Gabe Carimi Scot

Offensive Tackle/Guard

Wisconsin

6-7 314

Draft Board Overall Prospect Rank: #24

Draft Board Overall Offensive Tackle Rank: #3

Rating: 83 (Late 1st)

40 time: 5.12

2/19/11: Gabe Carimi might be the best pure right tackle prospect to come out in a while. He’s not athletic enough or quick enough to play left tackle and be matched up with the opponent’s best pass rusher every week, but what he does well is run block and he does it extremely well. In a way, he’s like a run blocking savant.

He doesn’t quite have the same measurable as Willie Colon, who measures in at 6-3 rather than Carimi’s 6-7, but they are very similar players. Colon gives up 6-8 sacks per year as a right tackle, but he’s so good as a run blocker that you deal with it. Colon is probably the best pure run blocker in the league and Carimi was the best pure run blocker in college football last year, for Wisconsin, whose strong line and running game allowed them to dominate the Big 10.

He overpowers everyone and plays with amazing leverage despite the tall frame. Most elite run blockers are 6-3, 6-4, while Carimi is 6-7. He has a strong lower body though and uses that to get great leverage, the way Jon Runyan, who was perennially the best right tackle in the league, when he was with the Eagles, before retiring (and becoming elected to congress as a republican from New Jersey). Runyan also was 6-7.

Carimi could also move inside to guard, but his value is as a right tackle, where he won’t be overwhelmed with the opponent’s best pass rusher every week, but can still focus on doing the most damage possible as a run blocker. He should get drafted in the late first, where teams like the Eagles, Ravens, Seahawks, Patriots, Bears, Steelers, Falcons and Saints all need offensive line help, but are good enough to use a first rounder on a luxury pick, which is what a right tackle really is.

NFL Comparison: Jon Runyan

 

Guards

QB RB WR TE OT G C NT DT 3-4 DE DE RLB OLB MLB CB S K P

Updated 4/17/10 

100 Once in a decade prospect 

95-99 Elite talent 

90-95 Solid top 10 pick 

85-90 Solid first round pick 

80-85 Late 1st-early 2nd 

75-80 Solid 2nd round pick 

70-75 Solid 3rd round pick 

65-70 3rd-4th round pick 

60-65 4th-5th round pick 

55-60 5th round pick 

50-55 6th round pick 

45-50 7th round pick 

40-45 Undrafted, invite to training camp 

30-40 Career practice squader 

20-30 No NFL future 

0-20 No football future 

 

1. Mike Iupati (Idaho) 83                              

1/27/10: Unlike Ducasse, this much hyped offensive lineman has really lived up to the hype. He is destroying guys one on one and is making a huge case to be a first round pick lock, which is rare for a guard.

A massive offensive guard with the possible ability to kick out to right tackle if he needs to. He completely dominated defensive lineman one on one this season, though he didn’t have the toughest competition, and moves extremely well for his size. We’ll all get a good look at him and the hype that surrounds him at the Senior Bowl next week. He’s already drawing premature comparisons to by far the best guard of the last 20 years, Larry Allen.

2. Mike Johnson (Alabama) 78

He probably wouldn’t be a top 10 tackle without his ability to play guard, but he’s an amazing run blocker. He blocked for Glen Coffee in 2008 and Mark Ingram in 2009. He’s not a big mauling run blocker, but his technique is amazing and he should be drafted in the 2nd or maybe 3rd round as a right tackle or right guard.

3. John Jerry (Mississippi) 74

Is he going to have problems against the pass, sure, but he projects well as a right guard at the next level and is a really tough matchup inside at 345 pounds. His older brother, Peria, is already in the NFL, a defensive tackle with the Atlanta Falcons who was drafted in the 1st round last year.

4. Vladimir Ducasse (Massachusetts) 73

1/27/10: This small school kid with excellent size had a lot of hype surrounding him coming into the week and he has not lived up to it. He has looked like 5 steps slower than every defensive lineman has had been guarding. He’s really having trouble with tougher competition. He’s probably only a guard at the next level rather than a right tackle as some had envisioned him. 

