that guy. He was essentially playing a 4-3 rush linebacker position at USC and that wouldn’t be as hard to transition from as a 4-3 end position.

I know there isn’t a large statistical sample to use here, since the rush linebacker position is a very modern position that has not been around long, but what has happened to Wimbley, Lawson, and Gholston is a bit startling. Because of that, it would make me at least think twice before drafting a guy like Jerry Hughes or Jason Pierre Paul to play rush linebacker in the first. Instead I would wait until the 2nd or the 3rd round to take a guy like Ricky Sapp, Eric Norwood, or Sergio Kindle who have experience playing the outside linebacker position in college in addition to defensive end. Brandon Graham could be safe too because he played some linebacker in high school, though guys who played some linebacker in college seem to be the safe way to go.