Another big man from a small school, Ducasse is 340 pounds of mean. He didn’t have the toughest competition, but he’ll get his chance to show himself at the Senior Bowl as well. He has the ability to play both right guard and right tackle, but it’ll be interesting to see if he projects as a right tackle longterm because he’s a step or two slower than the average right tackle. 

5. Maurkice Pouncey (Florida) 69

By far the most versatile guard on here, he has the ability to play both guard positions, and center, which he played last year. He could also play right tackle and he has great athletic upside, though he didn’t quite tap into all of that in his time at Florida.

6. Jon Asamoah (Illinois) 67

The best pure zone guard in this draft class, and he has the versatility to play both guard slots. He moves well for his size, but isn’t overpowering. He could run the fastest 40 of all guard prospects which means he could be a Raider next year.

7. Mitch Petrus (Arkansas) 65                       

2/25/10: He benched 225 pounds 45 times. That doesn’t equate to football success necessarily, but it certainly helps. 

He’s been suspended before for academic reasons, but he’s also the same monster blocker that was getting National hype as a sophomore blocking for Felix Jones and Darren McFadden. If scouts can look past his character issues and his weaknesses against the pass, he’ll be drafted in the 4th round as a right guard.

 

8. Sergio Render (Virginia Tech) 64

A former elite guard prospect who falls back quite a bit this year after struggling a bit. He’s still worth a mid round prospect because he’s a great athlete who uses his hands well, but his leverage needs work

9. Jeff Byers (USC) 59

1/30/10: He’s undersized, but with great form he really held his own against much bigger defensive lineman. He played at center for most of the game, which is not his natural position, but he did a great overall job, which is very good because, due to his small frame, that’s likely the position he’ll have to play at the next level. 

A former elite guard prospect who would be a perfect fit for a zone blocking scheme. He only weighs 290 pounds so he won’t fit all schemes and he has a nasty history of injuries, but if he fulfills his potential, he could be the best pure left guard in this draft class. He needs to bulk up though, even to play a zone scheme.

10. Brandon Carter (Texas Tech) 58

3/15/10: This is what I like to see. Ran a poor 5.36 at his Combine, so he lost 10 pounds and then ran a 5.24. A 5.24 at 6-6 319 isn’t overly impressive, and for an offensive lineman 40 times barely matter, but I love the dedication and commitment to football.

By far the craziest guard in the draft class. If it were legal, he’d probably bite off a defensive linemen’s head. He’s a huge run blocker, but I have some concerns about how he’ll transition to a real blocking scheme in the NFL and about his pass blocking and mobility, which he really lacks.

11. Thomas Austin (Clemson) 56

A bit of an unknown who burst onto the scene as a senior this year, but he’s got good versatility and an excellent knack for the fundamentals so he could be drafted as a depth guy at worst.

12. Joe Thomas (Pittsburgh) 54

A very solid and versatile depth guy whose motor I love. He doesn’t have a ton of upside and he’s not a huge name guy, but every time I’ve seen him, he’s made NFL caliber blocks. Size is an issue though.

13. Cord Howard (Georgia) 51

An All-ACC first teamer this year as a guard after making the 2nd team last year, Howard is a very solid all around guard, but nothing really leaps off the page when you watch him.

14. Marshall Newhouse (TCU) 49

An athletic freak with a 5.00 40 at 6-4 319, which means he’ll be on the Raiders’ radar, but I have some concerns about his leverage and technique. Level of competition was also a concern for him.

15. Matt Stephens (Richmond) 45

One of Division I-AA’s best offensive linemen, never missed a start and opened up a ton of holes for Richmond’s elite running game. Level of competition is obviously an issue, but this guy was one of the best at what he did for the last 4 years and deserves a shot at the next level. 

16. Reggie Stephens (Iowa State) 44

17. Shelley Smith (Colorado State) 43

18. Shawn Lauvao (Arizona State) 42

19. Andrew Lewis (Oklahoma State) 41

Jamal Williams Broncos

Good to see the Broncos are actually focusing on needs this offseason. They were awful against the run last year and their lack of a true nose tackle had a lot to do with that. Williams has his flaws; that’s why the Chargers cut him. He’s 34 and coming off of a major injury, but with so few nose tackles on the market and in the draft, they almost needed to sign him. He should be a nice 2 year stop gap and 16 million over 3 years isn’t a ton to pay for a 2 year stopgap at one of the most important positions on a 3-4 defense. They could still draft a nose tackle this year if one falls to them, but they no longer are tied to the position and have to make a reach. They can instead focus on filling other front 7 needs and getting some help at receiver.

Grade: B+

Jermaine Cunningham

 

Defense End/Rush Linebacker

Florida

6-3 266

40 time (projected): 4.69

Draft board overall prospect rank: #57

Draft board defensive end rank: #7

Overall rating: 77*

1/21/10: He doesn’t have amazing athleticism, but he has an amazing motor and that’s really half of the battle. He would fit very well as a rush linebacker or a cover 2 defensive end. I think a lot higher of him than most places do and he’ll probably be drafted in the 4th round at the highest, but he has borderline 2nd round skills. His fundamentals are very sound.

12/12/09: Scrappy is a word used most with baseball and basketball players, but Jermaine Cunningham is a scrappy football player.

            11/27/09: Jermaine Cunningham is one of my favorite underrated college football players. He was a big time recruit out of High School and picked the University of Florida, where he has yet to establish major statistical success. He doesn’t have great measurable size or measurable speed, but I have been extremely impressed with him when I have watched him. He hustles every single play and has a great heart. He’s a great leader on the football field and though his sacks totals aren’t extremely high, they are consistently above average. He’s often in the backfield and uses his hands very well. He breaks up passes and also has an interception which leads me to believe that he’ll be a very good rush linebacker in the NFL, which would negate his lack of elite size and allow him to display his full range of speed rushing moves. He also uses his hands in the trenches on passing plays to negate his lack of size. He pushes off of offensive linemen very well and he has very long arms which makes him tough to block. He is a sound tackler and is not easily broken because his arms are both long and strong and he wraps up properly. He hits hard as well and has a good number of forced fumbles especially for his size. He’s an extremely smart player as well. The major knock on him is obviously his size. He can be driven off of the line quickly and though he never gives up on a play and is constantly trying to break blocks, that will hurt him in the NFL. However, if he moves to rush linebacker, that won’t be an issue. He also fits extremely well as a cover 2 defensive end because he has a good repertoire of speed rushing moves, he plays faster than he times, and because of his great uses of his hands and his arms. He was arrested in December 2007 for an altercation in a sandwich shop, but as bad as that sounds, that seems to be a one time isolated incident, and thus somewhat excusable for an NFL prospect (I said lettuce, dammit!). His character on the field with his hustle and his willingness to play through injuries, played the entire 2008 season through a hyper extended knee which also could be to blame for less than excellent production that year, makes up for that incident. He is a small guy, but uses everything he has to get the job done and he’s a consistent senior with 3 strong college seasons. He’ll make a good rush linebacker or cover 2 defensive end in the NFL, but might not be drafted, because of his lack of elite production, elite size, or an elite 40 time, until the 4th round.

NFL Comparison: Alex Brown

Jim Harbaugh

By Michael J Morris

Jim Harbaugh has agreed to a five-year, $25 million contract to become the newest head coach of the San Francisco 49ers.

This news coming out the day after the consensus No. 1 pick, Andrew Luck, decided to return to school. Once that news came out, some, including myself, expected Harbaugh to follow suit. 

It was reported that Denver, Miami, and San Francisco were the NFL teams in contention, but as days passed during the week, Denver and Miami bowed out. 

The jump from the NCAA to the NFL won’t be too much of a leap for he and his family, as he will be able to stay close to he and his family. A job in Denver or Miami would have meant a relocation of home-base for him and his family.

Harbaugh has no NFL experience as a coach, but went 58-27 overall as a college coach and 29-21 in four seasons at Stanford.  Harbaugh took over as head coach for Standford in December 2006 and flipped the switch for the school. 

Harbaugh was a college star at Michigan but bounced around the NFL as a player in his 15 seasons, playing for the Bears, Colts, Chargers, Panthers, and Ravens. He was a first-round draft pick taken 26th overall by Chicago in 1987, Harbaugh passed for 26,288 yards in his career and completed 129 touchdowns. 

The quarterback position is what will, as it did for Singletary, determine whether or not Harbaugh will see his contract all the way through. If the 49ers continue to play with mediocre pieces behind center, this team will continue changing coaches as often as one would change their oil.

Go back to 49ers Fan Spot 

http://michaeljmorris.wordpress.com/ 

 

Julius Peppers Bears

 

Julius Peppers was the class of the 2010 NFL Free Agency class with 81 sacks in 8 years. I get that. However, the Bears are making a huge investment here giving him 6 years 91 million dollars. That will take him until he’s 35 years old. That’s an awful lot of money to pay someone who will be that old at the end of his deal, especially when you consider that Peppers actually has a few issues with work ethic and motor and does take a few games off. This move will help the Bears in the short term, but I’d say there’s a 70% chance that Peppers doesn’t live this deal out in Chicago.

Grade: B-

 

Kickers 2011

 

Updated 4/9/11

QB RB FB WR TE OT G C DE RLB DT 3-4 DE NT MLB OLB CB S K P

Scoring System 

100 Once in a decade prospect 
95-99 Elite talent 
90-95 Solid top 10 pick 
85-90 Solid first round pick 
80-85 Late 1st-early 2nd 
75-80 Solid 2nd round pick 
70-75 Solid 3rd round pick 
65-70 3rd-4th round pick 
60-65 4th-5th round pick 
55-60 5th round pick 
50-55 6th round pick 
45-50 7th round pick 
40-45 Undrafted, invite to training camp 
30-40 Career practice squader 
20-30 No NFL future 
0-20 No football future 

 

1. Alex Henery 52 (Nebraska)

2. Josh Jasper 49 (LSU)

3. Kai Forbath 47 (UCLA)

4. Thomas Weber 44 (Arizona State)

5. Wes Bryum 41 (Auburn)

 

 

 

Linebackers 2012

 

Average total drafted in last 5 years: 28.8

1. Luke Kuechly (Boston College) Top 15

2. Dont’a Hightower (Alabama) 1

3. Lavonte David (Nebraska) 2

4. Mychal Kendricks (California) 2

5. Zach Brown (North Carolina) 2

6. Bobby Wagner (Utah State) 2-3

7. Sean Spence (Miami) 3-4

8. Nigel Bradham (Florida State) 3-4

9. Bruce Irvin (West Virginia) 4-5

10. Josh Kaddu (Oregon) 4-5

11. Terrell Manning (NC State) 4-5

12. Keenan Robinson (Texas) 4-5

13. Kyle Wilbur (Wake Forest) 4-5

14. Demario Davis (Arkansas State) 4-5

15. Tank Carder (TCU) 4-5

16. Travis Lewis (Oklahoma) 5-6

17. Emmanuel Acho (Texas) 5-6

18. James-Michael Johnson (Nevada) 5-6

19. Audie Cole (NC State) 5-6

20. Vontaze Burfict (Arizona State) 5-6

21. Chris Galippo (USC) 6-7

22. Alex Hoffman-Ellis (Washington State) 6-7

23. Najee Goode (West Virginia) 6-7

24. Miles Burris (San Diego State) 6-7

25. Danny Trevathan (Kentucky) 6-7

26. Tyler Nielsen (Iowa) 6-7

27. Jerry Franklin (Arkansas) 7-U

28. Caleb McSurdy (Montana) 7-U

29. Tahir Whitehead (Temple) 7-U

30. Darius Fleming (Notre Dame) 7-U

31. DJ Holt (California) 7-U

32. Cameron Collins (Oregon State) 7-U

33. Ryan Baker (LSU) 7-U

34. Shawn Loiseau (Merrimack) 7-U

35. Marcus Dowtin (North Alabama) 7-U

 

Marion Barber Bears

 

This is only 5 million over 2 years, but Barber is done so it doesn’t matter. Lingering hamstring injuries have sapped his explosiveness and caused him to average 3.3 yards per carry last year, though I guess that’s better than the 2.4 Chester Taylor averaged, so I guess they upgraded the #2 back position.

Grade: C

 

Miami/Virginia Tech

Spotlight #1: Virginia Tech CB Jayron Hosley 

Spotlight #2: Miami OLB Sean Spence 

1st quarter

14:55: Jayron Hosley blankets a short curl route.

14:09: Miami quarterback looks Hosley’s way, nothing open, keeps it for a small gain.

13:23: Hosley outmuscled on a run play by a blocking receiver.

12:46: Hosley finishes off a receiver with a tackle after a big catch. The receiver was not Hosley’s responsibility.

6:05: Virginia Tech senior receiver Jarrett Boykin with his 3rd catch of the game. He’s Virginia Tech’s all time leading receiver and having a nice game so far.

5:48: Spence fills a gap well, great vision and speed, combines for tackle for loss of 5, not a strong tackle though, needed help.

2:17: Hosley in a zone, reads quarterback’s eyes, jumps the route, almost picks it off, but drops it. It went right through his hands. Excellent job to make a play on the ball, but he needs to come up with that.

2:06: Hosley with a nice 18 yard punt return, shifty in the open field.

1:02: On a pass play, Spence drops into coverage, comes back to ball after quarterback decides to run with it and puts a big hit on a bigger quarterback. Logan Thomas, Virginia Tech’s quarterback, is a 6-6 245 former tight end, whereas Spencer is undersized at 6-0 225, but you have to like the instincts, hustle and fearlessness on this play.

0:36: Spence in on another tackle.

2nd quarter

7:42: Spence with great closing speed, angle, and vision on a tackle either for a loss or no gain, it was close.

6:31: Hosley in on a tackle near the line of a bigger back, not a strong tackle, but a solid effort.

4:03: Hosley’s side targeted, very inaccurate, closer to him than any receiver, but still far out of his reach. Nice effort to try for the pick anyway.

2:10: Spence looks very smooth dropping into coverage, he has all night.

1:51: Spence with nice hustle, as soon as the ball is in the air, he hustles over to the area of the receiver, even though it’s not his responsibility. Still a completion, but a nice effort, excellent motor.

1:43: Spence on a sideline tackle.

1:14: Spence around the ball all night, fights off blocks, big hit, very impressive player. He didn’t look 6-0 225 on that play.

 

3rd quarter

13:27: Spence drops into coverage and there’s a fumble recovered by an offensive lineman. Spence does an excellent job to come back to the ball and make the tackle on an offensive lineman who probably has about 80-90 pounds on him. Fearless, great instincts once again.

12:47: Spence does a great job in coverage tackling a ball carrier on a screen for a loss.

11:10: Kyle Fuller with a tackle on a run. Fuller is Virginia Tech’s “other” cornerback and he’s had several impressive plays tonight, especially against the run. Fuller is only a sophomore and could be a high pick in 2013 or 2014.

9:01: Spence in on another tackle, great angle to ball.

7:01: Spence muscled off a run play with good run blocking.

5:42: Spence blocked inside early, disengages, bounces to the outside and chases down the ball carrier from behind.

2:42: Hosley is timid on a run play.

0:34: Hosley has a pass completed in his area and is content to let the other 2 guys tackle, not willing to stick his nose in there to make sure he’s down.

4th quarter

14:23: Hosley again won’t stick his nose in on a running play, jumps over a guy trying to bring a ball carrier down. He needs to be in there to support his teammate. Terrible effort and hustle.

13:35: Hosley against a 6-5 receiver, can’t defend the fade in the end zone. Nothing he can do there at 5-10 175.

13:05: Jarrett Boykin with a 60 yard touchdown. He’s having a huge game, abusing Miami’s young secondary.

11:50: Hosley with an absolutely dreadful effort on a tackle of a ball carrier on a long run, could have stopped it 10-15 yards earlier.

9:14: Hosley in on a tackle on a long run again, weak tackle, but Miami’s Lamar Miller, the ball carrier, is tough to bring down. Miller, a redshirt sophomore, is on fire now after getting just 6 carries in the first half.

8:08: Spence pancaked. His lack of size was noticeable there.

6:14: Spence locks down underneath man, forces quarterback to flush the pocket past the line of scrimmage and then just a boneheaded decision by Logan Thomas with an illegal forward pass.

5:55: Hosley disengages from wide receiver, gets a tackle on Lamar Miller, not the strongest tackle, but better than his other ones. Again Lamar Miller is tough to bring down.

5:23: Kyle Fuller with a huge big play saving tackle on the running back. He’s just a sophomore, but he’s been Hosley’s antithesis tonight. He’ll be worth a look in a year or two.

2:54: Hosley poor angle on a long run for touchdown. He could have stopped the touchdown had he filled the gap instead of whatever he decided to do. 34-31 Miami now late. If Virginia Tech loses, this play is why. Lazy. Poor motor.

1:43: Spence pancaked again, unfortunately.

1:37: Spence in on a tackle on a quarterback keeper near the line.

0:30: Hosley allows short catch and then a nice force out of bounds, smart prevent play to avoid big play up 3 under 30 seconds left.

0:00: Jayron Hosley definitely showed his ball hawking abilities on a near pick, though I would have preferred him to come down with the ball. He also was rarely thrown on and when he was, he played well, with the exception of the fade in the end zone. There wasn’t much he could have done there against someone with 7 inches on him, but that’s to be expected of a 5-10 cornerback.

What was particularly bad was his piss poor effort in run stuffing. I know he’s small at 5-10 175, but not only is he a poor tackler, he gives poor effort. I’m not expecting him to tackle like a 6-2 225 pound safety, but give some effort. He’s very timid and lazy against the run and I think it’s a sign of immaturity. I know they won, but if they don’t get that last touchdown, they lose and the reason why is because Hosley gave no effort to fill a gap on a long run. It’s like he doesn’t understand the importance. I know Virginia Tech’s defensive line needed to play better and I know Lamar Miller is a tough man to bring down, but Hosley is largely at fault for Miller’s huge day on the ground.

All in all, I compare Hosley to DeAngelo Hall. I hate comparing players to other players who came from the same school, but Frank Beamer likes a particularly kind of defensive back and Hosley and Hall fit that to a tee. Hosley is going to give up a few big plays, but he’s also going to make a few big plays in coverage, particularly interceptions. He’s great at jumping routes, but he often goes for the big play instead of making the sure, safe play. He’s also terrible and lazy in run defense, like Hall. Also like Hall, he’s a bit undersized, 5-10 175, Hall was around 5-10 185 coming out of Virginia Tech.

As for Miller, this was my 2nd game watching him (Ohio State), but I haven’t spotlighted him yet. He’s a redshirt sophomore, but I may have to spotlight him just in case. I think he’s the 3rd best runner in college football after Marcus Lattimore and Trent Richardson, 2nd among draft eligible running backs. He could go somewhere around where Ryan Williams went last year as a redshirt sophomore after Mark Ingram went in the first (Williams went early 2nd).

Despite getting only 6 carries in the first half, Miller rushed for 166 yards and a score on 18 carries. Miami’s comeback coincided with Miami giving Miller the ball more as he scored twice in the 2nd half, once through the air, once on the ground, and he picked up big chunks of yardage on almost every play totaling 189 yards on 21 total touches. On the season, he has 677 yards and 5 scores on 94 carries in 5 games, along with 9 receptions for another 35 and another score.

Sean Spence was the opposite of Jayron Hosley tonight. He was fearless, relentless, high motor, high effort, all around the ball, someone I’d want to have on my team. He didn’t look like a 6-0 225 pound linebacker, with a few exceptions. He officially had 12 tackles in the game, but it seemed like he had a tackle on every other play. Official scorers often are wrong with tackle totals, on the side of crediting the defender with too few.

He also looked awesome in coverage, a bust for a 6-0 225 pound linebacker who might end up at safety at the next level. I’d keep him at linebacker because he does so well there now, at least at first, but his motor, instincts, and fearlessness are going to be an asset at whatever position he plays, even if it’s special teams. He got pancaked on a few plays, but he didn’t have a tackle broken all game. What he lacks in strength, he makes up for in technique in tackling and of course, his heart.

I would have no problem drafting this kid as a 4-3 linebacker (inside/outside, he lined up at both) in the 2nd round of the 2012 NFL Draft, provided I needed a linebacker. I said similar things about Casey Matthews out of Oregon last year (6-1 230). I gave him a 2nd round grade and when the Eagles took him in the 4th, it was considered a reach. However, he’s already a starter for them and doing a very good job as a rookie. Spence can be a similar player. I compare him more to Sean Weatherspoon (Spoon is a little bigger), but he has some of Matthews in him too.